POLL 1st Team NHL goalie of the decade

[KennyBanyeah]

As the decade closes let's vote in our all NHL teams. Let's not go full Flyers/Senators and start from the net out building our team.

 

[Judge Fudge]

Now....

Gosh. Hard choices. I'm not a huge MAF fan but you can't disagree with what he has done over the past 10 years. Quick is a hard second.

 

[KennyBanyeah]

Now....

Gosh. Hard choices. I'm not a huge MAF fan but you can't disagree with what he has done over the past 10 years. Quick is a hard second.

If it goes well we'll do second and third teams as well.

 

[BGDave]

What helped me narrow the list down for this and for the Dmen was to ask myself "Will they be in the HOF?"

That helped to shorten the list.

But really really tough.

 

[thedddd]

Hard to pick against MAF who has been to 5 finals but as a starter, he is only 1-2.

Edit: He is really 0-1 in this decade as a starter.

 

[Bloody Brian Burke]

Hank was consistently good, took some pretty average teams deep into the playoffs on multiple occasions, is handsome. Easy win and likely deserved more than one Vezina.

People taking MAF gonna have to explain to me why him over Rask. Rask had the best sv% of anyone starting 450 or more games since 2009-10 & made 2 Final runs to MAF's 1.25.

 

[KennyBanyeah]

Hank was consistently good, took some pretty average teams deep into the playoffs on multiple occasions, is handsome. Easy win and likely deserved more than one Vezina.

People taking MAF gonna have to explain to me why him over Rask. Rask had the best sv% of anyone starting 450 or more games since 2009-10 & made 2 Final runs to MAF's 1.25.

I was on the fence between Rask and King Henrik.

Went with Henrik for durability and lack of support.

 

[Bloody Brian Burke]

I was on the fence between Rask and King Henrik.

Went with Henrik for durability and lack of support.

Likewise. Had Rask won one of those finals series I'd hand it to him.

 

[thedddd]

Hank was consistently good, took some pretty average teams deep into the playoffs on multiple occasions, is handsome. Easy win and likely deserved more than one Vezina.

People taking MAF gonna have to explain to me why him over Rask. Rask had the best sv% of anyone starting 450 or more games since 2009-10 & made 2 Final runs to MAF's 1.25.

I stated hard to pick against him but honestly I didn't pick him.
Went with Price and it was between him and Lundqvist and Price won the coin toss.

 

[forty_three]

I stated hard to pick against him but honestly I didn't pick him.
Went with Price and it was between him and Lundqvist and Price won the coin toss.

Rask, Hank and Price are the clear top to me, and I went with Price for one reason.

He is now the franchise wins leader in a franchise that has had Roy, Dryden, and Plante. That is one hell of an accomplishment.

 

[Bloody Brian Burke]

Rask, Hank and Price are the clear top to me, and I went with Price for one reason.

He is now the franchise wins leader in a franchise that has had Roy, Dryden, and Plante. That is one hell of an accomplishment.

The Habs have been god-awful all decade and Price is literally the only reason they've ever made the playoffs in that span. Pull him from the equation and they're literally the pre-Matthews Leafs. He deserves a shit ton of credit.

But they only had that one playoff run with him. Not his fault, of course, but like Kenny said Hank also had some terrible support and in 4 postseasons from 2012-2015 he won 6/10 playoff rounds and was unbelievably clutch in knockout games. In comparison, Price won 5 rounds all decade.

 

[DevilishWon]

Broduer better in half a decade than the others in a full one.

!!!

 

[mooger_35]

Broduer better in half a decade than the others in a full one.

!!!

It was the 7 games with St. Louis that put him over the top for you wasn’t it?

 

[forty_three]

It was the 7 games with St. Louis that put him over the top for you wasn’t it?

No, the Enterprise commercials.

 

[esls79]

Can I write in Patty Wah for his coaching debut against Bruce Boudreau?

 

[elocomotive]

People are voting for MAF? LMAFO! Cam Talbot and Devan Dubnyk have better save percentages this decade while playing for far worse teams during that time. MAF is one of the worst puck handlers of all time.

Fleury got on the right teams at the right time and he's certainly a competent goaltender, but best of the decade? C'mon, man...


This guy?

This guy?!?

THIS fucking guy?!?!?!?

 

[DevilishWon]

There's a deli in Newark that has a lot of specialty sandwiches and entrees named after Devils players. The only Ranger with a dish named after him is Lundquist. I's called King Henrik's soup, but you can only get it in bowls....NO CUPS..ouch

 

[thedddd]

People are voting for MAF? LMAFO! Cam Talbot and Devan Dubnyk have better save percentages this decade while playing for far worse teams during that time. MAF is one of the worst puck handlers of all time.

Fleury got on the right teams at the right time and he's certainly a competent goaltender, but best of the decade? C'mon, man...


This guy?

This guy?!?

THIS fucking guy?!?!?!?

The beachball series alone put him over the top as the clear cut best.