- Thread starter
- #1
Mike A. S.
Well-Known Member
Now that we've had time for everything to settle in. Who should've been in the College Football Playoff? Obviously 'Bama and Clemson are no-doubters. I think even Washington was pretty clearly deserving. I think the real debate comes down to Ohio State and Penn State.
I know an additional loss is big in college football. But since the playoff they haven't been as important. And since they were in the same division and Penn State won it, and won the same conference and beat Ohio State head to head then I think that at least makes it extremely close. I'm not totally sure myself which one deserves it more. But I think being conference champion should matter and supposedly that was what put Ohio State in over TCU & Baylor two years ago, so why didn't it matter this time?
I know an additional loss is big in college football. But since the playoff they haven't been as important. And since they were in the same division and Penn State won it, and won the same conference and beat Ohio State head to head then I think that at least makes it extremely close. I'm not totally sure myself which one deserves it more. But I think being conference champion should matter and supposedly that was what put Ohio State in over TCU & Baylor two years ago, so why didn't it matter this time?