To all Brady and Manning nut danglers

[jdwills126]

You're projecting. I do appreciate good teams and good play. I wasn't trying to "prop up" anybody, nor was I trying to drag anybody down. There is no doubt that Manning and Brady are great QBs.

If you read the threads on this board, how many of them are titled with Brady or Manning and the nut huggers trying to prop up their guy or run down the other? It's old and tired, but seems to happen on a daily basis.

Classic case of penis envy!

 

[Moab]

Moab, let me project. You're regretting having started this thread.

Not at all. In fact I find many of the posts humorous.

 

[Moab]

Classic case of penis envy!

Why would I give you penis envy? Hell, I haven't even flopped it out yet.

 

[GNG]

I wonder how many of these "Aaron Rodgers Nut Huggers" rooted for the Jets when Brett Favre went to New York.

I wonder if the Houston Texans will ever win a Super Bowl.

 

[rmilia1]

Aaron Rodgers has a better career QB ratin, a better carrer QB rating in the playoffs, a better TD to INT ratio, more YPA, more YPC, higher completion % AND a better record in the playoffs than Manning. Take out the playoff record and all that is true for Rodgers over Brady as well. Rodgers is legit and is a GREAT fucking QB. Now he needs to do it for about 5+ more years and he will for sure be in the conversation for best QB's of this generation AND all time.

 

[Desean12345]

Rodger's is better than both. Clearly he doesn't have the volume stats, but on a per game basis, postseason and regular season, he kills both.

 

[Desean12345]

Aaron Rodgers has a better career QB ratin, a better carrer QB rating in the playoffs, a better TD to INT ratio, more YPA, more YPC, higher completion % AND a better record in the playoffs than Manning. Take out the playoff record and all that is true for Rodgers over Brady as well. Rodgers is legit and is a GREAT fucking QB. Now he needs to do it for about 5+ more years and he will for sure be in the conversation for best QB's of this generation AND all time.

This. Statistically, it's actually not close. Rodgers blows both Brady and Manning out of the water in the regular and postseason.

Even if he retired today, he'd be a top 5-6 all time quarterback.

 

[GNG]

Aaron Rodgers has a better career QB ratin, a better carrer QB rating in the playoffs, a better TD to INT ratio, more YPA, more YPC, higher completion % AND a better record in the playoffs than Manning. Take out the playoff record and all that is true for Rodgers over Brady as well. Rodgers is legit and is a GREAT fucking QB. Now he needs to do it for about 5+ more years and he will for sure be in the conversation for best QB's of this generation AND all time.

 

[GNG]

This. Statistically, it's actually not close. Rodgers blows both Brady and Manning out of the water in the regular and postseason.

Even if he retired today, he'd be a top 5-6 all time quarterback.

 

[GNG]

Rodger's is better than both. Clearly he doesn't have the volume stats, but on a per game basis, postseason and regular season, he kills both.

If Rodgers can stay healthy and play 10 more seasons he'd own all the passing records.

 

[Wazmankg]

 

[Ricky Roma]

Rodgers, Manning and Brady are all awesome quarterbacks. However, people get too carried away with the numbers they put up, given this pinball offensive era. Only with Manning, do we get a bit of a sample as to what it was like (1998-2003) as far as passing goes....and still, that was easier than prior to 1994, and easier still before 1978.

 

[HammerDown]

Rodgers, Manning and Brady are all awesome quarterbacks. However, people get too carried away with the numbers they put up, given this pinball offensive era. Only with Manning, do we get a bit of a sample as to what it was like (1998-2003) as far as passing goes....and still, that was easier than prior to 1994, and easier still before 1978.

Spoken like a true Montana fan who, of course, would never "get carried away with the numbers."

 

[HammerDown]

No, one bumps it with a worn-out, cliche ole internet meme because one is so clever.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Spoken like a true Montana fan who, of course, would never "get carried away with the numbers."

Translation: I can't argue factually, so I'll just throw shit on the wall and hope something sticks.

Try again.

 

[HammerDown]

Translation: I can't argue factually, so I'll just throw shit on the wall and hope something sticks.

Try again.

Oh, I see. We're dealing in facts. I must have missed yours!

 

[GNG]

Even I'll admit that Tony Romo isn't in the same class as Manning, Rodgers or Brady but we Cowboys fans love him anyway.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Oh, I see. We're dealing in facts. I must have missed yours!

Apparently you did. My post dealt directly with the passing numbers/eras that today's quarterbacks enjoy vs. those of previous eras, and that 'numbers' can't simply be taken at face value. It cannot be disputed. It is fact.

 

[broncosmitty]

Apparently you did. My post dealt directly with the passing numbers/eras that today's quarterbacks enjoy vs. those of previous eras, and that 'numbers' can't simply be taken at face value. It cannot be disputed. It is fact.

 

[cezero]

To all Brady and Manning nut danglers, I am a Rodgers nut dangler and everything I say from this point forward is 100% hypocritical.

.