Athlon's Top 50 QBs of the BCS Era

[bone3421]

maybe its just be.....but i get a lot amusement watching people try to talk circles around starbigd while he speaks in truth a "MAJORITY" of the time and people try to twist his words

star is a very levelheaded non-homer fan

 

[bone3421]

and as for doom.....he is just jealous that vince shredded the "best team in ncaa history" and won the ship

 

[The Crimson King]

College Football's Top 50 Quarterbacks of the BCS Era | AthlonSports.com

Pretty good list. Although I'm surprised Cam Newton and Colt McCoy weren't higher.

true, he was better than most above him

 

[bamabear82]

true, he was paid better than most above him

fify

 

[cane_man]

Damn. Dorsey lost 1 game his entire career and doesn't make the top 10. Also, that one loss was highly suspect. Methinks this list takes nfl play into account.

 

[starbigd]

Damn. Dorsey lost 1 game his entire career and doesn't make the top 10. Also, that one loss was highly suspect. Methinks this list takes nfl play into account.

Are you being sarcastic or do you really think Dorsey was a better collegiate QB than the players listed ahead of him? Cause I'd take several QBs BELOW him if I were making this list.....

 

[Sox33OSU]

Damn. Dorsey lost 1 game his entire career and doesn't make the top 10. Also, that one loss was highly suspect. Methinks this list takes nfl play into account.

He was a product of an NFL team playing college ball. And don't be a fool; there was nothing suspect about his one loss. They flat out lost fair and square.

 

[757Hokie83]

49th- Tajh

rightly placed, behind two Hokie qb's

 

[TigerBait1971]

LOL at LSU's offense!!!!!

 

[OregonDucks]

How is Dennis Dixon not on that list?

 

[Uman5]

How is Dennis Dixon not on that list?

Doesn't desreve it, period.

 

[OregonDucks]

Doesn't desreve it, period.

dude was on his way to winning a heisman and national title before his ACL injury.

 

[Uman5]

dude was on his way to winning a heisman and national title before his ACL injury.

But didn't. Didn't really do or win shit. Sorry.

 

[Brasky]

Dennis Dixon was a great college quarterback.

I watched the game where he went down and knew right then and there that he would quickly be forgotten about. Sucks, but it's the reality of it.

 

[cane_man]

He was a product of an NFL team playing college ball. And don't be a fool; there was nothing suspect about his one loss. They flat out lost fair and square.

Terry porters version of fair and square? Give him 5 minutes he has to run it thru his head few times.

Look up any list of the worst calls in cfb history and that game will be in the top 3 on all....unless written by a buckeye homer.

 

[Sox33OSU]

Terry porters version of fair and square? Give him 5 minutes he has to run it thru his head few times.

Look up any list of the worst calls in cfb history and that game will be in the top 3 on all....unless written by a buckeye homer.

...and it's been proven that the game should've never gone to OT, but OSU managed to actually get screwed twice by the refs on the same play towards the end of regulation that would've allowed them to run the clock out. I'm sure you're aware of this fact, right?

 

[cane_man]

...and it's been proven that the game should've never gone to OT, but OSU managed to actually get screwed twice by the refs on the same play towards the end of regulation that would've allowed them to run the clock out. I'm sure you're aware of this fact, right?

Seems only osu fans buy that line of shit

 

[Sox33OSU]

Seems only osu fans buy that line of shit

There's nothing to buy, crybaby. It's an absolute fact:

Dennis Dodd wrote in an SI column Jan. 4, 2003: "What was potentially damaging to the Buckeyes was a blown call at the end of regulation. Gamble caught a sideline pass (barely inbounds, replays showed) that was ruled out of bounds. Had officials made the right call, Ohio State would have had a first down and probably run out the clock."

Use your eyes:

 

[Smoke]

Terry porters version of fair and square? Give him 5 minutes he has to run it thru his head few times.

Look up any list of the worst calls in cfb history and that game will be in the top 3 on all....unless written by a buckeye homer.

 

[Edisto_Tiger]

rightly placed, behind two Hokie qb's