Black Adam
Cowards WILL BE cowards..
I hear ya. But both should happen imo...I'm on the fence about returning the Heisman to him.
Yes, he would have made a lot of money if NIL existed at the time, but it didn't. Like it or not, he and his family received impermissible benefits. Those benefits being ok now, doesn't make them ok then.
If I'm not mistaken, more than just "on the field performance" is taken into account. The NCAA doesn't really have any sway over the Heisman and the Heisman Trust has it's own rules re: eligibility.
If anything needs to be changed from that time, it should be USC's wins and NC's being restored. The NCAA not only never proved their case re: USC knowing what was going on, it never made any logical sense that USC would know or be involved given where the impermissible benefits took place and that we're talking about a player who was already on scholarship. There was no transfer portal, so it's not like he could tell USC "give me what I want or I'm out".
There is also evidence that the NCAA had already decided USC's fate before they even began their investigation.
I wouldn't be against him getting it back, but I wouldn't consider it a "miscarriage of justice" if he doesn't.
I'm far more interested in USC getting their wins and NC back than Bush's Heisman.