- Thread starter
- #141
skinsdad62
US ARMY retired /mod.
Wow chiller , we agree“$28m for a playoff winning qb” is thr ultimate example of “putting lipstick on a pig.”
Wentz wouldnt be in the playoffs at all if it wasnt for TH.
Wow chiller , we agree“$28m for a playoff winning qb” is thr ultimate example of “putting lipstick on a pig.”
Wentz wouldnt be in the playoffs at all if it wasnt for TH.
Wow chiller , we agree
Can you please stop the agenda posting? I have been gone several weeks and you are still trying to do the same thing you have done for about 9 months now: convince the board that Carson Wentz is the long-term franchise QB and savior of the team.28m for a playoff winning QB?
Can you please stop the agenda posting? I have been gone several weeks and you are still trying to do the same thing you have done for about 9 months now: convince the board that Carson Wentz is the long-term franchise QB and savior of the team.
You were on here Thanksgiving and Christmas Day trying to argue with everyone that Wentz should be the starter. Grab a turkey leg or eggnog....just do something. Give it a rest...everyone is tired of it.
Wentz sux and you are the only poster here who wants him to stay here beyond this year. This team needs a starting QB badly, and that QB is NOT Wentz or Heinicke. Several posters including Chiller, Skinsdad, Gkekoa, and me have proven this to you several times. However, it does not fit your narrative or agenda of converting the board to buying into Carson Wentz.
If you do NOT think 28 million for a playoff-winning QB is that much, why are you not starting a Jimmy Garoppolo fan club? He is 5-2 in the playoffs and made 7 million this year...Wentz made 4 times that amount at 28 million. Wentz is 0-1 in the playoffs in his career. Jimmy G can be had for a fraction of the price and meets your needs for a "playoff-winning QB". For the record, I do not think Jimmy G is the answer either.
Garoppolo is 44-19 as a starter while Wentz is 46-45. That needs to be taken into account as well.
By your own logic, Garoppolo would be your answer correct? You claimed Wentz will be cheaper than Carr and Garopolo but you offer no proof of that and have no clue. What we do know is that Jimmy G made 7 million this year and Wentz made 28 million and is scheduled to make 26 million in 2023. Suppose Garoppolo signs for 10 million a year as a UFA in 2023...you mean to tell me that Wentz will make less than that? That doesn't make any sense. Even if they restructure Wentz as you suggested or cut him and resign him, why would you think he will make less than Garoppolo? You also claim to see no difference between Carr and Wentz which is you pushing your agenda and distorting the facts.
Nope...you are the only one.Not the only one at all. CW has a chance to be the guy. We will see.
Nope...you are the only one.
If Wentz was going to be the guy....he would not be on his 3rd team in 3 years and struggle badly in his first 6 games here. We have seen enough including his previous 6 years.
You failed to address my Garoppolo points so I take it that I am right about that. Using your own logic, Jimmy G needs to be our first FA signing.
I think Rivera thinks Wentz has a chance to be the guy next year. I think that decision, if it's still his to make come that time will be based on these next two weeks. Keim has said as much.
Stop twisting what I am saying.CW wins a playoff game he will be here in 2023. Thats all im saying. Niner oulaw, ksbo, and brock also agree with me.
I do understand that and you are conflating two different things. Yes or no...you want wentz back right now for 2023? I have not seen one poster advocate for wentz to be back in 2023 except you. Saying Rivera will bring him back and actually wanting wentz back are different things.exactly, duke doesn't understand that
This is why he got benched....leaving big plays on the field EVERY game
And that is why Rivera needs to go. Everyone e has pointed that out. Rivera is a terrible talent evaluator.I think Rivera thinks Wentz has a chance to be the guy next year. I think that decision, if it's still his to make come that time will be based on these next two weeks. Keim has said as much.
thats wince throwingThis is why he got benched....leaving big plays on the field EVERY game
they could be right as to that happening but it shouldnt . a playoff win isnt enoughCW wins a playoff game he will be here in 2023. Thats all im saying. Niner oulaw, ksbo, and brock also agree with me.
There's a difference btwn having to and choosing to. This is the latter. He's empowering his team with a say in their own future success or failure. Dumb coaching decisions aside, the players love him for it.He has to ask the players on who to play a QB. What a joke. You would think the HC and OC would know who the better QB is by now. IF he rolls with TH again that would be awful.