Worst starting QB in every NFL team's history

[DJ]

Andrew Walter for the Raiders imo. JaCarcass is the popular choice by a lot due to his being drafted as highly as he was. Walter completed 53.3% of his passes for 139.8ypg, 6.1ypa, 3 TD's to 13 INT's, and a horrid 55.8 PR in 2006.

During his time in Oakland.....Russell completed 52.1% of his passes for 131.7ypg, 6.0ypa, 18 TD's to 23 INT's, and a slightly better 65.2 PR.

 

[DJ]

Rick Mirer was pretty bad also. But, Walter was the worst.

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

Rick Mirer was pretty bad also. But, Walter was the worst.

Rick was bad, he had the 1 decent season his rookie year, but it was all downhill after that... They guy had no ability to go through progressions...

 

[DJ]

Rick was bad, he had the 1 decent season his rookie year, but it was all downhill after that... They guy had no ability to go through progressions...

He was being called the next Joe Montana when he was drafted....

 

[Gooch1034]

I think you could have a healthy debate on this subject for many hours re: the Bills with a list of 12-15 guys that could legitimately demand the "crown" for biggest turd in team (or even NFL) history starting at QB.

Hell, I wouldn't be able to pick who is the single worst QB to ever start and NFL game but that would be a hell of a discussion.

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

He was being called the next Joe Montana when he was drafted....

LOL I know.... And what makes it worse is Bill Walsh was the one saying that...

 

[night]

I wasn't alive for the Kim McQuilken era but I know Joey Harrington was so bad that we got a franchise quarterback in the draft because of him.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

Rick was bad, he had the 1 decent season his rookie year, but it was all downhill after that... They guy had no ability to go through progressions...

Amazingly some how he managed to stick around the NFL for a while. Granted he was a back up, but still.

 

[Manster7588]

LOL I know.... And what makes it worse is Bill Walsh was the one saying that...

I was anti Mirer from the beginning. Just looked at his stats and saw he stuck around the league for 10 seadons, never realized that.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

I was anti Mirer from the beginning. Just looked at his stats and saw he stuck around the league for 10 seadons, never realized that.

Damn NE for taking Bledsoe!

 

[boogiewithstu2007]

I was anti Mirer from the beginning. Just looked at his stats and saw he stuck around the league for 10 seadons, never realized that.

He did stick around for a while, never ended up being a good starter but was a serviceable back-up... Well kinda..

 

[jarntt]

Aw yes, the fun years of Stouffer, McGwire and Gelbaugh

Most Seahawk fans be like Who???






j/k...

 

[Manster7588]

Most Seahawk fans be like Who???






j/k...

No, but Google did get a lot of traffic in the Seattle area.

 

[Rex Racer]

For the Patriots I would go with a tie between Hugh Millen and Doug Flukie.

 

[Tainthappening]

I am sure he wasn't the worst but. . .

I am a Wisconsin fan as well as a Packer fan. I had to suffer through 2 years of Scott Tolzien and thought "thank God that is over with". Then Aaron Rodgers gets hurt two years ago and who the fuck do we trot out?

I just about lost my goddamn mind.

Randy Wright was a former Badger as well

 

[Tainthappening]

there were plenty of shitty quarterbacks during the dark ages for the Packers

pretty hard to choose just one

I think it is a coin toss between Wright and Whitehurst... Lynn Dickey was good QB with no ability to scramble/run.. many of the others not enough attempts to qualify for this list (250 attempts).

Packers have been pretty lucky with QBs overall... Starr, Dickey, Favre, Rodgers... throw in fact Packers also drafted Brunnell and Hasselback, the list is pretty impressive.

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

No, but Google did get a lot of traffic in the Seattle area.

At least the newbies didn't have to suffer through those dark years of football

 

[Manster7588]

At least the newbies didn't have to suffer through those dark years of football

This is true, I know I poke fun at the 12s but for those of you who are long time fans, there was some tough years.

 

[chf]

This is true, I know I poke fun at the 12s but for those of you who are long time fans, there was some tough DECADES.

ftfy

 

[jerseyhawksfan79]

This is true, I know I poke fun at the 12s but for those of you who are long time fans, there was some tough years.

The Ken Berhring era was a disgrace. Out right tanking seasons to piss off the fans to try to move the team.