Keeper Help

[jwolt92]

Draft pick trading also allowed, just have to wait for it to be opened. In the past I've traded guys for a 6th/7th round pick when I was on the fence and took advantage of teams without 5 quality keepers

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Since @MilkSpiller22 asked and I probably should have made it known ahead of time, here's some of the scoring rules that are making the decision tough.

.5 point PPR
1 point for every 25 kick and punt return yards.
2 points for rushing/receiving/passing 2 pt conversion
3 points for 100 yard rushing/receiving game
5 points for 200 yard rushing/receiving game

since you get points for returns, i would go hill... I can see him being the next Devin Hester

 

[SmokingMonkey]

since you get points for returns, i would go hill... I can see him being the next Devin Hester

how does return yardage pts help you when teams punt out of bounds to avoid your returns?

last season, when teams didn't fully realize that Hill could take it to the house every time he touched the ball, he got about 1000 combined KR/PR yards, or 40 more fantasy pts. Tough to say that he'd eclipse that yardage total with teams avoiding him the return game, AND increased reps as an every down WR. Does this little guy have to endurance for all that now that he's a marked man? We will find out.

Still might prefer the gamble on Henry becoming a top 3 RB within 2 years personally, but I'm typically a RB over WR guy myself

 

[MilkSpiller22]

how does return yardage pts help you when teams punt out of bounds to avoid your returns?

last season, when teams didn't fully realize that Hill could take it to the house every time he touched the ball, he got about 1000 combined KR/PR yards, or 40 more fantasy pts. Tough to say that he'd eclipse that yardage total with teams avoiding him the return game, AND increased reps as an every down WR. Does this little guy have to endurance for all that now that he's a marked man? We will find out.

Still might prefer the gamble on Henry becoming a top 3 RB within 2 years personally, but I'm typically a RB over WR guy myself

I like henry a lot... But this format looks like it benefits the big play players... I don't see henry ever being a big play guy... i see him, when he gets the full time role to be a consistent player... Hill IMO is more likely to hit the 200 receiving yard plateau than Henry the 200 rushing+ receiving plateau... Yes, this will be a rarity, but i think for this format Hill has the far larger upside, and might even have the better floor since he should get SOME points receiving as well...

 

[SteelersPride]

keep henry in prep for next year n possibly thisbyear

 

[SteelersPride]

actually no don't keep henry he's not worth a top 5. round pick

 

[SmokingMonkey]

I like henry a lot... But this format looks like it benefits the big play players... I don't see henry ever being a big play guy... i see him, when he gets the full time role to be a consistent player... Hill IMO is more likely to hit the 200 receiving yard plateau than Henry the 200 rushing+ receiving plateau... Yes, this will be a rarity, but i think for this format Hill has the far larger upside, and might even have the better floor since he should get SOME points receiving as well...

I'm not even going to look this up, I promise you, Tenn will provide Henry with a much better chance to hit 200yds rushing than Hill will ever have in KC on the receiving side

 

[TKOSpikes]

I think the point per 25 KR/PR yards is a mirage. 3-4 points on a good week.

It is Henry so far and away for me. Far and away.