If Next Season Started Tomorrow...

[Chef99]

...And you had the first pick, who would you choose? One year league.


I do believe that Miggy would be my choice hands down.

 

[Reverend Jim]

I'm taking Addison Russell , just because.

 

[Microwahevo]

Trout...he can do it all.

 

[BigDDude]

Well, since Puig will be a reach at # 1, I guess I will go Cabrera. I went Trout # 1 twice this year, and am having a slight tinge of buyers remorse.

 

[Philabuster5]

I guess I have to take Zambrano then.

 

[Microwahevo]

I went Trout # 1 twice this year, and am having a slight tinge of buyers
remorse.

Why? Don't like his .307 average, .383 OBP, .530 slugging, 12HR, 48RBI, 19 SB, 22doubles, 6triples?

 

[Reverend Jim]

Why? Don't like his .307 average, .383 OBP, .530 slugging, 12HR, 48RBI, 19 SB, 22doubles, 6triples?

I think he'd rather have the .368 average, .460 OBP, .649 slugging, 21HR, 77RBI & 18 doubles from Cabrera. But those 19 stolen bases do make it tempting, I do love those 20/20+ players.

 

[tlance]

I think he'd rather have the .368 average, .460 OBP, .649 slugging, 21HR, 77RBI & 18 doubles from Cabrera. But those 19 stolen bases do make it tempting, I do love those 20/20+ players.

20/20? We haven't hit the all star break yet. Trout is 25/40 at least.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I think he'd rather have the .368 average, .460 OBP, .649 slugging, 21HR, 77RBI & 18 doubles from Cabrera. But those 19 stolen bases do make it tempting, I do love those 20/20+ players.

I love 20/20 players as well, but they have to be 20/20 players... I think often the potential 20/20 players are overrated... I would always rather have an elite player at a particular stat than a player that is good(not great) at everything... example-everth cabrera over shane victorino( I know they play 2 different positions).

 

[tlance]

I love 20/20 players as well, but they have to be 20/20 players... I think often the potential 20/20 players are overrated... I would always rather have an elite player at a particular stat than a player that is good(not great) at everything... example-everth cabrera over shane victorino( I know they play 2 different positions).

That is precisely why I love Trout.

He is elite at steals and runs and above average everywhere else. How many guys will get you 40+ steals and 25+ HRs? If this is his sophomore slump, what happens next year?

I love Miggy too, I just don't think this choice is so clear cut. At least Braun has simplified things somewhat by bowing out of the race.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

That is precisely why I love Trout.

He is elite at steals and runs and above average everywhere else. How many guys will get you 40+ steals and 25+ HRs? If this is his sophomore slump, what happens next year?

I love Miggy too, I just don't think this choice is so clear cut. At least Braun has simplified things somewhat by bowing out of the race.

I agree that you really couldnt go wrong with either Miggy or Trout... I would always pick miggy first though... He is just to safe... you know he will hit 30+ HRs hit .320+ with 115+ RBIs... The BA is just too good to consider anyone else as the number 1 pick...

 

[The Cubs fan]

Chris davis?

 

[The Cubs fan]

Not 1st overall, but not even a mention for considering?

 

[TREFF]

I think most people are still waiting for the other shoe to drop on Crush..I know I am..but hasn't yet!