DL Depth

[deep9er]

5th guy: Williams
6th guy: Dobbs
7th guy: Tukuafu (may get cut if we keep only 6)
practice squad: Siliga

think Dobbs has already shown enough "flashes" to make it? he wasn't so solid holding the line either (Texans game), but slightly better than others.

also based on watching 2nd half of Texans game, and reading articles......i'll say Tukuafu makes it? Williams and Tukuafu looked similar to me on TV, so using what i read as the tie-breaker.

 

[maniax]

think Dobbs has already shown enough "flashes" to make it? he wasn't so solid holding the line either (Texans game), but slightly better than others.

also based on watching 2nd half of Texans game, and reading articles......i'll say Tukuafu makes it? Williams and Tukuafu looked similar to me on TV, so using what i read as the tie-breaker.

The reason I think we'll keep Williams is because he's a NT. The other dudes Dobbs and Tukuafu weigh around 280. I think we need Williams on the roster because (A) if we don't put Williams on the 53 man roster someone will snatch him up and (B) we need to see if RJF or Williams can develop into the NT of the future for us.

 

[deep9er]

The reason I think we'll keep Williams is because he's a NT. The other dudes Dobbs and Tukuafu weigh around 280. I think we need Williams on the roster because (A) if we don't put Williams on the 53 man roster someone will snatch him up and (B) we need to see if RJF or Williams can develop into the NT of the future for us.

ok, thats fine, no problem with your opinion.

but reading you posts it seems you want Ian Williams based off his name, his reputation? doesn't seem like you're basing it off his pre-season performances? if other teams are interested, they'll be looking at his on field performances.

RJF is the back up NT, can we afford three NT's on the roster?