- Thread starter
- #1
deanpet21
Well-Known Member
Biggest Reach Round 1: Miami Dolphins: OT JaWuan James
This was a clear-cut no brainer. Everybody knows that the Dolphins were desperate to upgrade a porous offensive line before they ruin quarterback Ryan Tannehill, but taking James in the top 20 was a stretch by any imagination.
Two teams that drafted offensive tackles before Miami told WalterFootball.com they did not have a first-round grade on James - one of them had him in the third. Another team that selected a few picks after the Dolphins did not have a first-round grade on James. That organization had him with a late third-round and early fourth-round grade.
A team picking in the top 10 that was rumored to be in the tackle market told WalterFootball.com that they had a fifth-round grade on James. While that sounds extremely low, that team felt the only tackles worthy of a first-round pick were Greg Robinson, Jake Matthews, Taylor Lewan and Zack Martin.
All told, WalterFootball.com heard from five teams that did not have a first-round grade on James. One team that drafted a left tackle in the top 10 said they had a late first- or early second-round projection on James. Thus, no team that we spoke with had a legitimate first-round grade on James.
Miami could realistically have drafted the top guard in the 2014 NFL Draft, Xavier Su'a-Filo, at No. 19 and landed James with its second-round pick. That still would have been a reach, but not of epic proportions like it was in the first round. This was an ugly start for new Dolphins general manager Dennis Hickey.
Honorable mentions: Kansas City Chiefs outside linebacker Dee Ford, Arizona Cardinals safety Deone Bucannon, Carolina Panthers wide receiver Kelvin Benjamin and San Francisco 49ers safety Jimmie Ward.
2013 Winner: Travis Frederick, Cowboys
2012 Winner: Bruce Irvin, Seahawks
Biggest Reach Day 2: Indianapolis Colts: OT Jack Mewhort
There were a lot of divided opinions of Mewhort. Some felt he was good, while others felt that he was a mid-rounder. The Colts taking him in the second round wasn't good value. Mewhort was dominated by Khalil Mack to open 2013 and also struggled against Clemson speed rusher Vic Beasley. Mewhort will probably move to guard in the NFL, but I think he's going to get targeted and abused by Houston's duo of J.J. Watt and Jadeveon Clowney. Tennessee's Jurell Casey should also handle Mewhort with ease.
Indianapoliswould have gotten better value by drafting tackle Morgan Moses and sliding him inside to guard. If Gosder Cherilus doesn't pan out, Moses could replace him at right tackle as well. Another good pick the Colts passed on for Mewhort was Nebraska cornerback Stanley Jean-Baptiste. He could have formed a nice duo with Vontae Davis.
Honorable mentions: Atlanta Falcons safety Dezmen Southward, New York Giants defensive tackle Jay Bromley, San Diego Chargers guard Chris Watt, Arizona Cardinals wide receiver John Brown, Denver Broncos guard/tackle Michael Schofield.
2013 Winner: Duron Harmon, Patriots
2012 Winner: Bryan Anger, Jaguars
This was a clear-cut no brainer. Everybody knows that the Dolphins were desperate to upgrade a porous offensive line before they ruin quarterback Ryan Tannehill, but taking James in the top 20 was a stretch by any imagination.
Two teams that drafted offensive tackles before Miami told WalterFootball.com they did not have a first-round grade on James - one of them had him in the third. Another team that selected a few picks after the Dolphins did not have a first-round grade on James. That organization had him with a late third-round and early fourth-round grade.
A team picking in the top 10 that was rumored to be in the tackle market told WalterFootball.com that they had a fifth-round grade on James. While that sounds extremely low, that team felt the only tackles worthy of a first-round pick were Greg Robinson, Jake Matthews, Taylor Lewan and Zack Martin.
All told, WalterFootball.com heard from five teams that did not have a first-round grade on James. One team that drafted a left tackle in the top 10 said they had a late first- or early second-round projection on James. Thus, no team that we spoke with had a legitimate first-round grade on James.
Miami could realistically have drafted the top guard in the 2014 NFL Draft, Xavier Su'a-Filo, at No. 19 and landed James with its second-round pick. That still would have been a reach, but not of epic proportions like it was in the first round. This was an ugly start for new Dolphins general manager Dennis Hickey.
Honorable mentions: Kansas City Chiefs outside linebacker Dee Ford, Arizona Cardinals safety Deone Bucannon, Carolina Panthers wide receiver Kelvin Benjamin and San Francisco 49ers safety Jimmie Ward.
2013 Winner: Travis Frederick, Cowboys
2012 Winner: Bruce Irvin, Seahawks

There were a lot of divided opinions of Mewhort. Some felt he was good, while others felt that he was a mid-rounder. The Colts taking him in the second round wasn't good value. Mewhort was dominated by Khalil Mack to open 2013 and also struggled against Clemson speed rusher Vic Beasley. Mewhort will probably move to guard in the NFL, but I think he's going to get targeted and abused by Houston's duo of J.J. Watt and Jadeveon Clowney. Tennessee's Jurell Casey should also handle Mewhort with ease.
Indianapoliswould have gotten better value by drafting tackle Morgan Moses and sliding him inside to guard. If Gosder Cherilus doesn't pan out, Moses could replace him at right tackle as well. Another good pick the Colts passed on for Mewhort was Nebraska cornerback Stanley Jean-Baptiste. He could have formed a nice duo with Vontae Davis.
Honorable mentions: Atlanta Falcons safety Dezmen Southward, New York Giants defensive tackle Jay Bromley, San Diego Chargers guard Chris Watt, Arizona Cardinals wide receiver John Brown, Denver Broncos guard/tackle Michael Schofield.
2013 Winner: Duron Harmon, Patriots
2012 Winner: Bryan Anger, Jaguars