Trade Offer

[romeo212000]

Had someone offer me D. Freeman and Amari Cooper for CMac. League is 12 team PPR 2RB, 2WR, TE, Flex

My team.
QB Stafford
RB: CMac, Hyde, A. Collins, T. Riddick, T. Montgomery
WR: T. Hill, OBJ, Fuller, Agholor, Westbrook, Benjamin
TE: Graham

His team
QB: Ryan, Fitz
RB: Freeman, D. Lewis, T. Coleman, A. Peterson, Chubb
WR: Hopkins, Thielen, Cooper, Edelman, Snead
TE: Kittle, Njoku

My initial response is to laugh at this trade by my ignorant untrained eye. Cooper has been spotty and no idea how productive Freeman will be. CMac is a top 5 back, maybe top 3. That said, Thielen is intriguing if he’s willing to deal and include a RB. What do you guys think?

 

[Sam Sportboy]

Had someone offer me D. Freeman and Amari Cooper for CMac. League is 12 team PPR 2RB, 2WR, TE, Flex

My team.
QB Stafford
RB: CMac, Hyde, A. Collins, T. Riddick, T. Montgomery
WR: T. Hill, OBJ, Fuller, Agholor, Westbrook, Benjamin
TE: Graham

His team
QB: Ryan, Fitz
RB: Freeman, D. Lewis, T. Coleman, A. Peterson, Chubb
WR: Hopkins, Thielen, Cooper, Edelman, Snead
TE: Kittle, Njoku

My initial response is to laugh at this trade by my ignorant untrained eye. Cooper has been spotty and no idea how productive Freeman will be. CMac is a top 5 back, maybe top 3. That said, Thielen is intriguing if he’s willing to deal and include a RB. What do you guys think?

Yer eye is right, No way I'm making that deal with the RB's you have now..............prolly wouldn't be making that deal anyway...............CMac is getting way too many touches and actually doing a lot with them to give him up fer an often injured RB and a Hot/Cold (usually cold BTW) WR.................even if he replaced Cooper with Thielen I don;t think I do that deal..............

 

[leftypower]

Had someone offer me D. Freeman and Amari Cooper for CMac. League is 12 team PPR 2RB, 2WR, TE, Flex

My team.
QB Stafford
RB: CMac, Hyde, A. Collins, T. Riddick, T. Montgomery
WR: T. Hill, OBJ, Fuller, Agholor, Westbrook, Benjamin
TE: Graham

His team
QB: Ryan, Fitz
RB: Freeman, D. Lewis, T. Coleman, A. Peterson, Chubb
WR: Hopkins, Thielen, Cooper, Edelman, Snead
TE: Kittle, Njoku

My initial response is to laugh at this trade by my ignorant untrained eye. Cooper has been spotty and no idea how productive Freeman will be. CMac is a top 5 back, maybe top 3. That said, Thielen is intriguing if he’s willing to deal and include a RB. What do you guys think?

I really don't see any strength at your RB position except Cmac - especially in ppr. Freeman is a good back but the usage and value of CMac in ppr greatly trumps Freeman. Cooper is so up and down that he's not an upgrade over those you already have. Thielen is a great ppr guy so that certainly would make it closer but I'd still pass. Perhaps Freeman, Coleman (don't think you can even think about Freeman without him) and Thielen for Cmac and 1 of your lowest 3 WRs would do it. .. not likely he will do it but that almost seems fair. ...
BTW - Hyde and Collins may be out of a start-worthy job soon. ... Hyde's touches go down to Chubb and Collins fumbling his way to the bench.

 

[SteelersPride]

Cmac is a ducking stud keep him

 

[femurov]

I guess the value is ok, but as has been stated, Cooper is too boom or bust to be a must start with what you already have at WR. I like Freeman, but you just don't have the need at WR to make a move like that. I also agree about Theilen. I think DHop and Freeman would make sense, but it would be a lot for him to give up for CMac and even then, I'm not sure it makes your team a whole lot better.

 

[romeo212000]

That’s kind of what I thought. Here’s a question. Knowing my RB situation, is it worth it to pursue a trade for J. Allen?

 

[romeo212000]

That’s kind of what I thought. Here’s a question. Knowing my RB situation, is it worth it to pursue a trade for J. Allen?

I’ve alse got T. Riddick and this guy has K. Johnson. I was thinking we could swap hand cigs. Would you look to get Allen or Johnson?

 

[leftypower]

I’ve alse got T. Riddick and this guy has K. Johnson. I was thinking we could swap hand cigs. Would you look to get Allen or Johnson?

Tough call. Collins and Allen or K. Johnson and Riddick. I would like to say the DET side but they seems hellbent on keeping Blount involved and holding Johnson down by grossly limiting his touches (12 or less). As such, guess a two-headed monster is better than three. ...

 

[SteelersPride]

Tough call. Collins and Allen or K. Johnson and Riddick. I would like to say the DET side but they seems hellbent on keeping Blount involved and holding Johnson down by grossly limiting his touches (12 or less). As such, guess a two-headed monster is better than three. ...

this

 

[romeo212000]

Tough call. Collins and Allen or K. Johnson and Riddick. I would like to say the DET side but they seems hellbent on keeping Blount involved and holding Johnson down by grossly limiting his touches (12 or less). As such, guess a two-headed monster is better than three. ...

this

He said he’d do Riddick for Allen. I’ll send the trade over this evening unless one of you yahoos tells me I’m being an idiot.

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

I’ve got CMac in both my leagues. I get constant trade offers for him and don’t plan on trading him for anything less than a replacemt RB1 and a WR1.

 

[leftypower]

He said he’d do Riddick for Allen. I’ll send the trade over this evening unless one of you yahoos tells me I’m being an idiot.

go for it. ....