Top 107

[ram29jackson]

 

[blstoker]

Who cares below avg in playoffs. If you put your teams in deep holes with pick 6's and int , you have to throw a lot to try and comeback. Your down 29-0 what are you gonna do, run the ball?

Actually, Peyton Manning was ranked 6th on the list for playoffs, Tom Brady came in 5th. Top Ten for play off experience was as follows:

1. Joe Montana
2. Drew Brees
3. Ken Stabler
4. Kurt Warner
5. Tom Brady
6. Peyton Manning
7. Terry Bradshaw
8. Bart Starr
9. Warren Moon
10. Troy Aikman

 

[ram29jackson]

Actually, Peyton Manning was ranked 6th on the list for playoffs, Tom Brady came in 5th. Top Ten for play off experience was as follows:

1. Joe Montana
2. Drew Brees
3. Ken Stabler
4. Kurt Warner
5. Tom Brady
6. Peyton Manning
7. Terry Bradshaw
8. Bart Starr
9. Warren Moon
10. Troy Aikman

playoff experience ? how is Brees a number 2 when he hasn't been in remotely the amount of playoff games as the others ?

 

[blstoker]

playoff experience ? how is Brees a number 2 when he hasn't been in remotely the amount of playoff games as the others ?

It isn't just the amount of experience that matters, but the quality of his performance during that experience. Brees has 11 starts in the playoffs, which is 16th, but his performances in those games have been amazing.

 

[ram29jackson]

It isn't just the amount of experience that matters, but the quality of his performance during that experience. Brees has 11 starts in the playoffs, which is 16th, but his performances in those games have been amazing.

but since its based on how your formula calibrates the stats , what were his numbers compared to someone else on the list that makes the outcome of your list happen. I'm asking because I am curious, I'm not trying to start anything

 

[blstoker]

So, here are the numbers for the guys who finished in the top 5:

(Montana, Brees, Stabler, Warner, Brady)

Completions - 112.5%, 137.3%, 113.9%, 120.9%, 114.3%
Completion% - 6.8+, 5.5+, 5.4+, 7.1+, 2.1+
Yards - 123.0%, 145.8%, 131.9%, 144.1%, 115.2%
TDs- 150.4%, 153.8%, 133.1%, 182.6%, 120.0%
TD% - 2.0+, 0.9+, 1.2+, 2.7+, 0.4+
INT - 73.7%, 54.2%, 73.6%, 104.2%, 83.1%
INT% - 1.0-, 1.7-, 1.5-, 0.1-, 0.8-
Rating - 22.8+, 19.1+, 21.6+, 7.3+, 24.3+
Seasons -10, 6, 7, 11, 5
Games - 23, 11, 12, 13, 26
Wins - 16, 6, 5, 18, 9

In the end, here's how the top 10 scored in overall points:

Montana - 128
Brees - 141
Stabler - 177
Warner - 202
Brady - 214
Manning - 223
Bradshaw - 237
Starr - 248
Moon - 269
Aikman - 270

 

[ram29jackson]

So, here are the numbers for the guys who finished in the top 5:

(Montana, Brees, Stabler, Warner, Brady)

Completions - 112.5%, 137.3%, 113.9%, 120.9%, 114.3%
Completion% - 6.8+, 5.5+, 5.4+, 7.1+, 2.1+
Yards - 123.0%, 145.8%, 131.9%, 144.1%, 115.2%
TDs- 150.4%, 153.8%, 133.1%, 182.6%, 120.0%
TD% - 2.0+, 0.9+, 1.2+, 2.7+, 0.4+
INT - 73.7%, 54.2%, 73.6%, 104.2%, 83.1%
INT% - 1.0-, 1.7-, 1.5-, 0.1-, 0.8-
Rating - 22.8+, 19.1+, 21.6+, 7.3+, 24.3+
Seasons -10, 6, 7, 11, 5
Games - 23, 11, 12, 13, 26
Wins - 16, 6, 5, 18, 9

In the end, here's how the top 10 scored in overall points:

Montana - 128
Brees - 141
Stabler - 177
Warner - 202
Brady - 214
Manning - 223
Bradshaw - 237
Starr - 248
Moon - 269
Aikman - 270

over all points of which/what ? Montana is number one on your over all list so which points are these that make him look sub par ?