mcnabb7542
Resident Fake Asian!
Brees in this round for me....
You jealous? The man has two Super Bowl MVP trophies. Both were earned after beating the Patriots.
I hated when people used total yards against a QB when his YPA and completion percentage was high coupled with low INTs and adequate TDs. Teams have their philosophies. Totals will go up with more throws, efficiency will go down. Look at red zone and third down, if needed. Total yards mean little. Deep attempts can also factor in, but is your offense miving and when they do, do they score (red zone)? When they don't move fast, can they (third down)?
Neither were earned. Every single defensive lineman starting was more valuable than Eli.
By the same token, if you look solely at efficiency stats and use them to compare someone who was on a dominant run team and had a lot of open looks as a result to someone who threw 60 passes a game because that's what his team needed to win, you're also not going to get much of a picture.
Third down numbers and red zone numbers vary significantly based on the situations the running game puts them in as well.
I'd like the people who voted for Russell Wilson to come out and admit as much. I just want to see who you are.
Romo, cutler, and Eli all would have made sure they didn't win shit.
No, they aren't. They are all terrible QBs and football retarded.
To me, Wilson being on this list is comical. If you switched him with half the QB's in the league, the Seahawks would be even better and his new team would be the same or worse. Put Rodgers, PManning, Brady, Brees, Stafford, Romo, Rivers, Cutler, Luck, Flacco, EManning, Foles, Kap or Newton on that Seattle team, and they still win the Super Bowl. Without a great running game and D, Wilson would look a lot different
LMAO, put Wilson behind the Shit OL Romo has had the last 5 years, give Wilson DMurray(for 5 games till he is hurt, then insert a backup) at RB, and the defense we've had last year that was missing 5-6 starters each year by midseason. The Cowboys have 3 straight 8-8's in which Romo had had a double digit lead in the 4th quarter 8-9 times only to have the defense cough it up. What the fuck could Wilson do with that? Not ShitDon't suppose you care to back any of that up with facts do you? Luck is a solid QB and Foles just might turn out to be one no doubt, but does he end up with the same stats on a different team? How many ex Kelly QB's did as well on other teams? Of course you can have arguments for rodgers, peyton, brady, and brees last season. The rest?
I mean did you really suggest Romo and Flacco are better than Wilson? Did you REALLY say that? Flacco and his 73 QB rating.
Wilson had statistically the worst pass blocking Oline in football last year and Wilson's stats were still top 10. Put Romo behind that line and Seattle loses at least 7 games with no question. Flacco would have been pulled for Jackson at some point.
Cutler? He might not even be the best QB on his own team.
Newton? Holy shit. Watch football much?
LMAO, put Wilson behind the Shit OL Romo has had the last 5 years, give Wilson DMurray(for 5 games till he is hurt, then insert a backup) at RB, and the defense we've had last year that was missing 5-6 starters each year by midseason. The Cowboys have 3 straight 8-8's in which Romo had had a double digit lead in the 4th quarter 8-9 times only to have the defense cough it up. What the fuck could Wilson do with that? Not Shit
Not really. How many votes does Kap have in this poll (I voted). ?Post #10 in this thread. Already said I did and why I did it.
If this was a poll about GOAT or rank QB's in order of their place in history then there would be some very different answers. This isn't about history or their place in it. It's about who do YOU think will have the best seasons as QB's next year. Hell, you had a few pick Eli. I mean Eli fucking Manning for gods sake. Hell, you had more than one for big Ben. Eli lead the league in interceptions last year and Ben wasn't in the top 10 of anything. Still, their fans are going to have their faith in them.
I'm damn sure the SF fans here will be very much overrating Kraperdick so why would you be so shocked about any other base and their faith in their own leader?
Not really. How many votes does Kap have in this poll (I voted). ?
That proves nothing. The question wasn't how many 9'er fans would have him at 4 or 5, but how many would have him at 6 or 7 when non 9'er fans might not have him at all until 10 or 11?
Big ben is getting votes at 4. If you took out every Steeler fan how many would he still get?
I said in the first of these polls that because they are asking who will do best next year you are asking for blind homerism all over this thing.
We all enter each season with more hope than reality likely leaves real room for. That carries over to our anticipated performance of all of our stars.
Tell me 9'er fans are different. Go ahead.
From the voting results, obviously.That proves nothing. The question wasn't how many 9'er fans would have him at 4 or 5, but how many would have him at 6 or 7 when non 9'er fans might not have him at all until 10 or 11?
Big ben is getting votes at 4. If you took out every Steeler fan how many would he still get?
I said in the first of these polls that because they are asking who will do best next year you are asking for blind homerism all over this thing.
We all enter each season with more hope than reality likely leaves real room for. That carries over to our anticipated performance of all of our stars.
Tell me 9'er fans are different. Go ahead.