The 54 Pick MLB, NFL, NBA Super Draft : CHAT

[Hall]

This also opens up trading. Trading away NFL talent for NBa or MLB is really fun and makes you evalutae the players more besides just draft stock.

 

[Shanemansj13]

This also opens up trading. Trading away NFL talent for NBa or MLB is really fun and makes you evalutae the players more besides just draft stock.

^^^This

 

[Hall]

With the point system there is a multiplier for voting? Or no? Not in the OP.

@Nosferatu

 

[Nosferatu]

With the point system there is a multiplier for voting? Or no? Not in the OP.

@Nosferatu

Why would that be necessary? Everyone sends me rankings for each sport 1st - 9th with 1st being best and worth 10 points. You do not rank your own team. I add the numbers for each team and determine a winner.

 

[Nosferatu]

Damn Meebs prolly doing 30 MPH on the highway!

 

[Hall]

Why would that be necessary? Everyone sends me rankings for each sport 1st - 9th with 1st being best and worth 10 points. You do not rank your own team. I add the numbers for each team and determine a winner.

To balance the draft capital needed to get a victory in NBA vs NFL.

I mean it doesn't matter to me, it was just a talking point that can be abated by making NFL worth slightly more to balance the investment.

 

[Nosferatu]

To balance the draft capital needed to get a victory in NBA vs NFL.

I mean it doesn't matter to me, it was just a talking point that can be abated by making NFL worth slightly more to balance the investment.

Okay how do you propose we do that without everyone just turning their back on the NBA portion of the draft knowing it's not worth as much? Maybe not turning their back but certainly waiting on putting together their NBA team until they have a good 10 or 12 of the best NFL players.

 

[Nosferatu]

Meebs prolly driving the damn flintstones car!

 

[Hall]

If they put 10 picks into NFL they are going to be so far behind in NBA they will probably finish last in it anyway.

The weighting isn't to make the NFL worth more as far as value is concerned its to take into account we are drafting twice as many NFL players as we are NBA players.

Even though we are doubling the amount of NBA picks perhaps make the vote worth only 50% more so 15 points for first. Its not to balance it all the way but just curtail it a bit.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Weighting NFL and MLB more would not be a good move. I expect people to slack on NBA anyway obviously but it could be even worse if we do this idea as well.

I say just regular voting. If we want to tweak voting next superdraft then we can

 

[Hall]

sounds good

 

[Hall]

One last suggestion before it starts. Double pick rounds at say round...30?

 

[Nosferatu]

If they put 10 picks into NFL they are going to be so far behind in NBA they will probably finish last in it anyway.

The weighting isn't to make the NFL worth more as far as value is concerned its to take into account we are drafting twice as many NFL players as we are NBA players.

Even though we are doubling the amount of NBA picks perhaps make the vote worth only 50% more so 15 points for first. Its not to balance it all the way but just curtail it a bit.

I like this idea but people already don't care about the NBA drafts aside from Meebs, Sushi and Shane, making it worth less will make the others care even less, the thinking would likely be who cares about the NBA portion of the draft a top 3 finish in the NFL portion is worth more than winning the NBA portion of the draft.

I truly do like the idea but i'm not sure it works with this group. Maybe I need to dream about it... lolzzz

 

[Nosferatu]

One last suggestion before it starts. Double pick rounds at say round...30?

Yes, yes and yes, as far as what round to start it why don't we wait and see how the draft goes and when we start slowing down we will move to double picks.

 

[Hall]

Okay, you def know the crowd better than I.

Okay just will say double pick round should start with UK imo whenever it is.

 

[Pack 500]

I like this idea but people already don't care about the NBA drafts aside from Meebs, Sushi and Shane, making it worth less will make the others care even less, the thinking would likely be who cares about the NBA portion of the draft a top 3 finish in the NFL portion is worth more than winning the NBA portion of the draft.

I truly do like the idea but i'm not sure it works with this group. Maybe I need to dream about it... lolzzz

I care

 

[Nosferatu]

I care

LIES

 

[Nosferatu]

Okay, you def know the crowd better than I.

Okay just will say double pick round should start with UK imo whenever it is.

Agreed, it will start on an even numbered round and the reason i'm saying let's wait and see is I think this might slow down earlier than round 30.

 

[Nosferatu]

The more I think about this the more I think Hall was right and we need to alter the points for football and baseball. The opposite of what I said could happen and people may go after the NBA right away as an easy way to get a high number of points, it is obviously easier to just use 3 or 4 picks and finish towards the top in hoops than the other sports.

Perhaps...

1st - 9th points...

NFL
14
13
12
11
10
9
8
7
5

MLB
12
11
10
9
8
7
6
5
3

NBA
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
1


There's not a drastic difference but enough to make it fair IMO.

 

[Nosferatu]

Anyone wanna guess what the winning score will be?

26? 27?