Should Odell Beckham Jr. Be Traded?

[Pattersonca65]

These trade to SF rumors have been going on with a number of players the past couple of years. These stories are nothing but annoying now. I really don't buy any of them.

 

[SteelersPride]

These trade to SF rumors have been going on with a number of players the past couple of years. These stories are nothing but annoying now. I really don't buy any of them.

It’s to play with jimmy

 

[MizzouFalcon]

You know, I’d probably be frustrated and act like a jackass too if I was one of the most skilled WRs in the league and I had that mouth breathing hillbilly noodle arming passes into the turf all the time.

 

[dbldwn711]

You know, I’d probably be frustrated and act like a jackass too if I was one of the most skilled WRs in the league and I had that mouth breathing hillbilly noodle arming passes into the turf all the time.

You do know that @DirtDirtDirt has gone AWOL but I appreciate the effort nonetheless!

 

[SideSwipe52]

Yes, he is a cancer, he needs to go, you never see Jerry Rice, Larry Fitzgerald, Tim Brown act like he acts.

 

[Jikkle]

I wouldn't be surprised if Cardinals go Bosa at #1 the 9ers trade #2 for #6 and OBJ.

If the Giants have their eyes set on a QB I don't think they can stand pat at #6 because someone will almost certainly leapfrog them to grab one.

Giants can move up while keeping a lot of draft capital and 9ers get OBJ for moving back 4 spots and still being in a position to draft a pass rusher.

 

[aubie2006]

Sounds like the Patriots want him.

 

[Pattersonca65]

It’s to play with jimmy

I think part of that is playing in Shanahan's offense but I dont think there is much interest for some of these players coming from the team.

 

[dtgold88]

I'd answer the same whenever I see a question like this...should we trade for (pick a player)? Should we trade (pick a player)?

Depends what they get in return. I cannot imagine any player in the league is truly untradeable.

 

[VikingFan2k2]

The questions are: “Will this effect the Giants, will this benefit either the Patriots or 49ers, and how will it impact Odell’s career?”

Affect.

 

[flclfanman]

If the Giants draft Haskens from OSU, then I think OBJ will give it a few more years.

Him, Barkley, and another WR and the Giantswill be cooking on Offense. Their defense will still stink, but at least they could score more consistently.

 

[SteelersPride]

I think part of that is playing in Shanahan's offense but I dont think there is much interest for some of these players coming from the team.

Yeah I was being sarcastic on jimmy . He had 4-5 games he won, numbers weren’t stellar. And he was good in New England mop up duty. I wanna see it prolonged and better numbers than he started with in San Fran for that contract

 

[Pattersonca65]

Yeah I was being sarcastic on jimmy . He had 4-5 games he won, numbers weren’t stellar. And he was good in New England mop up duty. I wanna see it prolonged and better numbers than he started with in San Fran for that contract

The contract doesn't bother me. The big hits are during the first two years when the team is flush was cap room. Coming into year two the team is still well under the cap. The remaining three years the team can walk away with little cap hit if it doesn't work out. The issue if it doesn't work out is the time lost not drafting and developing a young QB

 

[NinerSickness]

I wouldn't be surprised if Cardinals go Bosa at #1 the 9ers trade #2 for #6 and OBJ.

There'd have to be a franchise QB lots of teams desperately want for the VaGiants to make that move. Not sure that's going to be the case in 2019.

If the best player on the board is Q. Williams, then the 6 + ODB would be significantly too much for the 2 IMO. It's always hard to tell what trade value players have, but I don't think that would be enough for the VaGiants unless there's the QB.

 

[rmilia1]

Pretty sure the Giants can go 4-12 without him just as easily as they did with him. He's great but wideouts just aren't a huge deal . If they can get a good return then I say go for it especially since they don't have a QB who can get him the ball anyway

 

[Zoop]

No

 

[broncosmitty]

No

Correct

 

[jarntt]

Wonder if the Giants keep Collins and his steroids...

 

[Across The Field]

I'd answer the same whenever I see a question like this...should we trade for (pick a player)? Should we trade (pick a player)?

Depends what they get in return. I cannot imagine any player in the league is truly untradeable.

I'm beginning to warm up to the idea of Cleveland trading for him. Having Landry there would help a lot, as it seems Landry is a pretty stand up guy. Plus, having the chance to play with one of the top young QBs in the NFL has to be enticing for him. It would turn Cleveland into one of the top offenses in the NFL, no question.

 

[dtgold88]

I'm beginning to warm up to the idea of Cleveland trading for him. Having Landry there would help a lot, as it seems Landry is a pretty stand up guy. Plus, having the chance to play with one of the top young QBs in the NFL has to be enticing for him. It would turn Cleveland into one of the top offenses in the NFL, no question.

You certainly wouldn't hear me complaining about trading for him, but something tells me if they are gonna fire a major bullet like this it would be for defense.

Once Kitchens stepped in, the Browns were a top 5 (maybe top 2-3) offense in the second half. And did so with a rookie who hadn't played in more than a year (Callaway), a guy who had done next to nothing and had even been cut once (Higgins) and another who was cast off by his old team (Perriman)...along with Landry.

I am one of those who thinks QBs make the WRs. Not coincidence no matter who stepped in at WR in NE, NO, GB, Pittsburgh, Indy (as long as QB was healthy) they never skipped a beat.