phoenixrising
Shiprock
Some of the specific things that elite goaltenders do with regularity, Jimmy doesn't do often enough or, in some cases, ever. In saying that, he does make routine stops, outstanding ones at times, and some highlight reel gems; but, too often, when he needs to keep the play going (for various reasons), he will smother the puck with his glove, usually because there is an opponent in close proximity of the crease, often close because he waited too long to make a decision. It isn't a secret why he resorts to this, though, it's simply because his puck-handling skills aren't very good. This alone drops him below the top-echelon of other guys, who will stop the puck behind the net when it is shot into the zone of the boards to allow his dman to start the possession. He'll often let the puck continue to travel behind the net allowing the onrushing forward to challenge us for the possession.
We hardly ever see him move the puck up ice to maintain continued play to utilize the PP time, when the opposition clears the puck into our end. We seldom see him make a stop, then clear the puck to the corner; instead, he will freeze it, where sometimes the puck will come loose when players jam at it, making it more difficult to resettle it with all the traffic in and around the crease. c) He seldom makes a stop then a pass to another Wings' player in our zone with a fore-checker approaching him; he will cover it, instead, forcing a faceoff in our zone ending the possession in a heart beat. As far as shootouts are concerned, don't expect him to win very many, mostly because he lets the player skating in on net get his center of gravity moving far too much from an early deke, which makes it quite challenging to recover to make the stop when the puck is released. Also, in this situation, his activation responses are not as immediate as so many other netminders around the league. Those are some of the reasons that drop him down from the top level of guys that will literally steal the cup for a team. It is my opinion, he isn't the guy that can ultimately get your team to hoist the trophy. If Holland and the gang are waiting for him to develop further in his maturation as an elite goaltender, we're going to find that the guy is going to die of thirst out there in that arid vastness because the camel train isn't coming along any time soon - their search for him is over, they've given up on him for dead.
I can not disagree with you on this. Mike Vernon had the stuff, when Oz was in goal our 'D' had the stuff. Howard looks like a deer caught in the headlights on breakaways and shootouts.