Mebert
Not Mebert's Alt
Actually I think people are too hesitant to admit that some of the current players are as good as they are.
It is more about years I think. Tons of players have a flash in the pan breakout that fall to earth. With the older players you know what their career is. You always see players like Lin or Flip Murray who flash for a brief stretch before settling down to what they truly are.
It is a subjective formula though, how long is sustained excellence needed before you can throw them into their predecessors level. Everyone has their own view for that I think.