Peyton Manning Sets Another All-Time Record

[Ricky Roma]

This is the very last "Peyton sux" thread on its final gasping, dying breath and we have a Montana and two Brady fans making sure it doesn't just die a merciful death.

Give us a good lil cry....

hahaha

 

[HammerDown]

Give us a good lil cry....

hahaha

I'm not sad. It's more embarrassed. I'm embarrassed for the game.

 

[sonnyblack65]

Joe Montana is not the GOAT, however, he is a legend, a worthy HOFer, and one of the greatest of all time. I'm a die-hard ND fan (but not a fan of the NCAA, but that's a whole other discussion) and I love Montana, but to put him above the like of Manning is ridiculous. You see, Manning gets bashed cuz he had "weapons", on the other hand Joe Montana had, not only a ton of weapons, but the greatest weapon of all time! Joe Montana had a defense, a great defense! Is that his fault? Absolutely not, but he absolutely benefitted from it. Joe Montana played in an era with no salary cap, so the 49ers "loaded up"...is that his fault? Nope, just like Peyton playing in an era with pass happy rules. Football back then you could buy teams ala the Yankees and Red Sox, these days you either need a great front office, or a great QB to carry bad football teams. Manning did that. Heck, even I would put Brady above Montana....no joke

maybe in your mind and a few Manning fans, Montana wins it and its not even close. Manning isnt better than Brady who isnt better than Montana simple? Manning can't beat Brady head to head, win % td/int ratio etc. He has more yards and tds because of 4 more years and I didnt mention playoffs

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Hammer, I see your an admin. Can I get thread starting abilities? CnI, aka ColtsnIrish here.....ton of message boarders love and hate me with a passion. Getting older now, but still love making people cry! Especially the stupid ones

 

[HammerDown]

Manning can't beat Brady head to head, win % td/int ratio etc.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

maybe in your mind and a few Manning fans, Montana wins it and its not even close. Manning isnt better than Brady who isnt better than Montana simple? Manning can't beat Brady head to head, win % td/int ratio etc. He has more yards and tds because of 4 more years and I didnt mention playoffs

And I'm the homer....lol

 

[HammerDown]

Hammer, I see your an admin. Can I get thread starting abilities? CnI, aka ColtsnIrish here.....ton of message boarders love and hate me with a passion. Getting older now, but still love making people cry! Especially the stupid ones

Done! Take it easy on Ricky. Guy can't handle much more.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

Done! Take it easy on Ricky. Guy can't handle much more.

 

[sonnyblack65]

You see, nowadays everyone benefits from rule changes, but back then, only a few teams could load up on talent. Teams that had fiscal backing

wow jelly now I feel bad. It is called free agency now. There is a salary cap in play but players used to stay on a team ,usually for whole career. Glad you support Manning/Luck that have brought 1 Lombardi to Indy in the 90's 2000's and 2010;s they played 3 decades of futilty . Your a true fan thick and thin. hopefully Luck will be the Rodgers to your ex Favre

 

[Bradyjustwins]

Well the homer argument would work if I wasn't a ND fan and Montana wasn't an alum. It would also work better if I didnt think Brady was better. GTFOH with me being a "homer"

I think Montana is GOAT. You think Manning is. You are a Colts fan and I'm a Pats fan.

So yeah between that and your inflated opinion of Luck? Homer you are.

 

[HammerDown]

And I'm the homer....lol

You gotta love Sonny.

First it's "Manning can't beat Brady in anything" then it's "Manning only beats Brady in everything because he played longer."

The numbers aren't even CLOSE.

1.) Peyton Manning
2.) Johnny Unitas
3.) Dan Marino
...everyone else

 

[Ricky Roma]

*Looks at watch again*

Still waiting for this 'legit' argument....coming in another thread? No.....not there....not ever.

 

[Manning2Luck_uJelly]

I think Montana is GOAT. You think Manning is. You are a Colts fan and I'm a Pats fan.

So yeah between that and your inflated opinion of Luck? Homer you are.

YeAh I get your argument.....I'm a Homer and a ND fan and I think Brady is superior to Montana....okay....lol

 

[sonnyblack65]

Brady perhaps had a chance, but his playoff performances also leave little to be desired. He can battle Peyton for whatever place they wish....but beneath Joe Montana.[/QUOTE

If Brady won in 07 then it would be him as GOAT. Montana had a couple ofk lunkers in playoffs too but his 4 SB no int is key. If Brady surpasses 20 playoff wins then maybe too but right now Joe is the man

 

[sonnyblack65]

Shitty troll Peyton Manning thread fails an epic fail.

Brady and Montana fans are LIVID.

2 best ever Peyton fans would be livid if they read Ben or Eli were better

 

[Ricky Roma]

Brady perhaps had a chance, but his playoff performances also leave little to be desired. He can battle Peyton for whatever place they wish....but beneath Joe Montana.[/QUOTE

If Brady won in 07 then it would be him as GOAT. Montana had a couple ofk lunkers in playoffs too but his 4 SB no int is key. If Brady surpasses 20 playoff wins then maybe too but right now Joe is the man

But he didn't, and the fact is that Brady's playoff performances are below that of his regular season effort, whereas Montana's is superior in the playoffs is a major factor.

 

[sonnyblack65]

And I'm the homer....lol

you are Manning blahhhh Luck blahhh 1 ring Montana won 4 Eli has the most ice in his families veins

 

[HammerDown]

Montana has "a couple of playoff lunkers" and he's the GOAT.

Manning has "a couple of playoff lunkers" and he's a bum.

Amazing.

 

[Ricky Roma]

The numbers aren't even CLOSE.

'The numbers'......heh

Human cattle.

 

[sonnyblack65]

You gotta love Sonny.

First it's "Manning can't beat Brady in anything" then it's "Manning only beats Brady in everything because he played longer."

The numbers aren't even CLOSE.

1.) Peyton Manning
2.) Johnny Unitas
3.) Dan Marino
4) Brett Favre
5) Drew Brees

Name five qbs that have 3 Lombardi's in 80 years Alex "Correct"