• Have something to say? Register Now! and be posting in minutes!

NFL Players Association power struggle

FirebreathingMonkey

Well-Known Member
2,796
514
113
Joined
May 25, 2013
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Retired NFL player Sean Gilbert, who wants to replace NFL Players Association chief DeMaurice Smith, released a formal platform Tuesday highlighted by a plan to terminate the league's collective bargaining agreement and including support for an 18-game season as what he called a "carrot" to draw financial concessions elsewhere from owners.
[+] EnlargeGetty ImagesSean Gilbert has released his platform to unseat DeMaurice Smith as the NFLPA's executive director.


Smith, whose contract is set to expire in 2015, presided over the 2011 CBA that led to a three-year reduction of the league's salary cap. Gilbert said in a conference call that the deal has shifted $2.5 billion to owners from what players would have received under the previous CBA. If the current deal continues to its expiration in 2021, Gilbert projected a total transfer of $10 billion.
Summarizing his pitch to players, Gilbert quoted Ronald Reagan: "Are the players better off today than they were four years ago?"
Gilbert said he had proof that owners have violated the CBA's collusion rules, which if true would allow for early termination. He would not reveal details and said he had a "different set of facts" than those raised in a separate NFLPA lawsuit claiming the NFL had a secret salary cap during the uncapped 2010 offseason.
The platform makes 22 points on how Gilbert would proceed if and when he terminates the CBA, including demands for:

A $1 million minimum salary
• Reducing rookie contracts to three years, with renegotiation allowed after one
• Free agency after three years
• Removing commissioner Roger Goodell from his role as "judge, jury and executioners on matters of players' discipline"
• Roster size increasing from 53 to 57
• 100 percent cash spending of the annual salary cap
• A contract dissolution benefit that awards players 10 percent of nonguaranteed money lost after early termination of a contract.


Gilbert acknowledged that owners might not be interested in some of his proposals but said: "Shoot for the moon. If you fail, you'll still be among the stars."
However, he predicted he could draw owners to a reasonable bargaining position by conceding an 18-game season, which Smith successfully fought off in the 2011 CBA. NFLPA president Eric Winston has maintained staunch opposition to an expanded regular season, but Gilbert said he has spoken to a number of players about the issue.
"Once I broke down what 18 games meant," he said, "in terms of playing only two preseason games and getting an increase in salary, they understood what I'm trying to implement in terms of growing the game."
Gilbert played 11 seasons as a defensive lineman in the NFL for the Rams, Redskins, Panthers and Raiders, retiring after the 2003 season. He made the Pro Bowl in 1993 while with the Rams and finished his career with 42.5 sacks.
 

dkmightyhammer

Livin' la vida loca
22,736
13,542
1,033
Joined
Apr 21, 2013
Location
Alberta, Canada
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
A $1 million minimum salary Might be a bit steep, but not a terrible idea to give more to the bottom rung guys.
• Reducing rookie contracts to three years, with renegotiation allowed after one NOPE! I hated the old days of rookies holding out before accomplishing anything. The new format is just fine.
• Free agency after three years This should be between the team and the players agent. No reason to meddle in their personal decisions.
• Removing commissioner Roger Goodell from his role as "judge, jury and executioners on matters of players' discipline" LOVE this idea. Goodell has been a disaster.
• Roster size increasing from 53 to 57 I wouldn't even mind more, make it an even 60.
• 100 percent cash spending of the annual salary cap Good idea here too. Keeps cheapskate teams from underspending and giving a shit team to their fans.
• A contract dissolution benefit that awards players 10 percent of nonguaranteed money lost after early termination of a contract. NO Way! There could be any number of reasons why the contract was terminated. Think of a Hernandez situation, should the Pats pay a murderer (allegedly) 10% because they terminated that contract?
 

gowazzu02

Well-Known Member
2,838
82
48
Joined
Apr 23, 2013
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
A $1 million minimum salary Might be a bit steep, but not a terrible idea to give more to the bottom rung guys.
• Reducing rookie contracts to three years, with renegotiation allowed after one NOPE! I hated the old days of rookies holding out before accomplishing anything. The new format is just fine. I get the thinking, the fact that Wilson only makes 600k this year is literally criminal! But Your right, if you change it for the freak outlier, your open pandoras box.
• Free agency after three years This should be between the team and the players agent. No reason to meddle in their personal decisions. This goes back to the rookie conversation above
• Removing commissioner Roger Goodell from his role as "judge, jury and executioners on matters of players' discipline" LOVE this idea. Goodell has been a disaster. Fantastic, only problem this off season has shown us that Goodell controls things even if he's "not technically in control" IE. competition committee doing their damnedess to get pey pey a ring with the IC emphasis
• Roster size increasing from 53 to 57 I wouldn't even mind more, make it an even 60. The real thing I want is why limit game day rosters. If you have 57 guys, you should be able to play 57 guys.
• 100 percent cash spending of the annual salary cap Good idea here too. Keeps cheapskate teams from underspending and giving a shit team to their fans.
• A contract dissolution benefit that awards players 10 percent of nonguaranteed money lost after early termination of a contract. NO Way! There could be any number of reasons why the contract was terminated. Think of a Hernandez situation, should the Pats pay a murderer (allegedly) 10% because they terminated that contract?


-Couple of things. First WHY do we have to change shit when its not broken IE. 18 game regular season! no no no
-Rest of my edits in your quote in Seahawks Blue
 

BoBlake

Well-Known Member
2,184
108
63
Joined
Dec 7, 2013
Location
Chicago, IL
Hoopla Cash
$ 937.50
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
I love the idea of a longer season.

I'd rather see a 17 week season, with 2 bye weeks, and that odd game being played in a neutral location that doesn't have an NFL team (London, Vegas, Boise, Nebraska, etc).
 

Warden

Active Member
396
128
43
Joined
Aug 23, 2014
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
I do not mind a longer regular season. What I am totally opposed to is a shorter pre-season. These pre-season games may not have any impact on the stat sheet but they are extremely important for the coaches and players. Seattle has a very large number of undrafted players on their team, we could not do this with a shorter pre-season. He11 with a 2 game pre-season, we wouldn't of had the luxury of the open QB competition in 2012, we would be spending all our time getting Flynn ready for the season. Once the regular season starts there is no time to develop players, it is all about game planning. The quality of our regular season games and back ups is drastically improved because of four pre-season games. No team takes more advantage of the pre-season then Pete Carroll
 
Top