Name the top 3 players ever at your school.

[ralphiewvu]

It's a thread on top 3 players from your team and several other posters had posted honorable mentions. Calm your pussy, Mary.

An not one of said posters made a rediculous comment as you did Linda. Tag the rag out of your Vag and know Clarett wasn’t a man among boys that year.

Thanks

 

[Across The Field]

I did watch him. I realized he missed a couple games. He made a great play in the title game, key word being play. And yes, he did waste his talent, just not one of the greatest of all-time talents. I mean he ran a fucking 4.7 at the combine or something like that. lol.

He made an all-time play in the title game. He ran a 4.7 at the combine over 2 years after his last game, unless you forgot.

 

[Across The Field]

An not one of said posters made a rediculous comment as you did Linda. Tag the rag out of your Vag and know Clarett wasn’t a man among boys that year.

Thanks

Well, he was, but thanks for your little input.

 

[ralphiewvu]

Well, he was, but thanks for your little input.

He wasn’t. An you have no stats to back that up. But please continue with your rediculous homer input.

 

[ericd7633]

He made an all-time play in the title game. He ran a 4.7 at the combine over 2 years after his last game, unless you forgot.

Yes, I admitted he made a great play in the title game, which doesn't prove anything about him being a great RB. lol. And I didn't forget, you'd think with 2 years to train he wouldn't be that slow.

 

[Across The Field]

He wasn’t. An you have no stats to back that up. But please continue with your rediculous homer input.

*ridiculous

Gotta love WVU fans, can't talk college football or spell.

 

[Across The Field]

Yes, I admitted he made a great play in the title game, which doesn't prove anything about him being a great RB. lol. And I didn't forget, you'd think with 2 years to train he wouldn't be that slow.

So with all the elite talents that have come into college football and flamed out, why is he consistently ranked at or near the top of the "wasted talents" lists? Is that just a coincidence?

 

[ralphiewvu]

*ridiculous

Gotta love WVU fans, can't talk college football or spell.

Gotta love Ohio State fans, get called out on ridiculous homer bull shit then have to call out grammar as a means of responding.

So you lost this one, again lol

 

[7Samurai13]

It is for someone like you who didn't watch him. He missed two games and was injured for most of 2 others, and he still wound up with 18 TDs. He was absolutely dominant. His strip of Sean Taylor was one of the top plays of the decade, and was a pretty remarkable football play in general.

Again, it's not just me saying he was one of the biggest talents wasted in sports history.

So he was injury prone, lazy, and a mental midget? That screams all time great.

 

[Across The Field]

So he was injury prone, lazy, and a mental midget? That screams all time great.

So, the things I originally mentioned that were wrong with him.

 

[Across The Field]

Gotta love Ohio State fans, get called out on ridiculous homer bull shit then have to call out grammar as a means of responding.

So you lost this one, again lol

Bud, tell yourself what you have to, but you're certainly not a winner

 

[7Samurai13]

So, the things I originally mentioned that were wrong with him.

So if you take away all of his negatives he would have been an all time great. Michigan State has never lost a game in over 120 years of you take away all of their losses.

 

[ralphiewvu]

Bud, tell yourself what you have to, but you're certainly not a winner

You are the one calling Maurice Clarett a could have been greatest of all time running back because he stripped Sean Taylor of the ball in the MNC.

Keep telling yourself you’re right. It’s hilarious.

 

[Across The Field]

You are the one calling Maurice Clarett a could have been greatest of all time running back because he stripped Sean Taylor of the ball in the MNC.

Keep telling yourself you’re right. It’s hilarious.

Are you still talking?

 

[Across The Field]

So if you take away all of his negatives he would have been an all time great. Michigan State has never lost a game in over 120 years of you take away all of their losses.

If they had a healthy Clarett with his head on straight in those losses, they'd have a whole lot less losses.

 

[ericd7633]

So with all the elite talents that have come into college football and flamed out, why is he consistently ranked at or near the top of the "wasted talents" lists? Is that just a coincidence?

Because it's probably not a long list of people that have proven to be good at the CFB level their freshman year, and not play another down of football after. I never denied he wasted his talent. Just not an all-time level of talent. He just doesn't have the stats to back it up.

 

[ralphiewvu]

Are you still talking?

Yeah, I didn’t think you could say anything else. You know I’m right. You may just be a worse homer than bandwagon pink ears.

 

[Across The Field]

Because it's probably not a long list of people that have proven to be good at the CFB level their freshman year, and not play another down of football after. I never denied he wasted his talent. Just not an all-time level of talent. He just doesn't have the stats to back it up.

Yet others disagree. I'm not saying a list of CFB players with amazing freshman years who never played again.

 

[Cowboyinexile]

1. RB Barry Sanders (he turned 50 today btw)
2. QB/HC Mike Gundy
3. WR Justin Blackmon

Sanders is God at OSU so no debate on no. 1. Statistically Gundy doesn't make top 3 but handed off to Sanders and Thomas who is a legit no 4 on this list, and is leading the golden era so I give props and have him at no. 2. Blackmon at 3 because he was more dominant than Woods, Dez, Bowman, Dykes, and Washington. Any of those are arguable for Gundys spot (Weeden and Rudolf say hi as well) but none of them produced like he did at wide receiver.

 

[HawkFan]

(1) RB/QB/DB Nile Kinnick, 1939 (Heisman Winner)
(2) DT Alex Karras, 1957 (Heisman runner up)
(3) QB Chuck Long, 1985 (Heisman runner up)
(4) TE Dallas Clark, 2002 (John Mackey winner)
(5) OG Calvin Jones, 1955 (Outland Trophy winner, 10th in Heisman as OL)
(6) OT Robert Gallery, 2003 (Outland Trophy winner)
(7) K Nate Kaeding, 2003 (Lou Groza winner)
(8) SS Bob Sanders, 2003
(9) RB Shonn Greene, 2008 (Doak Walker winner, 6th in Heisman)
(10) LB Larry Station, 1985

Chuck Long
Bob Sanders
Josey Jewel

*Maybe Noah Fant in a couple of years.