Montee Ball or Eddie Lacy?

[The Foot]

Guys I know some people are a little worried about Ball but I appreciate guys who put their necks on the line with bold predictions. I still think he could be ok but do you think trading for Lacy is a better option at this point or am I just making things worse for myself?

 

[HaroldSeattle]

I've got both in different leagues. Toss a coin. I plan to hold on to both for now.

 

[TREFF]

Either way you're gambling. Sticking with Ball could end being a crapshoot, trading for Lacy could be the same. If it's a straight up one for one deal, I guess it's just a matter of personal preference. Both could struggle all year, both could rise to expectations. My money would be on Ball before it w would Lacy, but I have more faith in Manning figuring out how to make this 2 tight end offense hum, than I do Rodgers, who in my opinion, is starting to show signs of a whiny Lil B.

 

[SteelersPride]

boom

 

[averagejoe]

I was thinking of offering trades for Lacy in all my leagues. Lacy has faced 3 tough run-defenses. SEA, NYJ & DET. Hopefully, that was Lacy's problem. Still don't trust Ball.

 

[ColinCoby]

Ball has yet to show that he can be a top back. Lacy showed that last year.

As long as Lacy stays healthy, my money is on him having the better year. Manning has so many damn weapons to throw to. No need to hand the ball to a guy struggling. The Packers need Lacy to produce.

 

[Jack_John_Mark]

Honestly, in the Offense that Ball is in, he should be worth double digits on many occasions.

Against Seattle......at Seattle.....that was a rough matchup for the little guy.

 

[SoShady]

My money is on Lacy. Never been a big supporter of Ball.