McKinnon or Taliaferro?

[romeo212000]

What do you guys think?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

depends in ppr or not... In a non PPR league both players are dependent on the TD, and Tali is more likely to get them...
In any ppr league, Mckinnon is the higher potential guy and can be better more often, especially since the vikings dont have a great passing game, and may need to run often and do short passes to the backs very often...

 

[romeo212000]

Non PPR.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Non PPR.

then go tali, He is more likely to get TDs...

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

depends in ppr or not... In a non PPR league both players are dependent on the TD, and Tali is more likely to get them...
In any ppr league, Mckinnon is the higher potential guy and can be better more often, especially since the vikings dont have a great passing game, and may need to run often and do short passes to the backs very often...

Uhhhhhh... McKinnon can't catch the ball for shit...

 

[Breasy4c_o_l]

I like both guys as potential contributors down the road, just feel like Taliafero has the murkier situation w both Pierce & Forsett, whereas McKinnon's only got Asiata to compete w for touches right now(AP not coming back anytime soon if at all...)

 

[TREFF]

I'd take McKinnon regardless of scoring system.

 

[romeo212000]

New question. Mckinnon or Pierre Thomas?

 

[obibyn]

New question. Mckinnon or Pierre Thomas?

When was the last time Thomas had 142 yards on 19 touches? Pierre's limited value is in ppr leagues.