Lets debate who should win the Heisman...

[rolltide14_0]

I got Johnny Manziel...


CMP% - 67.6%
Passing Yards - 2,780
Passing TD's - 18
Interceptions - 6

Rushing yards - 1,014
Rushing TD's - 15
YPC - 6.5


Total yards - 3,794
Total TD's - 33

He's beating Cam Newton's numbers by over 700 yards at this point in the season.

And yes, I'm on the bandwagon because he beat Bama...what of it?

But not only that, just look at his numbers...

 

[huskers1217]

Taylor martinez!!

Ags might win 2 games this year without johnny football

 

[bamabear82]

Geno Smith?

Nah, Manziel's got my vote.

 

[rolltide14_0]

Geno Smith?

Nah, Manziel's got my vote.

 

[iowajerms]

Manti Te'o

 

[Tubbs1518]

1. Te'o
2. Klein
3. Barner
4. Manziel
5. Miller

 

[rolltide14_0]

No reasoning...?

This debate sucks, you guys lose..

 

[iowajerms]

1. Te'o
2. Klein
3. Manziel
4. Mariota
5. Murray

 

[iowajerms]

No reasoning...?

This debate sucks, you guys lose..

I think there has been 1 other defender that has deserved the Heisman in recent years - Suh. I don't think Te'o is as dominant as Suh was, but he is a monster.

He is really the only one on ND that I can name. The competition he has faced is just as tough as anyone else. There is no other defender this season that matches up with him.

 

[The Crimson King]

AJ McCarron

 

[bamabear82]

Bama all up in barners heads. ^

 

[rolltide14_0]

AJ McCarron

Good choice.

2158 passing yards, 20td's, 2 ints, 66% cmp..

 

[yeodonie]

Mariota is the highest rated passer in country and his numbers are beating prior Heisman winners. But he doesn't have a cutesy nickname like Johnny Football. Oh and he hasn't lost....twice

 

[Red_Alert]

Mariota is the highest rated passer in country and his numbers are beating prior Heisman winners. But he doesn't have a cutesy nickname like Johnny Football. Oh and he hasn't lost....twice

SEC >>>>>> Creative than Oregonians

 

[MarkOU]

No debate IMO. Kliens to lose.

 

[rolltide14_0]

No debate IMO. Kliens to lose.

Sadly, I agree. He's not the best QB, but he'll win cause he's a senior and on a undefeated team.

 

[imnotgay2011]

Since this thread is titled who SHOULD win, not who WILL win, the answer is Marcus Mariota, hands down.

Most efficient passer in the country who leads the most efficient offense in the history of college football. Ever. Anywhere.

meow!!!

 

[fordman84]

I got Johnny Manziel...


CMP% - 67.6%
Passing Yards - 2,780
Passing TD's - 18
Interceptions - 6

Rushing yards - 1,014
Rushing TD's - 15
YPC - 6.5


Total yards - 3,794
Total TD's - 33

He's beating Cam Newton's numbers by over 700 yards at this point in the season.

And yes, I'm on the bandwagon because he beat Bama...what of it?

But not only that, just look at his numbers...

two words: redshirt freshman


Manziel will never win it this year. If he were a Sr he might get solid consideration, but not as a Fish

 

[starbigd]

Manziel doesn't deserve the Heisman. Let's look at his numbers in proper perspective.

He's played 3 teams with a pulse all season. He was average at best in 2 of those games. His numbers in 8 games vs the SEC are nothing to write home about. Manziel in 7 SEC games: 8 TD passes and 5 INT...I just don't see it. Combined Manziel numbers vs Bama/LSU/Florida: 76 of 117 for 702 yards, 2 TD and 3 INT.. 52 carries for 179 yards and 1 TD If you add the Ole Miss game to the discussion, he's 93 of 143 for 893 yards, 4 TD and 5 INT.... Yup, easily the Heisman winner.

All this overreaction to ONE game and his numbers against the blind sisters of the poor has to stop.

He's EASILY the freshman of the year......but Heisman? Not so much. Next year, all bets are off though.

 

[imnotgay2011]

Manziel doesn't deserve the Heisman. Let's look at his numbers in proper perspective.

He's played 3 teams with a pulse all season. He was average at best in 2 of those games. His numbers in 8 games vs the SEC are nothing to write home about. Manziel in 7 SEC games: 8 TD passes and 5 INT...I just don't see it. Combined Manziel numbers vs Bama/LSU/Florida: 76 of 117 for 702 yards, 2 TD and 3 INT.. 52 carries for 179 yards and 1 TD If you add the Ole Miss game to the discussion, he's 93 of 143 for 893 yards, 4 TD and 5 INT.... Yup, easily the Heisman winner.

All this overreaction to ONE game and his numbers against the blind sisters of the poor has to stop.

He's EASILY the freshman of the year......but Heisman? Not so much. Next year, all bets are off though.

Mariota is the freshman of the year, nimwit. Not Manziel. Jeesh!

meow!!!