Is Rick Nash a Hall of Famer?

[thedddd]

No. He is like the Fred McGriff of Hockey.

List of NHL players with 1,000 points - Wikipedia
Too many players on this list not there and some might never get there.

 

[4thstreet]

No.

List of NHL players with 1,000 points - Wikipedia
Too many players on this list not there and some might never get there.

Roenick 513-703 for 1216 in 1363 games
122 pts in 154 playoff games

son of a bitch has been blackballed

 

[thedddd]

Roenick 513-703 for 1216 in 1363 games
122 pts in 154 playoff games

son of a bitch has been blackballed

Yep...

 

[dash]

Roenick 513-703 for 1216 in 1363 games
122 pts in 154 playoff games

son of a bitch has been blackballed

Never saw him kneeling for a national anthem, either...

 

[thedddd]

Roenick 513-703 for 1216 in 1363 games
122 pts in 154 playoff games

son of a bitch has been blackballed

That same note what does it take for a 600+ goal scorer to get in?

Dave Andreychuk - Wikipedia

 

[dash]

That same note what does it take for a 600+ goal scorer to get in?

Dave Andreychuk - Wikipedia

Yeah, Andreychuk should be in (although I can't say I'm a big fan of that classic pic of him hoisting the Cup back in 2004 as captain of the Bolts).

 

[thedddd]

Yeah, Andreychuk should be in (although I can't say I'm a big fan of that classic pic of him hoisting the Cup back in 2004 as captain of the Bolts).

I don't blame you.

Different note...That "Names on the Cup" documentary I have to say the best part was Lanny McDonald.

 

[4thstreet]

That same note what does it take for a 600+ goal scorer to get in?

Dave Andreychuk - Wikipedia

By the time he's done -iginla will have similar numbers to Andreychuk-and they say he's a sure fire hall of famer.

 

[dash]

By the time he's done -iginla will have similar numbers to Andreychuk-and they say he's a sure fire hall of famer.

Plus, DA has a Cup and Iggy does not and likely will not.

/Neither of them made the top 100 in NHL history, though (along with Joe Thornton, who is also a shoo-in in my opinion for the Hall).

 

[DragonfromTO]

By the time he's done -iginla will have similar numbers to Andreychuk-and they say he's a sure fire hall of famer.

It was a different time though. That's the reason that over his career Iginla at least managed to pop up a handful of times on season leaderboards while Andreychuk pretty much never did. And while they're not perfect, a lot more award votes for Iginla reveal this difference as well.

 

[Judge Fudge]

I think he will.....

but it will be like 15-20 years down the line.

 

[jstewismybastardson]

I think he will.....

but it will be like 15-20 years down the line.

Is that when they open up the "hall of above average" wing at the hall of fame?

 

[Judge Fudge]

Is that when they open up the "hall of above average" wing at the hall of fame?

Yep and he'll be standing there with my 3rd favorite canuck...

 

[thedddd]

Yep and he'll be standing there with my 3rd favorite canuck...

Who is 1 and 2?

1. Matt Cooke
2. Alek Stojanov

 

[Judge Fudge]

Who is 1 and 2?

1. Matt Cooke
2. Alek Stojanov

1) Trevor Linden
2) "Captain KirK"

Kirk McLean - Wikipedia

 

[thedddd]

1) Trevor Linden
2) "Captain KirK"

Kirk McLean - Wikipedia

My next guess was Gerald Diduck and Geno Odjick

 

[puckhead]

no for Nash.

Neely shouldn't be in either.
and Bernie Federko, for that matter.

 

[pixburgher66]

...how the hell is Cam Neely in the HoF?

 

[dash]

...how the hell is Cam Neely in the HoF?

He was pretty good in "Dumb and Dumber"

 

[KennyBanyeah]

...how the hell is Cam Neely in the HoF?

IMO, it's based (wrongly if you ask me) on one season. As great as scoring 50 goals in 49 games is, you need some longevity and durability to get into the Hall.

Plus the "good Canadian boy, played the game the right way, I haven't changed my perception of hockey since 1962" members of the hockey inner circle carry a lot of clout.