Is Baker Mayfield a Bust?

[dtgold88]

Oh no not the question coward again. You are adorable.

You know you got outed for trying to be a GrammAr Nazi. Don't try and pull your normal bs and make it about a singular post. No one will help you move those goal posts. Your Eng.ish comp, spelling and grammar are terrible though you try playing it off.

As I said a one yard dump off that goes for 80 is an 80 yd pass. We all know and accept it. Only someone with a hidden agenda would think or try twist that into a QB great pass.

Keep posting, keep proving.

Got to love this forum

why are you going out of your way to prove you cannot even keep up with yourself, let alone what I have said?

 

[dtgold88]

You should add or if he doesn't have talent around him.

Or if it's not an offense that fits his skill set.

Or his FO didn't surround him with talent.

Or his cat died.

Or, or, or...

You know cover all your waffle bases.

you should stay out of it as adults are talking.

OK, I take it back. Please keep commenting as it's free comic relief.

 

[dtgold88]

Are you trying to say Darnold > BM?

Wondering the same.

 

[Wamu]

Wondering the same.

That fella is very weird. I don't think he really believes half the gibberish he posts. If he does then he's even funnier. A couple of weeks ago he was saying OBJ's a HOFer.

 

[NWPATSFAN]

you should stay out of it as adults are talking.

OK, I take it back. Please keep commenting as it's free comic relief.

Oh the irony.

Got to love this forum.

 

[dtgold88]

Oh the irony.

Got to love this forum.

If nothing else I don't think you've lied much this week so congrats?

 

[jarntt]

Are you trying to say Darnold > BM?

I guess it's not very popular, but I'm torn on the topic. I think it's close to a toss up between the two. Darnold has had terrible situations since coming into the league and Baker great situations. Assuming it's a fair battle I guess we will find out soon who Car likes better. Although, I see little chance both are 100% healthy the entire time, so one may win by default.

 

[Wamu]

I guess it's not very popular, but I'm torn on the topic. I think it's close to a toss up between the two. Darnold has had terrible situations since coming into the league and Baker great situations. Assuming it's a fair battle I guess we will find out soon who Car likes better. Although, I see little chance both are 100% healthy the entire time, so one may win by default.

How many more years does Darnold get the- he plays for a bad team excuse? Between him and BM the numbers are clear.

BM. 29-30 record / TD's to int's- 92/56 & total qbr- 52.0 / 61.6 comp. %

SD. 17-32 / 54 to 52 / 39.4 / 59.8%

But I disagree that BM had a great situation. He joined a team that won only 4 games the previous 3 seasons. It became a much better situation though. But didn't start that way.

 

[jarntt]

How many more years does Darnold get the- he plays for a bad team excuse? Between him and BM the numbers are clear.

BM. 29-30 record / TD's to int's- 92/56 & total qbr- 52.0 / 61.6 comp. %

SD. 17-32 / 54 to 52 / 39.4 / 59.8%

But I disagree that BM had a great situation. He joined a team that won only 4 games the previous 3 seasons. It became a much better situation though. But didn't start that way.

I don't know, Stafford got over a decade. He has had atrocious OLs since in the league (not bad, atrocious) and really hasn't had much talent around him at skill positions either. Even last year Car lost their best player and teams just swarmed all over DJ Moore all year.

Doesn't matter what it was before. Matters what it was while they are there. Funny they both ended up in the same spot but Carolina paid more for Darnold to get there

 

[Wamu]

I don't know, Stafford got over a decade. He has had atrocious OLs since in the league (not bad, atrocious) and really hasn't had much talent around him at skill positions either. Even last year Car lost their best player and teams just swarmed all over DJ Moore all year.

Doesn't matter what it was before. Matters what it was while they are there. Funny they both ended up in the same spot but Carolina paid more for Darnold to get there

I'm only talking about a BM/Darnold comparison. Other QB's aren't relevant to the topic.

But it is kinda ironic they are now teammates. If BM doesn't win it outright I'll be surprised.

 

[jarntt]

I'm only talking about a BM/Darnold comparison. Other QB's aren't relevant to the topic.

But it is kinda ironic they are now teammates. If BM doesn't win it outright I'll be surprised.

Like I said, I suspect my thoughts on it aren't too popular so I'm not looking for agreement. I just don't see it as the slam dunk everyone does I guess

 

[Wamu]

Like I said, I suspect my thoughts on it aren't too popular so I'm not looking for agreement. I just don't see it as the slam dunk everyone does I guess

With BM I don't think anything's a slam dunk. My opinion of this is based solely what the head to head numbers say. Because as I've said before never been a BM fan.

 

[ElPatron1]

Baker Mid-field lol

 

[Clayton]

Baker Meh-field

 

[Golden Spur]

I was raggin' on him as much as anyone early in the game, but BM played well in the 2nd half. Myles was just overwhelming our LT and we had no answer for Chubb.

 

[Stakesarehigh]

I was raggin' on him as much as anyone early in the game, but BM played well in the 2nd half. Myles was just overwhelming our LT and we had no answer for Chubb.

Baker played well in 2nd half

 

[ElPatron1]

Baker played well in 2nd half

He use to do that a lot with the browns. Play terrible, have a few flashes and still lose lol

The problem is he always digs himself a hole...Is way to cocky for not being very good. He talked shit before the game calling it his "revenge" game...Ouchie!!

 

[dtgold88]

I was raggin' on him as much as anyone early in the game, but BM played well in the 2nd half. Myles was just overwhelming our LT and we had no answer for Chubb.

I agree. I think Browns might have rolled if we had Baker and JB played for the Panthers. He played well whenever he had some time.

 

[dtgold88]

Baker played well in 2nd half

we lose that one and it really might have been the biggest Browns ever loss.

 

[dtgold88]

He use to do that a lot with the browns. Play terrible, have a few flashes and still lose lol

The problem is he always digs himself a hole...Is way to cocky for not being very good. He talked shit before the game calling it his "revenge" game...Ouchie!!

I mean, he did what he had to do to get his team the W. you thinking he should have played D, too?