megalodon30
Archduke of Crosstown Busses
He had a defense and was merely average at best as a QB
Average QBs don't win MVPs or get named to all pro teams.
He had a defense and was merely average at best as a QB
Guys who complete 51% of career passes with 212 TDs and 210 INT says otherwise.Average QBs don't win MVPs or get named to all pro teams.
Well, you did compare him to Donovan McNabb. Kinda sounds like hate. And 21st is a little weak. In the 10-15 range at least, imo.
Guys who complete 51% of career passes with 212 TDs and 210 INT says otherwise.
Yep, I saw that earlier this year. The dude needs to lay off the hallucinogens.McNabb thinks that he belongs in the HOF.
Passer Rating??? Really?
Carson Wentz has a better career passer rating than Joe Montana.....
I view Bradshaw in 2 phases. During the height of the Steel Curtain in the mid 70's with SB wins in '75 & '76, yea Terry was viewed as a piece of the pie & doing his part. They had one of the best collections of talent ever assembled on a football field. But once the Curtain began its decline around '77, Bradshaw was a huge reason that they won those last 2 Super Bowls ('79 & 80). He was MVP in both Super Bowls, played a great game in XIII, and a great half in XIV after having one of his worst performances of his career in the first half. Not to mention the sizable uptick in his passing numbers during those regular seasons.He had a defense and was merely average at best as a QB
Yes but he’s not as good as many. I think he will drop out of the top 20 or should eventually. Outside of his super bowls he would have been another guyHe was playing in the 70s. He was good enough to win an MVP and multiple SBs.
Yes... Based on intangibles alone he's easily still one of the most talented QBs to ever play the game. But if we're basing this on accolades then he might slip to the bottom of the top 20. His stats are still great.
Tier 1
Brady
Montana
Manning
Brees
Unitas
Marino
Staubach
Favre
Young
Elway
Tier 2
Bradshaw
Rodgers
Starr
Aikman
Graham
Warner
Kelly
Tarkenton
Roethlisberger
Wilson*
Russ WilsonList is invalid because of the glaring omissions of Terry Hanratty and Jim Plunkett.
*Wade Wilson? A. RIP B. Really? His numbers are good? Cool.
Russ Wilson
I'd put Sammy Baugh over Hanratty & Plunkett
I figured it was! I'll admit pre 1980 football is not my strong-suit unless it pertains to muh Stillers. So i'm a tad biased but I still know enough history to involve myself in such discussions!OMG!
LOL.
A. Oops! Of course Russell Wilson. My bad.
B. The Hanratty & Plunkett line was a joke. I do love Jim Plunkett though.