If we are being honest about it, DeVonta Smith is going to establish himself as the best WR in the league within the next 3 years.

[Anointed One]

maybe this season clears all this up

Hope so... Then we can start a new thread with whomever the Eagles draft in '24 that will eventually be a top 3 player at their position over the next 3 years...

There is no question Smith is a very good WR but I don't believe he's top 3, let alone top 10 at this point...

 

[PDay8810]

Hope so... Then we can start a new thread with whomever the Eagles draft in '24 that will eventually be a top 3 player at their position over the next 3 years...

There is no question Smith is a very good WR but I don't believe he's top 3, let alone top 10 at this point...

plus 1

 

[fightinfunbags]

I imagine McLaurin would be even more of a beast if he had AJ Brown opposite of him...

Or an accomplished QB. All this ranking stuff of guys is what we fans do but at the end of the day it’s all nonsense. Go run routes. Go make plays. Go block on run action. Go do your job. And when it’s all over, we can talk about how great or not great dude is. I don’t even know how we would quantify these things. People will revert to stats but even that is limited. Take McLaurin. I love that dude. Has he had many snaps with a competent QB in his career in the league? Give him Burrow or Mahomes or Allen and maybe he’s putting up PlayStation stats as well.

 

[Battlelyon]

Puka Nacau, " Who the hell is Devonta Smith?"

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Puka Nacau, " Who the hell is Devonta Smith?"

"If we are being honest about it". You gotta keep the theme @Battlelyon .

 

[DJ Fieri]

Puka Nacau, " Who the hell is Devonta Smith?"

That kid has been impressive so far.

What a steal where they drafted him...

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

That kid has been impressive so far.

What a steal where they drafted him...

Yep, and not the first time or the last time it happens. A.B./ 6th rd, Thielen and Welker UD, Kupp and Lockett 3rd rd. The list goes on and on. Everybody gets so enamoured with the top prospects and granted, some of them are great but a kid like this where everything looks just okay and nothing jumps out always pops up if they are solid route runners with good hands. Maybe he ends up falling off or maybe he has a long and solid career. But he has been impressive so far.

 

[DJ Fieri]

Yep, and not the first time or the last time it happens. A.B./ 6th rd, Thielen and Welker UD, Kupp and Lockett 3rd rd. The list goes on and on. Everybody gets so enamoured with the top prospects and granted, some of them are great but a kid like this where everything looks just okay and nothing jumps out always pops up if they are solid route runners with good hands. Maybe he ends up falling off or maybe he has a long and solid career. But he has been impressive so far.

Shows the Rams have good scouting. And they need that after having traded for Stafford, Ramsey (no longer with them) etc.

 

[jarntt]

Puka Nacau, " Who the hell is Devonta Smith?"

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I imagine McLaurin would be even more of a beast if he had AJ Brown opposite of him...

or an actual QB throughout his career.
The fact he has accomplished what he has with what he has is pretty amazing.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Maybe he meant.
Top 3 #2 WR.

There could be an argument to be made for that.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

Maybe he meant.
Top 3 #2 WR.

There could be an argument to be made for that.

Yeah, maybe. Who do we have? Higgins, Waddle, Aiyuk, Lockett, Godwin, Olave? So yeah, Smith in the mix.

 

[Mebert]

Smith is all the way down to 25th in yards.......so embarrassing.

 

[Lake Shore Drive]

Smith is all the way down to 25th in yards.......so embarrassing.

I thought this thread was worth resurrecting, just because.

And FTR, Smith is currently 28th in total yards received and tied for 38th in avg yards. The good news for him tho it's still only his 3rd year, so he has 12 more games to establish himself as the best WR in the league. Honest.

 

[eaglesnut]

I thought this thread was worth resurrecting, just because.

And FTR, Smith is currently 28th in total yards received and tied for 38th in avg yards. The good news for him tho it's still only his 3rd year, so he has 12 more games to establish himself as the best WR in the league. Honest.

Top 3.

He'll have to do more in the rest of the season than he's done in the last 3 weeks.

AJ Brown making his case for top 3. AJ hates this thread. Eagles will have one no matter what.

 

[Mebert]

I thought this thread was worth resurrecting, just because.

And FTR, Smith is currently 28th in total yards received and tied for 38th in avg yards. The good news for him tho it's still only his 3rd year, so he has 12 more games to establish himself as the best WR in the league. Honest.

This last week he got shut down. Outside of that he has made a solid case for top 10-15. While still short of thread title, anyone would take that.

 

[PDay8810]

 

[Lake Shore Drive]

Top 3.

He'll have to do more in the rest of the season than he's done in the last 3 weeks.

AJ Brown making his case for top 3. AJ hates this thread. Eagles will have one no matter what.

Don't think there's many fans out there who question the possibility of AJ being a top 3. The man can play with the best.

 

[PDay8810]

Don't think there's many fans out there who question the possibility of AJ being a top 3. The man can play with the best.

just keep throwing the ball his way and everything should work out great

 

[jarntt]

I thought this thread was worth resurrecting, just because.

And FTR, Smith is currently 28th in total yards received and tied for 38th in avg yards. The good news for him tho it's still only his 3rd year, so he has 12 more games to establish himself as the best WR in the league. Honest.

It’s just not the same with RTK gone. I guess we can all admit now that we think Smith is a pretty good WR