Harvin on PUP...

AintNoSaint · Jul 25, 2013

Uh-oh!!!!!! Hip....ugh!

Attractive and Rich · Jul 25, 2013

Ed Reed had to get hip surgery last year and is 10 years older than Harvin. Came back in no time.

seahawksfan234 · Jul 25, 2013

seahawksfan234 · Jul 25, 2013

But in all seriousness I think it makes sense for them to just bite the bullet and have the surgery. If they don't, it could linger on/possibly get worse and come back to bite us later.

RegentDenali · Jul 25, 2013

Crap. From what I read, its a slight injury to it and may or may not require surgery. He performed just fine OTAs. Showed up on a MRI. They will seek multiple opinions on this.

Hope to have him for 2013. Sucks.

Banned 10x · Jul 25, 2013

Logicallylethal · Jul 25, 2013

I'm reading the comments section on ESPN and Viking fans and 49er fans are rejoicing over the injury calling it Seattle karma

really though?

But in regards to the actual injury...I hope this only results in him missing some pre-season games...at the most 6 games in the regular season

Ahh...losing Irvin AND Percy for the first part of the year...that's going to be a lot to overcome especially if we want home field advantage...

AintNoSaint · Jul 25, 2013

If Harvin isn't available to us, the prognoticator's are going to downgrade us some, as he seems to be the X Factor in a lot of their speculations. Be fun to beat the Niner's without him.....like we did last year. Perhaps a good opportunity for Tate to elevate his game in a contract year.

HaroldSeattle · Jul 25, 2013

seahawksfan234 said:

darken65 · Jul 25, 2013

seahawksfan234 said:

That is a great one! Made me laugh!

darken65 · Jul 25, 2013

Logicallylethal said:
I'm reading the comments section on ESPN and Viking fans and 49er fans are rejoicing over the injury calling it Seattle karma

really though?

But in regards to the actual injury...I hope this only results in him missing some pre-season games...at the most 6 games in the regular season

Ahh...losing Irvin AND Percy for the first part of the year...that's going to be a lot to overcome especially if we want home field advantage...

I can't speak for all 9ers fans...just myself. I personally would let go of ESPN and comments made there. No real fan of this game would be happy of any player injuries. As a fan of the game and a division rival ,we want your 'A' game with no excuses that can be used. Wishing Percy a speedy recovery.

Banned 10x · Jul 25, 2013

darken65 said:
I can't speak for all 9ers fans...just myself. I personally would let go of ESPN and comments made there. No real fan of this game would be happy of any player injuries. As a fan of the game and a division rival ,we want your 'A' game with no excuses that can be used. Wishing Percy a speedy recovery.

Let's hope he's playing in that week 2 game

boogiewithstu2007 · Jul 25, 2013

AintNoSaint said:
If Harvin isn't available to us, the prognoticator's are going to downgrade us some, as he seems to be the X Factor in a lot of their speculations. Be fun to beat the Niner's without him.....like we did last year. Perhaps a good opportunity for Tate to elevate his game in a contract year.

Tate is a stud... I have nothing but confidence in that guy...

FirebreathingMonkey · Jul 25, 2013

Well I'm not a doctor so can anyone tell me how bad this is? I know its not as bad as an acl tear which is months if not the year. But a tear of the hip bone, means? are we looking at a few weeks with surgery, meaning he'd be ready week 3 or 4 of the preseason (not necessary put into the game but could play) . Or is this something he could play though, just going to hurt this season if he didn't get the surgery. And dose being put on the pup mean he can't play until week 6 or am I thinking of something else?

Thanks

HaroldSeattle · Jul 25, 2013

At this point nobody knows. I'm sure more tests will follow to find out just how bad or minor it is.

Jikkle · Jul 25, 2013

FirebreathingMonkey said:
Well I'm not a doctor so can anyone tell me how bad this is? I know its not as bad as an acl tear which is months if not the year. But a tear of the hip bone, means? are we looking at a few weeks with surgery, meaning he'd be ready week 3 or 4 of the preseason (not necessary put into the game but could play) . Or is this something he could play though, just going to hurt this season if he didn't get the surgery. And dose being put on the pup mean he can't play until week 6 or am I thinking of something else?

Thanks

10-16 weeks is what I'm hearing and it that depends on a variety of factors if he has the surgery.

The team apparently wants him to play through it but that all is going to come down to what the doctors say.

If he's put on the PUP he has to be out until week 6 and can't return before.

I think the larger issue for Seattle is Harvin is if he's going to be a durability concern the rest of the contract. Especially playing in the NFC West where he's going to take a beating from seeing the 9ers, Rams, and Cards defense twice a year.

Sharkonabicycle · Jul 25, 2013

Eh we'll see. Reports are pretty vague now, no reason to freak out about it.

Only the coaches and medical staff will know the extent of injury.

Can you FAKE a PUP? Would be funny if they are just doing this to catch teams off guard, then come regular season it's like, "Oh yah, he's fine."

WizardHawk · Jul 25, 2013

Jikkle said:
10-16 weeks is what I'm hearing and it that depends on a variety of factors if he has the surgery.

The team apparently wants him to play through it but that all is going to come down to what the doctors say.

If he's put on the PUP he has to be out until week 6 and can't return before.

I think the larger issue for Seattle is Harvin is if he's going to be a durability concern the rest of the contract. Especially playing in the NFC West where he's going to take a beating from seeing the 9ers, Rams, and Cards defense twice a year.

According to the reports today that is untrue. If they are on the PUP going into camp the restriction isn't there. They can return at any time. If they go on the list after camp starts there are restrictions. It is my understanding he was on the list prior to the official start of camp so he can return any time.

WizardHawk · Jul 25, 2013

And for all of the fans looking to go crazy over this, need I remind you that Seattle BLEW UP the 9'ers in week 16 without Harvin? They were also down one of their stud CB's and had a few other guys on injury.

Seattle is a better team with Harvin in the game. No doubt. But they are hardly in trouble without him. Keep it all in perspective people.

C.Adl.C.Hox.Fan · Jul 25, 2013

Harvin wasn't the only one...

Physically Unable to Perform List
DE Chris Clemons

(knee) Knew of that one.
WR Percy Harvin

(hip) Fuck....
TE Zach Miller

(foot) Is this a pre-existing/lingering or new?
DE Greg Scruggs

(knee) ...
CB Tharold Simon

(foot) I thought he was out of the woods on this one.
RB Robert Turbin

(foot) Say what when why how?

Non-Football Injury List
LB Korey Toomer

(knee) Shit, I had hopes for him.

Hopefully this is all hyper-conservative decision making in contrast to Redskin logic.
Does anyone know until what point these folks may be taken off PUP pre-regular season, or is it already a done deal?

Thanks Wizardhawk, you posted as I was typing.

Harvin on PUP...

New Member

New Member

Radical Moderate

Radical Moderate

LOL at 42-13, 29-3, 19-3

aka Raindrop

Well-Known Member

New Member

Administrator

Warped Member

Warped Member

aka Raindrop

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Bipedal Sea Dog

Release the Kraken - Fuck the Canucks

Release the Kraken - Fuck the Canucks

New Member

Similar threads