Gnats post game 2

[skinsdad62]

I thought he should have gotten a shot to play for the Giants game. He was 100% healthy and had two weeks to prepare. he is the most talented QB we have on the roster right now. It was a playoff game last Sunday night and RR still went with TH. Im not saying CW is the answer here but he should have gotten the start

how do you bench the guy who was 5-1-1 dean and has the locker room? and with what we gave up for wince he needed to be the answer here . instead we gave up 3 picks , all potential starters , for a one year rental to be where we would have been in the 1st place

 

[deanpet21]

how do you bench the guy who was 5-1-1 dean and has the locker room? and with what we gave up for wince he needed to be the answer here . instead we gave up 3 picks , all potential starters , for a one year rental to be where we would have been in the 1st place

b/c Th wasn't the reason why this team was 5-1-1. If he was, I would agree with you, but he wasn't. Right if you gave up what we gave up for Wentz why not give him a shot for the Ginats game? They just wrote him off. Now I hear reports if Th has a bad first half today CW could get in. WHAT???? Why didn't that happen last week? We had 3 points at halftime. Why wasn't a switch made? RR totally bungled this situation.

 

[skinsdad62]

b/c Th wasn't the reason why this team was 5-1-1. If he was, I would agree with you, but he wasn't. Right if you gave up what we gave up for Wentz why not give him a shot for the Ginats game? They just wrote him off. Now I hear reports if Th has a bad first half today CW could get in. WHAT???? Why didn't that happen last week? We had 3 points at halftime. Why wasn't a switch made? RR totally bungled this situation.

he is as much a reason for the wins as anyone else is , thats simply a false narrative . why didnt it happen last week ? because we were in the game and had a chance to win

 

[j_y19]

I thought he should have gotten a shot to play for the Giants game. He was 100% healthy and had two weeks to prepare. he is the most talented QB we have on the roster right now. It was a playoff game last Sunday night and RR still went with TH. Im not saying CW is the answer here but he should have gotten the start

This isn’t an evaluation of CW. This is an opinion if he should be playing. What has he done well? Where has he failed?

 

[j_y19]

b/c Th wasn't the reason why this team was 5-1-1. If he was, I would agree with you, but he wasn't. Right if you gave up what we gave up for Wentz why not give him a shot for the Ginats game? They just wrote him off. Now I hear reports if Th has a bad first half today CW could get in. WHAT???? Why didn't that happen last week? We had 3 points at halftime. Why wasn't a switch made? RR totally bungled this situation.

Fair enough. TH was not the reason why we were 5-1-1 under his helm. But then to be fair, CW was the reason why we were 1-4 under his helm. Right?

 

[kbso83432]

 

[deanpet21]

he is as much a reason for the wins as anyone else is , thats simply a false narrative . why didnt it happen last week ? because we were in the game and had a chance to win

the defense and running game were the reasons for the wins. CW got a raw deal. If he never got hurt, he still would have been the QB. Just like last week defense game up 13 points and we still can't win. Thats a joke. RR still thinks he can win with TH today. I hope so.

 

[deanpet21]

View attachment 317461

still would have to convert the 2 pointer to tie.

 

[Sportster 72]

That and $2.30 will get you a cup of coffee at Wawa.

 

[kbso83432]

still would have to convert the 2 pointer to tie.

That why I get so pissed when Ron starts listening to his analytic nerds and starts chasing points early.

Ron doesn't call plays on offense or defense. I'm sure he might tell Scott give me a run or give me a pass from time to time.

His job is to keep the locker room together, get his guys ready to play, and help determine who deserves to be out there. For the most part he's done a great job at that.

However, since he is not the main play caller, his main duty also consist of getting situational football correct when it comes to clock, down and distance, and scoring. He sucks at that.

 

[kbso83432]

How do you punt on 4th and 1 on the opponents 34 when Robinson has been a run away train thus far? Not trying to bang on Rivera this morning. I'm one of the few that still support him on this board, but I get it. I understand why most want him gone.

 

[deanpet21]

How do you punt on 4th and 1 on the opponents 34 when Robinson has been a run away train thus far? Not trying to bang on Rivera this morning. I'm one of the few that still support him on this board, but I get it. I understand why most want him gone.

you are exactly right. RR and Turner have been bad this year with decision making and play calling

 

[kbso83432]

They have

you are exactly right. RR and Turner have been bad this year with decision making and play calling

They have cost us games.

 

[deanpet21]

They have
They have cost us games.

its been a frustrating year to say the least. You are right about going for 2 earleir in the game when the OPT call was made on Dotson. There was no reason to go for it at the point of the game. Next play Syle misses the xP. Im trying to put that game behind me. Worst officiated and coached game I ever seen.

 

[skinsdad62]

the defense and running game were the reasons for the wins. CW got a raw deal. If he never got hurt, he still would have been the QB. Just like last week defense game up 13 points and we still can't win. Thats a joke. RR still thinks he can win with TH today. I hope so.

I know if several plays Falco made that saved our asses dean Stop with the BS