Geno Smith

[bksballer89]

Why would you bench a rookie? Who are they going to start? Brady Quinn.

Let Geno take his lumps this year....He will be better next yr for it.

If he gets the Jets 6-8 wins this season I would consider his season a success.

And benching your franchise QB in RG3 is beyond stupid.....Unless you're trying to get fired

 

[Nyfan1980]

Geno costed us the game today, he handed it to the Titans. But man the guy shows so much talent, he'll make these plays then make these dumb mistakes. I think the Jets are asking too much from him as a rookie who may not have been ready anyways as hes playing in a new system.

They got away from the run too early, Bilal Powell has been looking great. And it didn't help that his 2 starting WRs got injured.


Geno moves the ball, just makes boneheaded mistakes. Has 1,089 yards through 4 games. That is on pace for 4,352 yards, a lot for a rookie.

 

[bksballer89]

Geno costed us the game today, he handed it to the Titans. But man the guy shows so much talent, he'll make these plays then make these dumb mistakes. I think the Jets are asking too much from him as a rookie who may not have been ready anyways as hes playing in a new system.

They got away from the run too early, Bilal Powell has been looking great. And it didn't help that his 2 starting WRs got injured.


Geno moves the ball, just makes boneheaded mistakes. Has 1,089 yards through 4 games. That is on pace for 4,352 yards, a lot for a rookie.

In other words he play like the rookie that he is?

 

[Nyfan1980]

In other words he play like the rookie that he is?

yes. I think they need to scale things back right now, hes asked to do too much and hes not ready for it.

 

[wildturkey]

The Jets can't win with ANYBODY

This is the worst I've ever seen RG3 play, and I've been watching him since HS. He's never in my memory even had 2 back to back bad quarters, let alone games. His mechanics are off, his touch isn't there........either he's still not healthy or he's not feeling Shanarat and his offense. I think there are more problems there than just his play or health.

Its not the Shannahans, as hateable as they can be. It's Griffin. He mentally isn't there and its affecting his physical mechanics and preparation. You can see him struggling to think on the field and in the process, everything about what a QB is suppose to do breaks down in the play. Then he's stuck with a minimal or negative play. His knee injury probably has something to do with it but his struggles boil down to one thing, his pride. He tries to damn hard to be a leader and he's put himself in a very tough spot in which it appears at the moment, he physically and mentally isn't ready for.

 

[starbigd]

Its not the Shannahans, as hateable as they can be. It's Griffin. He mentally isn't there and its affecting his physical mechanics and preparation. You can see him struggling to think on the field and in the process, everything about what a QB is suppose to do breaks down in the play. Then he's stuck with a minimal or negative play. His knee injury probably has something to do with it but his struggles boil down to one thing, his pride. He tries to damn hard to be a leader and he's put himself in a very tough spot in which it appears at the moment, he physically and mentally isn't ready for.

I'll buy that. But I still think he and Shanny fundamentally don't get along.

 

[Steelboy84]

RGIII had a solid day today. He is their best player and best chance to win. It would be silly to bench him.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

RGIII had a solid day today. He is their best player and best chance to win. It would be silly to bench him.

 

[HammerDown]

 

[Tai Chi≈Surfing]

Jets O-Line was m.i.a. for most of the game... they had too many stupid penalties to
compete on the road.

Horrible overall game plan and preparation by the coaching staff ...especially by marty mornhinweg the OC.
Next week won't be any easier in Atl. on MNF.

 

[69er]

Geno is still green and RG3 isn't that bad,he isn't getting much help from the guys around him.

 

[Tai Chi≈Surfing]

Geno's growing pains are ruining the positive baby steps he's taken.....

I realize it's a long process, but the self inflicted wounds need to drastically decrease.

Being 2-2 after 4 games isn't the end of the world....but they need to cut back on the penalties and turnovers..

 

[HammerDown]

 

[Southieinnc]

Did anybody but Jets fans really expect the Jets to be 2-2? They are doing better than expected and with a rookie.

 

[SoCalWizFan]

The Jets can't win with ANYBODY

This is the worst I've ever seen RG3 play, and I've been watching him since HS. He's never in my memory even had 2 back to back bad quarters, let alone games. His mechanics are off, his touch isn't there........either he's still not healthy or he's not feeling Shanarat and his offense. I think there are more problems there than just his play or health.

Sounds like someone has been watching too much crap like "First Take" or "Pardon the Interruption". Please tell us all about these other problems that go beyond his "play or health". No doubt you can't because you simply made it up. Jeez - everything has to be a conspiracy nowadays. Please - stop buying into all of the crap that is propagated by sources like ESPN & Mike Florio.

 

[JahiiCarson_SqodGeneral]

EJ Manuel>Geno Smith

For best rookie QB this year. That is all.

 

[IPostedWhat]

Both QB's have a lot of work still to do, but Geno has been a turnover machine this Season.

 

[Steelboy84]

EJ is more of a pro style QB.

 

[Saturnmane]

Glennon is better than both of them. He has more td's than either of them and he has only played for part of the season. Glennon has a 62% completion percentage while EJ is 58% and Geno is 56%.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

For best rookie QB this year. That is all.

EJ certainly looked better than Geno yesterday... But as of now you still have to give it Geno!!! The Jets have a better record, and since QBs are credited for record that is a huge factor... also of course EJ missed a few games...