Dynasty trade offer

[Trudem]

I give up:

Adrian Peterson - not keeper
Pierre Garcon - keeper
Kelvin Banjamin - keeper
Devonta Freman - keeper

I get:
Le' Veon Bell - keeper
Demaryius Thomas - not keeper
Carlos Hyde - keeper

My other RBs this year would be Forte - not keeper and Ball - Keeper

 

[SoShady]

How do your keeper rules work if it's a dynasty but you can't keep AP or DT? Going off the info provided in the post. I would stick with AP, Benjamin and Freeman. I would ride AP over Bell until those wheels fell off. Who knows what happens with the 49ers and Hyde. But I would rather gamble on Benjamin becoming a top WR and Freeman becoming a really good PPR back.

 

[TREFF]

Giving up just a bit too much imho

 

[TKOSpikes]

I would stand pat as well. It's close, and if you like Bell better than I maybe you do it... I'd rather keep Freeman or have him add another little spice.

 

[Trudem]

We have a modified dynasty. No one drafted in the top 3 rounds can be kept. So of my whole team I have to give back Forte, AP and Rodgers and everyone else can be kept.

im stupid deep at WR that can be kept Nelson, Garcon, Patterson, Williams, Benjamin, Cooks, Matthews

 

[Trudem]

The way I was looking at it AP and Garcon are almost a wash for Bell and Thomas with him getting a slight edge since Bell is the keeper over Garcon. That would mean Freeman and Benjamin for Hyde, which I think is way slanted to him

 

[SoShady]

Do players move up each year until you can't keep them any longer? Or are they set in the round you drafted them forever?

 

[Trudem]

Do players move up each year until you can't keep them any longer? Or are they set in the round you drafted them forever?

They stay in the year they were orignally drafted. I drafted Cam last year 4.01 and he is mine for as long as I want.

 

[SoShady]

They stay in the year they were orignally drafted. I drafted Cam last year 4.01 and he is mine for as long as I want.

Well you upgrade at WR in a big way for this year. It comes down to what is your opinion on Bell and Hyde. The latest issues with Bell sure doesn't help. From my time it seems like you either like Bell or hate him not much in between on him. Do you think Hyde is the long term answer at RB for the 49ers? Getting two possible RB1 that you can keep for as long as you want could be worth it. Giving up a little extra in the front for the control in the back.

 

[Trudem]

Well you upgrade at WR in a big way for this year. It comes down to what is your opinion on Bell and Hyde. The latest issues with Bell sure doesn't help. From my time it seems like you either like Bell or hate him not much in between on him. Do you think Hyde is the long term answer at RB for the 49ers? Getting two possible RB1 that you can keep for as long as you want could be worth it. Giving up a little extra in the front for the control in the back.

im not going to accept because he wants too much imo.

 

[DetroitFan*]

We have a modified dynasty. No one drafted in the top 3 rounds can be kept. So of my whole team I have to give back Forte, AP and Rodgers and everyone else can be kept.

im stupid deep at WR that can be kept Nelson, Garcon, Patterson, Williams, Benjamin, Cooks, Matthews

You should have all agreed to draft garbage players until round 4...

 

[Trudem]

You should have all agreed to draft garbage players until round 4...

why...that would defeat the entire purpose of that rule

 

[TKOSpikes]

You have s nice group of WR, I wouldn't use "stupid deep". Three very good rookies gives you flexible depth this year... long term, yeah maybe stupid deep, but by the time they're ready for consistent production it will be nearing Garcon's end.

Although I'm in total agreement with you that moving Garcon (and AP) for a keepable RB is the way to go.

 

[Trudem]

You have s nice group of WR, I wouldn't use "stupid deep". Three very good rookies gives you flexible depth this year... long term, yeah maybe stupid deep, but by the time they're ready for consistent production it will be nearing Garcon's end.

Although I'm in total agreement with you that moving Garcon (and AP) for a keepable RB is the way to go.

This is obviously my goal as im shopping that package for just that.

 

[jarntt]

The other team has to throw in a hand job or two to even consider that...

 

[Barilko]

do not do it

 

[The Foot]

Keep your side

 

[HizzleRocker]

If I were you, I would ride AP, Forte, Ball, and Garcon to the Championship. Don't make that trade.

 

[TKOSpikes]

Of you don't win this year after that Dez deal, I might just quit playing forever!

 

[Trudem]

Of you don't win this year after that Dez deal, I might just quit playing forever!

If I stay healthy, I should be fine.