Don't be fooled by judge in Deflategate case; NFL will win in end over Brady

[Scooby-Doo]

There are many lawyer opinions about this. Not all with this one. As noted by the judge, the courts have thrown out arbitration cases before and the judge made a point of criticizing the process of the NFL in several way.

Certainly the judge wants them to settle and he may end up holding nose and siding with NFL but I also believe that the judge is capable to ruling for Brady with justification that will make it stick if he wants to.

That is all fine. However if it goes to the court of appeals, it will most likely get overturned considering the NFLPA agreed to the entire appeal process.

In non-leagal terms. Brady is fucked.

 

[PatsFan2003]

That is all fine. However if it goes to the court of appeals, it will most likely get overturned considering the NFLPA agreed to the entire appeal process.

In non-leagal terms. Brady is fucked.

Again. Pure speculation. You don't know that. I think it can depend on the particulars of this case and the justification by Berman. If he has said that there are cases where arbitration has been overturned, I'm sure he knows what he's talking about.. Again lawyer opinions vary.

The NFL started this case in New York with some assumption and it may or may not work out for them.. Surprise, surprise.

Explain the justification of the Supreme Court in upholding Obamacare. The law can be variable.

 

[{+}Mother-Marge{+}]

(((YAWN)))

 

[Oldschool739]

There are many lawyer opinions about this. Not all with this one. As noted by the judge, the courts have thrown out arbitration cases before and the judge made a point of criticizing the process of the NFL in several ways.

Certainly the judge wants them to settle and he may end up holding nose and siding with NFL but I also believe that the judge is capable to ruling for Brady with justification that will make it stick if he wants to.

Well I would like to restate my opinion on the matter once again;

 

[Delphic1]

Again. Pure speculation. You don't know that. I think it can depend on the particulars of this case and the justification by Berman. If he has said that there are cases where arbitration has been overturned, I'm sure he knows what he's talking about.. Again lawyer opinions vary.

The NFL started this case in New York with some assumption and it may or may not work out for them.. Surprise, surprise.

Explain the justification of the Supreme Court in upholding Obamacare. The law can be variable.

I think the best case scenario is Brady winning this case, and starts playing. The league appeals to the second circuit. It reverses Berman's decision just in time for the playoffs, and Brady misses the playoffs.

Win-win situation for everyone.

 

[PatsFan2003]

And yet here you are. Yes, yes, it's about deflategate but it's a good point that's been raised.

 

[PatsFan2003]

I think the best case scenario is Brady winning this case, and starts playing. The league appeals to the second circuit. It reverses Berman's decision just in time for the playoffs, and Brady misses the playoffs.

Win-win situation for everyone.

I vote for the appeals process to go into next year. After the Patriots next Superbowl win of course. The court reverses the ruling just in time for Brady to retire.

 

[Broncos6482]

Solid read, and I actually agree.

The biggest problem in this whole thing for Brady is that the NFLPA agreed to Goodell as the arbitrator, and agreed that his findings would be binding. They agreed to it. That's pretty much the bottom line from where I'm standing.

I'm not saying that the NFL is right, or that Brady is wrong...I'm just saying, the players and the union screwed themselves in the CBA and are paying for it with situations like this.

 

[tedman2012]

"nice post count"

PS i posted days ago about the steve garvey SC precedent and that even if it goes to 2nd circuit, their hands are tied.


keep up

what about all the other shit ?

 

[tedman2012]

I vote for the appeals process to go into next year. After the Patriots next Superbowl win of course. The court reverses the ruling just in time for Brady to retire.

if the judge decides for brady the nfl will appeal the same day and ask for the lower courts order be thrown out . it would be in weeks not months both sides will ask for a hurry up .

 

[Rock Strongo]

what about all the other shit ?

news evolves

 

[tedman2012]

Solid read, and I actually agree.

The biggest problem in this whole thing for Brady is that the NFLPA agreed to Goodell as the arbitrator, and agreed that his findings would be binding. They agreed to it. That's pretty much the bottom line from where I'm standing.

I'm not saying that the NFL is right, or that Brady is wrong...I'm just saying, the players and the union screwed themselves in the CBA and are paying for it with situations like this.

kraft was a huge factor in that contract . so kraft screwed his ne pats fans !!!!!!! oh yes just like brady screwing himself kraft taught him well .

 

[tedman2012]

news evolves

you are a great shit stirier

 

[PatsFan2003]

if the judge decides for brady the nfl will appeal the same day and ask for the lower courts order be thrown out . it would be in weeks not months both sides will ask for a hurry up .

Will they? Why should the Brady camp now be in a hurry? Again speculation.

I'm not the lawyer so I'm not saying that it won't pan out as Munson says but I don't think it's a slam dunk for the NFL.

 

[Scooby-Doo]

[.QUOTE="PatsFan2003, post: 7059642, member: 8436"]Again. Pure speculation. You don't know that. I think it can depend on the particulars of this case and the justification by Berman. If he has said that there are cases where arbitration has been overturned, I'm sure he knows what he's talking about.. Again lawyer opinions vary.

The NFL started this case in New York with some assumption and it may or may not work out for them.. Surprise, surprise.

Explain the justification of the Supreme Court in upholding Obamacare. The law can be variable.[/QUOTE]
I agree. It is all speculation

(((YAWN)))

truth hurts doesn't it?

 

[tedman2012]

Will they? Why should the Brady camp now be in a hurry? Again speculation.

I'm not the lawyer so I'm not saying that it won't pan out as Munson says but I don't think it's a slam dunk for the NFL.

they are in a hurry today so what would change ?

 

[Scooby-Doo]

news evolves

This morning is old news

 

[Scooby-Doo]

they are in a hurry today so what would change ?

Nobody knows how long it will take, but the longer it drags, the more likely it hurts the patriots more. When Brady does serve his suspension, it could be toward the end of the year when the pats are fighting for a playoff spot.

 

[Scooby-Doo]

Mother Marge gave me a Bullshit rating on my post that said discuss.

 

[Scooby-Doo]

I think the best case scenario is Brady winning this case, and starts playing. The league appeals to the second circuit. It reverses Berman's decision just in time for the playoffs, and Brady misses the playoffs.

Win-win situation for everyone.

This would be poetic justice.