Can we end the Dak Wentz debate now?

[DirtDirtDirt]

RB coach with the Bills. You're thinking of Vance Joseph. I personally think Joseph overachieved in Miami, but I don't know.

Shiiiiit, i was thinking of Joseph

yeah, my problem with Lynn was that he was a predominate run heavy Coordinator, in what has become a passing league, he played a big part in the end of Rex Ryans' career because Ryan went run heavy

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Dak checks the same Census box as Tiger Woods.

Ha.

Shiiiiit, i was thinking of Joseph

yeah, my problem with Lynn was that he was a predominate run heavy Coordinator, in what has become a passing league, he played a big part in the end of Rex Ryans' career because Ryan went run heavy

Yeah, I do think he should've been promoted as an OC first, but blah. Had the Chargers drafted Watson like they originally intended, things could be quite different. Easier to notice flaws when the team sucks.

 

[ATL96Steeler]

2017 thru 10 games.

Wentz...190/318/2430/59.7%/25TD/5INT/23 sks

Prescott...201/320/2139/62.8%/16TD/7INT/22 sks



Wentz is having a better 2017 season to date...9 more TD passes jump off the page.

In terms of who is better...I'm torn....if I had to put the team on my QB's arm, I would rather it be Wentz, I think he's better equipped to handle that...if I had to win A game...right now I would take Dak. He's got a little more experience in those games...won @ PIT, @ GB, @ MIN and he played well enough to win in the playoffs vs GB.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

 

[Dude]

From the look of it, the debate is barely starting. This season, Eagles have a better team than Cowboys. Last year it was the other way around. Time will tell, but so far, Wentz looks more poised inthe pocket, and he can run too. It seems this is a good time to begin the debate, not end it.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

2017 thru 10 games.

Wentz...190/318/2430/59.7%/25TD/5INT/23 sks

Prescott...201/320/2139/62.8%/16TD/7INT/22 sks



Wentz is having a better 2017 season to date...9 more TD passes jump off the page.

In terms of who is better...I'm torn....if I had to put the team on my QB's arm, I would rather it be Wentz, I think he's better equipped to handle that...if I had to win A game...right now I would take Dak. He's got a little more experience in those games...won @ PIT, @ GB, @ MIN and he played well enough to win in the playoffs vs GB.

Fair, I just do wonder without Zeke and a not as good Oline, is this Dak the same Dak that won those impressive game.....Now it may not matter in the long run cause he should have both of those things, but when asked to win a game without much help, I wonder who is better equipped

 

[knowyourenemy]

2017 thru 10 games.

Wentz...190/318/2430/59.7%/25TD/5INT/23 sks

Prescott...201/320/2139/62.8%/16TD/7INT/22 sks



Wentz is having a better 2017 season to date...9 more TD passes jump off the page.

In terms of who is better...I'm torn....if I had to put the team on my QB's arm, I would rather it be Wentz, I think he's better equipped to handle that...if I had to win A game...right now I would take Dak. He's got a little more experience in those games...won @ PIT, @ GB, @ MIN and he played well enough to win in the playoffs vs GB.

True but that hasn't really translated to this year. I'm going to make up a stat and don't know if it's even true or not but I believe he leads the league in 4th quarter turnovers returned for touchdowns.

 

[Dude]

Fair, I just do wonder without Zeke and a not as good Oline, is this Dak the same Dak that won those impressive game.....Now it may not matter in the long run cause he should have both of those things, but when asked to win a game without much help, I wonder who is better equipped

Eagles seem to be better equipped this season. That helps Wentz. A lot.

 

[ATL96Steeler]

Fair, I just do wonder without Zeke and a not as good Oline, is this Dak the same Dak that won those impressive game.....Now it may not matter in the long run cause he should have both of those things, but when asked to win a game without much help, I wonder who is better equipped

I'd like to beg off this question....lol

Seriously...idk Maybe Wentz...he's won more games at the college level...I assume he had to carry them more than what Dak did at Miss St.

 

[PhoenixEagles1]

I'd like to beg off this question....lol

Seriously...idk Maybe Wentz...he's won more games at the college level...I assume he had to carry them more than what Dak did at Miss St.

Wentz only started like 7 games in college and ND is a power house in D2. Dak faced waaay better comp in college. Wentz threw more passes on the NFL his rookie season then he did his entire college career. That was the knock on Wentz... hardly any experience and lower level comp. His backup played just as well. I didn't watch Dal in college but my draft guide said his knock was "When he's not protected he struggles".

 

[ATL96Steeler]

Wentz only started like 7 games in college and ND is a power house in D2. Dak faced waaay better comp in college. Wentz threw more passes on the NFL his rookie season then he did his entire college career. That was the knock on Wentz... hardly any experience and lower level comp. His backup played just as well. I didn't watch Dal in college but my draft guide said his knock was "When he's not protected he struggles".

Really? I thought he won like 5 Jr NCAA titles....guess I should revert back to Dak then...

I did see Dak play a few times as SEC is pretty much the only CFB I watch...he ran the ball a lot at Miss St, but wasn't a runner like RG3 if that makes sense...I didn't foresee this type of impact from him this early.. I know you're a fan of one of the teams in question here, but right now this is splitting hairs...Dak had the edge on the rookie season...Wentz has the edge this season.

 

[PhoenixEagles1]

Really? I thought he won like 5 Jr NCAA titles....guess I should revert back to Dak then...

I did see Dak play a few times as SEC is pretty much the only CFB I watch...he ran the ball a lot at Miss St, but wasn't a runner like RG3 if that makes sense...I didn't foresee this type of impact from him this early.. I know you're a fan of one of the teams in question here, but right now this is splitting hairs...Dak had the edge on the rookie season...Wentz has the edge this season.

Sounds fair and Maybe I'm jumping down Dak's throat too quickly. It's been a horrible two games but it's not fair to judge someone on such a small period. He is good... no denying that but I summed it up like this before the season and all the Cow boy fans ripped me but I think it's true. Dak has the potential to be a top 10 QB and pro bowler. Wentz has the potential to be the best QB in the NFL. Both good but there is a distinct difference.

 

[handicappers]

Derp

 

[ATL96Steeler]

Sounds fair and Maybe I'm jumping down Dak's throat too quickly. It's been a horrible two games but it's not fair to judge someone on such a small period. He is good... no denying that but I summed it up like this before the season and all the Cow boy fans ripped me but I think it's true. Dak has the potential to be a top 10 QB and pro bowler. Wentz has the potential to be the best QB in the NFL. Both good but there is a distinct difference.

If it played out like that, you would think both DAL and PHI will be at the top of the NFC for the next decade.

What will separate them should that happen would be rings and performances in big games...I think either fanbase would take the top 10 guy with 2 rings over the best QB with no rings.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

If it played out like that, you would think both DAL and PHI will be at the top of the NFC for the next decade.

What will separate them should that happen would be rings and performances in big games...I think either fanbase would take the top 10 guy with 2 rings over the best QB with no rings.

All day everyday!
It is a team sport, not an individual player sport.

 

[knowyourenemy]

True but that hasn't really translated to this year. I'm going to make up a stat and don't know if it's even true or not but I believe he leads the league in 4th quarter turnovers returned for touchdowns.

Damn. He is elite at throwing pick sixes.

 

[Iggloo]

Is Dak the next Nick Foles?

 

[Rey]

 

[packerzrule]

Prescott has been exposed as just another QB

 

[Ricky Roma]

Dak Kaepernick? Probably not that bad, but jeez.