Ricky Roma
The Catch
First of all, it's garbage to bring up Aaron Rodgers and how he 'shit the bed.' He didn't play at his elite level, and the Packers got rolled for it. Their defense was complete trash, and as mentioned, a converted FG and a potential TD that was fumbled really turned that game in one direction. He certainly didn't play any worse than Brady did against Houston, and the Patriots won with ease. That's the biggest difference right there.
Now, Manning has had more players overall to work with offensively throughout the years, but none of them are respectively as good as Moss and Gronk. Having said that, Manning was still more of a one-man unit for the Colts vs what Brady was for the Pats, because of the other side of the line and the guy(s) on the sidelines. I still view them very equally as far as history is concerned - perhaps a slight edge to Brady.
Now, Manning has had more players overall to work with offensively throughout the years, but none of them are respectively as good as Moss and Gronk. Having said that, Manning was still more of a one-man unit for the Colts vs what Brady was for the Pats, because of the other side of the line and the guy(s) on the sidelines. I still view them very equally as far as history is concerned - perhaps a slight edge to Brady.