Brady vs Manning Support

[Ricky Roma]

First of all, it's garbage to bring up Aaron Rodgers and how he 'shit the bed.' He didn't play at his elite level, and the Packers got rolled for it. Their defense was complete trash, and as mentioned, a converted FG and a potential TD that was fumbled really turned that game in one direction. He certainly didn't play any worse than Brady did against Houston, and the Patriots won with ease. That's the biggest difference right there.

Now, Manning has had more players overall to work with offensively throughout the years, but none of them are respectively as good as Moss and Gronk. Having said that, Manning was still more of a one-man unit for the Colts vs what Brady was for the Pats, because of the other side of the line and the guy(s) on the sidelines. I still view them very equally as far as history is concerned - perhaps a slight edge to Brady.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

First of all, it's garbage to bring up Aaron Rodgers and how he 'shit the bed.' He didn't play at his elite level, and the Packers got rolled for it. Their defense was complete trash, and as mentioned, a converted FG and a potential TD that was fumbled really turned that game in one direction. He certainly didn't play any worse than Brady did against Houston, and the Patriots won with ease. That's the biggest difference right there.

Now, Manning has had more players overall to work with offensively throughout the years, but none of them are respectively as good as Moss and Gronk. Having said that, Manning was still more of a one-man unit for the Colts vs what Brady was for the Pats, because of the other side of the line and the guy(s) on the sidelines. I still view them very equally as far as history is concerned - perhaps a slight edge to Brady.

Another example of Rodgers needing to be superman for the Pack to have a chance

And Brady just being there, for the Pats to have a chance

 

[Ricky Roma]

Another example of Rodgers needing to be superman for the Pack to have a chance

And Brady just being there, for the Pats to have a chance

It's why I will never use 'SB wins' or 'wins' period in general as any measuring stick for and against QB's. It's such a weak argument, and you'd think the name Trent Dilfer would resonate with every NFL fan, but here we are.....still.

When a defense gives up 500 yards....it's pretty laughable to start with Aaron Rodgers unless you have some sort of grudge or are jealous that he's better than 'your guy.'

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

It's why I will never use 'SB wins' or 'wins' period in general as any measuring stick for and against QB's. It's such a weak argument, and you'd think the name Trent Dilfer would resonate with every NFL fan, but here we are.....still.

When a defense gives up 500 yards....it's pretty laughable to start with Aaron Rodgers unless you have some sort of grudge or are jealous that he's better than 'your guy.'

It was a predictable approach for those who hate Aaron Rodgers

A missed FG and a fumble on the 5, in what should have been a 10-10 game, we should have been off to the back and forth game we all expected

Instead, Rodgers doesn't see the ball again until its 17-0

And the entire approach to the game is different, and the Falcons are now pinning their ears back, unleashing hell on Rodgers

Yesterday was just confirmation of what Ive always thought...The guy is a one man show, very rarely picked up by his defense, by his running game, or by his coach.....He has to be outwardly, or his team is going home

 

[Southieinnc]

It was a predictable approach for those who hate Aaron Rodgers

A missed FG and a fumble on the 5, in what should have been a 10-10 game, we should have been off to the back and forth game we all expected

Instead, Rodgers doesn't see the ball again until its 17-0

And the entire approach to the game is different, and the Falcons are now pinning their ears back, unleashing hell on Rodgers

Yesterday was just confirmation of what Ive always thought...The guy is a one man show, very rarely picked up by his defense, by his running game, or by his coach.....He has to be outwardly, or his team is going home

And you are so predictable. Are you sure you are not Goodell?????

 

[sonnyblack65]

It was a predictable approach for those who hate Aaron Rodgers

A missed FG and a fumble on the 5, in what should have been a 10-10 game, we should have been off to the back and forth game we all expected

Instead, Rodgers doesn't see the ball again until its 17-0

And the entire approach to the game is different, and the Falcons are now pinning their ears back, unleashing hell on Rodgers

Yesterday was just confirmation of what Ive always thought...The guy is a one man show, very rarely picked up by his defense, by his running game, or by his coach.....He has to be outwardly, or his team is going home

 

[RobToxin]

Yay!

This is what the SportsHoopla needed.

Yet another Manning-Brady thread.

 

[Oldschool739]

Incredibly tough to gauge, because how do you measure if Harrison and Wayne were great WR's, or were a product of the guy throwing them the ball?

Either way, any talent discrepancy is offset by Belichick vs Tony Dungy and Jim Caldwell

Spot on.....both are great qb's but Tom is more because of BB and the incredible staff he's had around him.
PM's is because of him and him alone.
If BB was out of the picture, who wouldn't pick PM to QB their team in his prime over TB ?

 

[NEPatsfan]

Spot on.....both are great qb's but Tom is more because of BB and the incredible staff he's had around him.
PM's is because of him and him alone.
If BB was out of the picture, who wouldn't pick PM to QB their team in his prime over TB ?

TB12 is the GOAT

 

[NEPatsfan]

Comparison of the two receiving corps of the SB participants, from yesterdays games.

Atlanta,



Atlanta and New England are about the same yesterday.

 

[Oldschool739]

GB has the players, if they aren't playing to their potential, it's coaching. I don't like Fat Mac , and I think he has been a hindrance to that teams success over all.
With the talent and the QB they have, they should be better than what they are.
They got pure lucky to get past Dallas.
As long as gat mac is there, almost but not a weeO is what they are. Could you see that O with josh McDaniels at the helm ?

 

[Yankee Traveler]

Smoking the righteous shit maaan!

Jacksonville pot arrest is latest run-in with law for ex-NFL, UF player Jabar Gaffney

FYI...The picture is Reche Caldwell, not Jabar Gaffney.

 

[Mike A. S.]

Incredibly tough to gauge, because how do you measure if Harrison and Wayne were great WR's, or were a product of the guy throwing them the ball?

Either way, any talent discrepancy is offset by Belichick vs Tony Dungy and Jim Caldwell

Tony Dungy is a Hall of Fame coach. Maybe he's not as good as Bill Belichick but he's definitely not someone you can accuse of bringing down a player.

 

[NEPatsfan]

FYI...The picture is Reche Caldwell, not Jabar Gaffney.

Much grassy ass.

 

[Yankee Traveler]

Much grassy ass.

Who could forget that bug eyed no catching in the end zone degenerate.