Brady vs Manning Support

[Mike A. S.]

I'm having a friendly argument with a friend of mine, so I'm asking help to settle this. Who had more talent around them throughout their careers, Brady or Peyton? Talking about on the offensive side of the ball only.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Incredibly tough to gauge, because how do you measure if Harrison and Wayne were great WR's, or were a product of the guy throwing them the ball?

Either way, any talent discrepancy is offset by Belichick vs Tony Dungy and Jim Caldwell

 

[Mike A. S.]

Incredibly tough to gauge, because how do you measure if Harrison and Wayne were great WR's, or were a product of the guy throwing them the ball?

Either way, any talent discrepancy is offset by Belichick vs Tony Dungy and Jim Caldwell

One way to gauge though is where the players were drafted. I understand there are tons of 1st-round flops or late-round steals. But I think this is a good starting point. Manning had tons of 1st-round pick receivers, running backs and offensive linemen around him, while Brady typically didn't get many of those.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

One way to gauge though is where the players were drafted. I understand there are tons of 1st-round flops or late-round steals. But I think this is a good starting point. Manning had tons of 1st-round pick receivers, running backs and offensive linemen around him, while Brady typically didn't get many of those.

Theres' a lot of ways to go with this......No coincidence that Bradys' best season came when he was throwing it to the best WR of all time (arguably)........And there are a few WR's who had their worst seasons playing with Brady, like a Jabar Gaffney or Brandon Lloyd.......Mostly because a certain type fits the Brady system...

 

[NEPatsfan]

Theres' a lot of ways to go with this......No coincidence that Bradys' best season came when he was throwing it to the best WR of all time (arguably)........And there are a few WR's who had their worst seasons playing with Brady, like a Jabar Gaffney or Brandon Lloyd.......Mostly because a certain type fits the Brady system...

Mention my name a gain mother fkr and I'll stab you in the neck

 

[redseat]

Mention my name a gain mother fkr and I'll stab you in the neck

What's he up to these days?

 

[NEPatsfan]

What's he up to these days?

Smoking the righteous shit maaan!

Jacksonville pot arrest is latest run-in with law for ex-NFL, UF player Jabar Gaffney

 

[NEhomer]

Who gives a fuck about HGH boy? He's retired. Can't we focus upon how badly Rodgers shit the bed yesterday? Peyton was lucky to tie his brother.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Who gives a fuck about HGH boy? He's retired. Can't we focus upon how badly Rodgers shit the bed yesterday? Peyton was lucky to tie his brother.

Atlanta punted once

Id probably not put that game on Rodgers

 

[NEhomer]

Atlanta punted once

Id probably not put that game on Rodgers

If Rodgers is on the field, Ryan isn't.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

If Rodgers is on the field, Ryan isn't.

The missed FG and the white fat guy fumbling, that game would have been 10-10 and we might have gotten the great one we expected

 

[NEhomer]

Rodgers sucked.

If Brady had that game you'd be launching a shit-fest about him.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Rodgers sucked.

If Brady had that game you'd be launching a shit-fest about him.

If the Pats gave up 44 points, the last guy youd be blaming for the loss is

you know who

 

[tducey]

Manning, though I think Brady's made more guys stars than Manning.

 

[TJL]

Who gives a fuck about HGH boy? He's retired. Can't we focus upon how badly Rodgers shit the bed yesterday? Peyton was lucky to tie his brother.

Rodgers didn't shit the bed, the Packers defense played absolutely horribly.

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

Eh it's toss up. Brady had the better collective o-line but Manning had Jeff Saturday. And he was named after the most badass day on Earth.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Rodgers didn't shit the bed, the Packers defense played absolutely horribly.

Don't worry, this is a fanbase that blames a defense for losing a SB 17-14, but doesn't blame a defense that gives up 44 points, and forces one punt all day

 

[Mike A. S.]

Why are we talking about Rodgers and the Falcons on this thread?

 

[TJL]

Why are we talking about Rodgers and the Falcons on this thread?

Because the answer to the thread is obvious, it's Manning.

Manning had 2 of the greatest WR's of all time, then he had Stokely, Welker, Damarius Thomas, he had Edggerin James, he had Dallas Clark, he's had an immense amount of weapons.

You can't even name Brady's WR's half of the time, look at Hogan last night for example, who the fuck is that guy?

His best player, he's ever had Gronk goes down with injuries constantly.

He's only had one elite receiver his whole career (Gronk's a TE), and he only had him for two years and in only one of the years was he any good and that's Moss.

Welker was a scrub before he went to the Pats, was a decent role player with the Phins, then Brady/Bellicheck made him what he was and he continued that success in Denver.

Sorry if I spelled a bunch of the names wrong, I blame the parents of the players for giving their children fucked names.

 

[flyingelvis]