Brady, Murray, and Andre for Calvin and luck

[Beengay fudgepackers]

Who has the beter side of the trade?

 

[TREFF]

Just looking at those five players. .I'd have to say the owner who gets Calvin.
But, as always, there's more to it than that. Did one team have a big hole at RB? That could even it out if he's now starting Andre and Murray instead of Calvin and some scrub. Plus the team dealing 3 players has a free roster spot to fill, and the other has to drop someone. .. lots of variables to consider other than the trade itself when talking about who got the better end of any deal.

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

Just looking at those five players. .I'd have to say the owner who gets Calvin.
But, as always, there's more to it than that. Did one team have a big hole at RB? That could even it out if he's now starting Andre and Murray instead of Calvin and some scrub. Plus the team dealing 3 players has a free roster spot to fill, and the other has to drop someone. .. lots of variables to consider other than the trade itself when talking about who got the better end of any deal.

Well I'd be giving up Calvin and luck. The rest of my rb/wrs are shady McCoy, lacy, Bernard, Mendenhall, Demaryius Thomas, mike Wallace, and micheal Floyd. Start 2 of each with 1 flex.

 

[TREFF]

Well I'd be giving up Calvin and luck. The rest of my rb/wrs are shady McCoy, lacy, Bernard, Mendenhall, Demaryius Thomas, mike Wallace, and micheal Floyd. Start 2 of each with 1 flex.

Well, I wouldn't say you won the deal by any means, but it does fill a hole for you. IMHO, Brady and Luck are a near wash this season given the receiver issues in NE. You gain a RB to fill RB2 (or solidify flex, either way). The step down from Calvin to Andre is significant, but it's not like we're talking about Greg Little here. Overall, your team is probably going to be more consistent now, although the potential for huge weeks went down just a little bit. .not a bad deal.

 

[Xponentialchaos]

All things equal, I'd rather be on the Calvin Johnson side of this.

But I can definitely see why you would want to do this based on your roster.

 

[Beengay fudgepackers]

I didn't make the trade yet. It was proposed to me.