Best QB you have ever seen play football

[RoboticDreams]

your username says it all

 

[packerzrule]

Johnny Unitas....yes i'm old.

ditto

 

[packerzrule]

I would also throw Tarkenton into the mix

that guy did some amazing shit

 

[Nipsey]

Peyton Manning with no close second. When Tom Brady isn't surrounded by greatness at every position, Sunday happens.

NONSENSE

Brady's passes were on point on Sunday. And…Reche Caldwell says "hi."

 

[The Derski]

Favre isn't top 20. Manning, Rodgers, and Brady all shit on him.

Favre is definitely top 20. Regardless of interceptions. He still won a SB and multiple MVPs and has the most TDs of all time. Don't know what you're smoking.

 

[JDM]

Favre is definitely top 20. Regardless of interceptions. He still won a SB and multiple MVPs and has the most TDs of all time. Don't know what you're smoking.

Most overrated player ever. It's not close. His records are all the result of playing well past the point he wasn't even serviceable any more.

He just threw the ball and hoped someone was open.

 

[ROMOTOOWENS]

Troy Aikman is better. Today.

Not according to Aikman himself.

 

[$500 Million]

Joe Montana

 

[ROMOTOOWENS]

and by the way I was kidding

 

[BF4L]

Montana
Brady
Manning
Young
Marino

This is.was gonna be my list.

Montana is still #1 and IF Brady had won those 2 SB's against the Giants he would be #1 but he did not.

The debate between Brady and Manning is basically personal preference. Brady fans will argue for Brady and Manning fans for Manning. They are both excellent QB's. Anyone who even came close to mentioning Favre or Elway in the same sentence with all of the above names has 0 clue.

To even suggest that Brady and Manning are not 2 or 2A is ludicrous. To say one is better then the other is also ludicrous.

 

[The Derski]

Most overrated player ever. It's not close. His records are all the result of playing well past the point he wasn't even serviceable any more.

He just threw the ball and hoped someone was open.

Name 20 QBs better than Favre.

 

[Breaker99]

Hey, if you're OK with being inaccurate more power to ya!

I was inaccurate on one thing, and that was that they have the same number of All Pro selections. You added another thing to make it look like I was wrong about that too, but I never compared MVP's.

Beat it, I am entitled to my opinion.

 

[Breaker99]

You mean like when Montana shit all over Elway in the SB 55-10? Yeah. High school player.

Elway is one of the most overrated players in the history of the league. He actually had BELOW AVERAGE YPA, passer rating and completion percentage for the years he was in the NFL. Not below average for a HOFer; below average for any QB from '83 to '98.

And Manning had a chance to establish himself as the best of all time, but he choked it away against the Saints, Steelers, etc.

Too soon to tell with Rodgers.

 

[SFNL]

Randall Cunningham was the best that I've ever seen in person.

Manning is second.

Brady is the best I've ever seen that couldn't get on the field in college.

 

[packfancjh]

The only way to compare QBs statistically is against the average like they do with ERA in baseball. I did a long study to determine the best QBs' YPA, completion percentage & passer ratings against the average. So looking at that and what they did in the playoffs

If you are going on what they did in the playoffs then Bart Starr is numero uno. 5 championships with a 9-1 record.

 

[cwood]

Favre isn't top 20. Manning, Rodgers, and Brady all shit on him.

Ahahahahhahaha! Please tell me you're not being serious. Not top 20... that might be the craziest thing anyone has ever said on this message board.

 

[packfancjh]

Most overrated player ever. It's not close. His records are all the result of playing well past the point he wasn't even serviceable any more.

He just threw the ball and hoped someone was open.

His 2nd to last year playing was his best statistical year ever and he brought MN to the NFC title game only to be derailed by cheaters so you can't say he was past the point of being serviceable anymore

 

[JDM]

They would have been better with Tavaris Jackson.

AD was the reason they were anything, not Favre.

 

[The Derski]

They would have been better with Tavaris Jackson.

AD was the reason they were anything, not Favre.

You sound like a complete crack head. Favre threw 33 TDs to 7 INTs that season. QB rating of 107.2.

 

[cwood]

They would have been better with Tavaris Jackson.

AD was the reason they were anything, not Favre.

4200 yards, 33 TDs, 7 INTs and 68.4% completion percentage. Do you even watch football?

ANYWAY, the answer for me is Peyton.

Edit - Jinx, AZ-Dbacks!