I don't need to listen to anyone but my wife and that's only because I like to stay alive. Seriously what ever is decided is fine just saw a issue and pointed it out before we had a huge incident later after picks have been made.
I missed the chaos, my two cents is the OP is the rules, cut and dried, unless there's a 100% consensus that a rule is added. That's how we've rolled for years, but I'm fine either way, it's just a game
Kinda seems like it already was a huge incident...
No sir we are just asking because there was confusion with Shane's OP. I was told by him no restrictions and if they played less the 5yrs then their position would be determined by most games played at that position. I tagged everyone and posted that and I am glad I did because it brought out the confusion before it became a huge issue. Thanks @Shanemansj13 for all your input in this debate. You have been very helpful. As helpful as me giving drafting tips.
But that wasnt put in the OP prior to the draft beginning so its pointless to even debate it.
I missed the chaos, my two cents is the OP is the rules, cut and dried, unless there's a 100% consensus that a rule is added. That's how we've rolled for years, but I'm fine either way, it's just a game
Dude I am not arguing I am just stating what Shane told me. That's fine players had to play 5yrs at 1 position, I am just stating what I was told.
But that wasnt put in the OP prior to the draft beginning so its pointless to even debate it.
Either:
1. It means players under 5 years are not eligible. OP doesnt say that
Or
2. It means that a player under 5 years just plays the position they have played the most seasons. OP doesnt say that.
So now we are fucked regardless
Not true, it does say it! If the player didnt play 5 years how could he have played a position for 5 years? If doesnt say anywhere in the OP that players who played less than 5 years will be used at the position they played the most. So 5 years supersedes the no player restriction rule.
How I understood the rule when I read the OP. There are no player restrictions as long as the player played 5 years at the position you draft him for.
Either:
1. It means players under 5 years are not eligible. OP doesnt say that
Or
2. It means that a player under 5 years just plays the position they have played the most seasons. OP doesnt say that.
So now we are fucked regardless
Not true, it does say it! If the player didnt play 5 years how could he have played a position for 5 years? It doesnt say anywhere in the OP that players who played less than 5 years will be used at the position they played the most. So 5 years supersedes the no player restriction rule.
How I understood the rule when I read the OP. There are no player restrictions as long as the player played 5 years at the position you draft him for.
Ok well there it is settled
So last clarification:
Players drafted 2012 or later are ineligible for this draft?