like it, but I've been pretty accurate thus far.
Bat Pence 3rd and Posey 4th. Put the speed at the top of the lineup.
Speed is a factor, but the bigger point, IMO, is that we should try to get Pence as many PA's as possible. With Pagan back and Panik hitting well, I, too, would want Pence to hit third. He hits LHP almost the same as RHP.
More than Posey?
This is my thought. Sure, you want Pence to get PAs, but not at the expense of Posey.
Nice dilemma to have. Either works for me, and you can certainly make a great case to bat Posey third.
But worth asking is: Do you want Posey batting with Pence on base, or Pence batting with Posey on base? Considering DP possibilities, and getting from 1B to 3B on a single, or from 2B to home, you may want Pence 3rd and Posey 4th.
Fun to think about, and it's a win either way. Just not Pence 5th - he's a better hitter than Pablo right now, esp against LHP.
Which prompts the question:
do you want Pence protecting Panda, or Panda protecting Pence?
Either way, as you say, a nice dilemma to have...until Belt starts raking again.
Ultimately, I'd like:
Oxy/Panik/Herk/MVP/Panda/BB9/Carbonell/Stamos
-- provided Carbonell is the real deal (I think he is).