5X5 MLB Draft : CHAT

[CitySushi]

@wlk3 and I have agreed to a trade:

Christy Mathewson, Trevor Hoffman and Al Simmons

for

Cy Young, Jimmie Foxx and Roy Face

 

[wlk3]

@wlk3 and I have agreed to a trade:

Christy Mathewson, Trevor Hoffman and Al Simmons

for

Cy Young, Jimmie Foxx and Roy Face

Yes

 

[CitySushi]

@Shanemansj13

 

[CitySushi]

@Nosferatu

 

[Nosferatu]

@wlk3 and I have agreed to a trade:

Christy Mathewson, Trevor Hoffman and Al Simmons

for

Cy Young, Jimmie Foxx and Roy Face

 

[Shanemansj13]

Yes

You sure? Hahaha

 

[Nosferatu]

So what this trade really is, is...


Jimmie Foxx & Roy Face for Al Simmons & Trevor Hoffman

I'm not going to veto this but why don't people offer me trades like this EVER!!!

 

[Shanemansj13]

So what this trade really is, is...


Jimmie Foxx & Roy Face for Al Simmons & Trevor Hoffman

I'm not going to veto this but why don't people offer me trades like this EVER!!!

I mean I freaking traded him basically straight up for Pedro and this is how WLK disrespects the guy I drafted

 

[MilkSpiller22]

So what this trade really is, is...


Jimmie Foxx & Roy Face for Al Simmons & Trevor Hoffman

I'm not going to veto this but why don't people offer me trades like this EVER!!!

I mean, to make it even worse... You can easily defend a trade under this format Trevor Hoffman FOR Roy Face...

So really, this trade is Al simmons for Jimmie Foxx

and both are righty bats from the 33 grouping

 

[Nosferatu]

Trade is posted...

2nd round pick for 8th round pick... lolzzz

 

[Nosferatu]

@femurov

 

[femurov]

@UK Cowboy

 

[Nosferatu]

I did text Femur

 

[Nosferatu]

Ooops

 

[wlk3]

Yeah yeah yeah well my pitching still rocks

 

[wlk3]

I’d like to say this... ironically Cy is normally ranked 2-3 pitchers group down from Christy... it’s always Johnson 1... then 2 lefties/Pedro/Rocket/Gibson/Christy... after that a group then someone usually Ritz gets cy... here Christy and Cy are equal... my pen Hoffman who’s normally a top 4 reliever at worst... Face is easily a round 15 or so pick maybe depending on how many drafters... however I get both and basically I didn’t get anything but Foxx for Simmons... interesting...

 

[tducey]

Back home now so next draft I'm in.

My favorite TV shows all-time are:

Seinfeld
The Simpsons (Up to 1998)
Three's Company
E/R
The Jeffersons

 

[Shanemansj13]

I’d like to say this... ironically Cy is normally ranked 2-3 pitchers group down from Christy... it’s always Johnson 1... then 2 lefties/Pedro/Rocket/Gibson/Christy... after that a group then someone usually Ritz gets cy... here Christy and Cy are equal... my pen Hoffman who’s normally a top 4 reliever at worst... Face is easily a round 15 or so pick maybe depending on how many drafters... however I get both and basically I didn’t get anything but Foxx for Simmons... interesting...

So you think the difference in Cy and Christy is the same as Hoffman and Simmons for Foxx and Hoffman? You lost one of the best hitters and power hitters of all-time. You upgraded on relievers but BP is not nearly as important as lineup and rotation. The difference between Hoffman and Face doesnt not equal Foxx and Simmons.

In an all-time draft...

Christy 2nd round
Hoffman 10th round
Simmons 15th round

Foxx 2-3 round
Cy 3-4 round
Face N/A

 

[UK Cowboy]

So you think the difference in Cy and Christy is the same as Hoffman and Simmons for Foxx and Hoffman? You lost one of the best hitters and power hitters of all-time. You upgraded on relievers but BP is not nearly as important as lineup and rotation. The difference between Hoffman and Face doesnt not equal Foxx and Simmons.

In an all-time draft...

Christy 2nd round
Hoffman 10th round
Simmons 15th round

Foxx 2-3 round
Cy 3-4 round
Face N/A

Contrary to popular belief, Tommy and I weren't around to see Christy and CY pitch...I always go by what the players and managers of an era have to say when comparing players. Both were great, but pretty much across the board Christy was considered more dominant, the only guy that was considered on a near level with Walter Johnson

 

[UK Cowboy]

Back home now so next draft I'm in.

My favorite TV shows all-time are:

Seinfeld
The Simpsons (Up to 1998)
Three's Company
E/R
The Jeffersons

Glad you are back!

Favs for me
Game of Thrones
24
The Office
TNG
Highlander
Deadwood
Justified