2 Question Keeper League Help

[redseat]

This is for my KEEPER League.... I have TWO questions:

1. Should I trade Matt Chapman for Alex Bregman?

2. Same person wants to trade me, Bregman, Murphy (Catcher), Aroldis Chapman and RP - Will Smith (Picks and Money - I believe)
- I send: Matt Chapman, Stephenson (Catcher) Gregory Soto and I drop Weneski

Do I do EITHER or both or neither or what!?

 

[redseat]

@femurov
@TREFF
@MilkSpiller22
@Sam Sportboy

ETC

 

[MilkSpiller22]

This is for my KEEPER League.... I have TWO questions:

1. Should I trade Matt Chapman for Alex Bregman?

2. Same person wants to trade me, Bregman, Murphy (Catcher), Aroldis Chapman and RP - Will Smith (Picks and Money - I believe)
- I send: Matt Chapman, Stephenson (Catcher) Gregory Soto and I drop Weneski

Do I do EITHER or both or neither or what!?

trade 2, the best player in the deal is murphy... so if you are getting him, it si worth it,...

but who do you have at catcher?? Murphy would be an upgrade to almost everyone...

Chapman vs bregman is very close... if i had either, i dont know if i would make a trade for the other... not a fan of lateral moves like that

 

[redseat]

trade 2, the best player in the deal is murphy... so if you are getting him, it si worth it,...

but who do you have at catcher?? Murphy would be an upgrade to almost everyone...

Chapman vs bregman is very close... if i had either, i dont know if i would make a trade for the other... not a fan of lateral moves like that

Haha yeah I guess # 1 really IS part of #2 since those two are in the trade for #2...

Currently my catcher IS Tyler Stephenson

I am in 2nd place right now and he is in 3rd and I am playing him this week.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Haha yeah I guess # 1 really IS part of #2 since those two are in the trade for #2...

Currently my catcher IS Tyler Stephenson

I am in 2nd place right now and he is in 3rd and I am playing him this week.

unless i am missing something... which i may be... trade 2 looks pretty good for you... I probably like Bregman more than Chapman anyway... But upgrading to murphy is HUGE...

 

[YourFriendGannon]

Unless it’s Tom Murphy...

 

[redseat]

unless i am missing something... which i may be... trade 2 looks pretty good for you... I probably like Bregman more than Chapman anyway... But upgrading to murphy is HUGE...

Sorry I shouldn't have put two options.. it is only ONE trade involving Bregman and Chapman... I should have just said, "is Bregman and upgrade over Chapman for a keeper league"

 

[TREFF]

@femurov
@TREFF
@MilkSpiller22
@Sam Sportboy

ETC

I'd love to help out, but I've been out of the loop on the MLB side of the world for about a decade now. Best of luck

 

[redseat]

I'd love to help out, but I've been out of the loop on the MLB side of the world for about a decade now. Best of luck

lol I alway do this! You are the FOOTBALL guy!

 

[Sam Sportboy]

@femurov
@TREFF
@MilkSpiller22
@Sam Sportboy

ETC

Lol..I gave up on Baseball cuz, well I sucked at it. If I was to give an opinion yer best bet would be to go totally opposite of whatever I had to say.

 

[TREFF]

lol I alway do this! You are the FOOTBALL guy!

A football guy...lol

I'd like to think I'm THE football guy, but I miss a lot of calls

 

[broncosmitty]

As a Chapman owner, I’d jump at the chance to get a third baseman with comparable production who isn’t feast or famine and won’t strike out 200 times.

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

I would take either of those deals. I like #2 better but if #1 is your only choice I would take it. See Broncosmitty above...

 

[femurov]

I'm not much help in baseball. Sorry.

 

[redseat]

As a Chapman owner, I’d jump at the chance to get a third baseman with comparable production who isn’t feast or famine and won’t strike out 200 times.

I accepted the 2nd offee

 

[Shanemansj13]

I would trade Chapman for Bregman straight up but since you gave an expanded deal that helps you even more...you take #2 all day.

I really don't get this trade for the other owner. Makes no sense.

 

[redseat]

I would trade Chapman for Bregman straight up but since you gave an expanded deal that helps you even more...you take #2 all day.

I really don't get this trade for the other owner. Makes no sense.

I accepted. We shall see if it works out for me or not. Hopefully it's a good thing but this year I was kicking ass prior to this deal. Not sure if I ruined a good thing or not

 

[broncosmitty]

I accepted. We shall see if it works out for me or not. Hopefully it's a good thing but this year I was kicking ass prior to this deal. Not sure if I ruined a good thing or not

Did you really get picks along with it too?

 

[redseat]

Did you really get picks along with it too?

I gave him my 2nd and 9th round for his 17th and 18th

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I gave him my 2nd and 9th round for his 17th and 18th

LOL... that would have been helpful to tell us before we gave advice...

a 2nd rounder would have likely changed my opinion.... because now, we would have been discussing actual keeper value... without the picks, keeper value was not really a factor, becuase you were getting so much more...