1990 - 2015 NFL Draft : CHAT

[Nosferatu]

so we give him a pass, but lets say that Manning is the worst playoff QB ever?? I am not trying to knock the guy... Just amazed that everything that goes wrong for him is just not his fault...

Ok, i'll post it again. Go look at points allowed in those losses. He has had 1 bad game where the Packers lost in the playoffs and that was last year vs the Seahawks and the Packers should have won that game. His QB rating in the playoffs is 101.0 i'll take that all day every day! Mannings QB rating in the playoffs is 88.5 and who said Manning is the worst playoff QB ever? John Elways QB rating in the playoffs is 79.7 and everyone loves him.

 

[femurov]

No drops for Femur.

I do have a drop. Drop Brock Marion add Roy Williams

Roy Williams is my safety on the all Undrafted defense

 

[Nosferatu]

Roy Williams is my safety on the all Undrafted defense

We traded remember?

 

[Mebert]

Its not just that... we talk about him like he is the best QB... We give excuses anytime he fails... he is 6-5 in the playoffs including a 4-0 SB run, and has never had a winning record in the playoffs besides for the SB... But nobody talks about him having playoff troubles...

Rodgers has the lowest ever Interception percentage while also having a top 5 TD%. This is not because he is a game manager, because he also has the 6th best yards per completion of all time. And with all of that he also is one of the most accurate QB's of all time. To me the only QB you can put over him is Montana, and I am not even sure he is not the best all time.

Aaron Rodgers is the football Jesus, put on this earth to score touchdowns.

 

[Mebert]

Aaron Rodgers is the reason that Elways bitching about he threw it deeper so the stats are mean to him holds no value.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Aaron Rodgers is the reason that Elways bitching about he threw it deeper so the stats are mean to him holds no value.

Top 4, IMO, no specific order

Montana
Marino
Brady
Rodgers

 

[Nosferatu]

My rankings
1. Montana
2. Marino
3. Rodgers
4. Young
5. Unitas
6. Brady
104. Elway

 

[femurov]

DE - Dana Stubblefield
NT - Jamal Williams
DE - Casey Hampton

There were a lot of guys I considered here, but most were mainly 43 guys. I considered doing a 43 and 34 defense, but then I remembered I am way too lazy to do that.

OLB - Joey Porter
ILB - Levin Kirkland
ILB - Teddy Bruschi
OLB - Shawn Merriman

It was tough for me to decide to go 34, but that's where the value was, imo. I considered guys like Keith Bullock, Keith Brooking and Peter Bouleware.

CB - Ray Buchanen
CB - Eric Davis
CB - Lito Sheppard
S - Merton Hanks
S - Mark Carrier

We raided the secondary pretty good. Roy Williams would have made this group a tad bit better.

 

[femurov]

My rankings
1. Montana
2. Marino
3. Rodgers
4. Young
5. Unitas
6. Brady
104. Elway

Wow... just... wow. I don't know where to start.

 

[Mebert]

Wow... just... wow. I don't know where to start.

I wouldn't put Elway that high either

 

[Nosferatu]

DE - Dana Stubblefield
NT - Jamal Williams
DE - Casey Hampton

There were a lot of guys I considered here, but most were mainly 43 guys. I considered doing a 43 and 34 defense, but then I remembered I am way too lazy to do that.

OLB - Joey Porter
ILB - Levin Kirkland
ILB - Teddy Bruschi
OLB - Shawn Merriman

It was tough for me to decide to go 34, but that's where the value was, imo. I considered guys like Keith Bullock, Keith Brooking and Peter Bouleware.

CB - Ray Buchanen
CB - Eric Davis
CB - Lito Sheppard
S - Merton Hanks
S - Mark Carrier

We raided the secondary pretty good. Roy Williams would have made this group a tad bit better.

I thought about everyone in that secondary aside from Sheppard.

 

[UK Cowboy]

I wouldn't put Elway that high either

Me either. Elway should be no higher than 125....

 

[Mebert]

Me either. Elway should be no higher than 125....

I have put a lot of thought into it, Elway can move above Joey Harrington

 

[femurov]

And it looks like the answer to that earlier Aaron Rodgers question is a resounding yes.

 

[femurov]

Are you people on Crack or are you just F'in with me?

 

[Nosferatu]

Me either. Elway should be no higher than 125....

I know but I didn't wanna piss off Femur...

 

[femurov]

And here I thought that I had found a nice little group of knowledgeable fans to have reasonable football discussions with...

 

[Mebert]

And here I thought that I had found a nice little group of knowledgeable fans to have reasonable football discussions with...

I am just messing with you, I like Elway, but I do not think that he is as good as his reputation

 

[Mebert]

And Elway the GM has been very good too.

 

[Nosferatu]

And here I thought that I had found a nice little group of knowledgeable fans to have reasonable football discussions with...

You have, now don't ruin it by telling us how great Elway was...