Let's end the Brady/Manning debate right. Now.

sonnyblack65 · Jun 26, 2019

megalodon30 said:
I'd be very surprised if they weren't friends. They're both the greatest of their era. No other QB could match these two at their best. Brady may be the goat, but Manning is certainly in the conversation of top 5 all time.

Both have a deep love and respect for the game. And because of that I think both of them respect the each other as quarterbacks and competitors. And both have to much clas to say, "yeah, I'm better than him."

Reminds me of Johnson-Bird rivalry not sure we will see it in the NFL for awhile

BostonBlackie · Jun 26, 2019

Bridgeburner said:
I've always looked at Manning as the best pure passer ever .........

Better than Marino?

PEOPLESCHICKEN · Jun 26, 2019

Rock Strongo said:
Tom Brady puts rivalry with NFL legend to rest

“Spoiler alert... we were friends this whole time. Always great to see you Peyton!” Brady wrote in the caption.

Gawd that is one awful suit

BostonBlackie · Jun 26, 2019

sonnyblack65 said:
Reminds me of Johnson-Bird rivalry not sure we will see it in the NFL for awhile

Except that Bird and Magic were on the court at the same time. That made it better IMO.

PEOPLESCHICKEN · Jun 26, 2019

Bridgeburner said:
I've always looked at Manning as the best pure passer ever and Brady as the best quarterback.

Yeah, not sure about pure passer. There were many Qb's that were better pure passers

Fouts
Marino
Kelly
Staubach
Elway
Montana

sonnyblack65 · Jun 26, 2019

BostonBlackie said:
Except that Bird and Magic were on the court at the same time. That made it better IMO.

True but they played different positions , so didn't guard each other/ LA/Boston def better match up then NE/Indy-Denver. Rare to see to QB's play each other as many games as they have and 2 best in this era

PEOPLESCHICKEN · Jun 26, 2019

sonnyblack65 said:
True but they played different positions , so didn't guard each other/ LA/Boston def better match up then NE/Indy-Denver. Rare to see to QB's play each other as many games as they have and 2 best in this era

It was reminiscent of the old AFL days

BostonBlackie · Jun 26, 2019

sonnyblack65 said:
True but they played different positions , so didn't guard each other/ LA/Boston def better match up then NE/Indy-Denver. Rare to see to QB's play each other as many games as they have and 2 best in this era

All good points. Manning scared the shit out me late in a game.

Nosferatu · Jun 26, 2019

The Kordell Stewart vs Tim Couch debate was much more intense!

sonnyblack65 · Jun 26, 2019

BostonBlackie said:
All good points. Manning scared the shit out me late in a game.

Scared the shit out of Belichic too, making him go for it 4th and 2 inside NE"s 30 with a 4 pt lead. Other coaches would have punted and put in hands of D, we know how that turned out

Brees#1 · Jun 26, 2019

williewilliejuan said:
Can you imagine how many rings Peyton would have won in the Patriots system? He probably wouldn’t lose twice to his little brother, either.

He would never lose to him, as he never did.

Dr. Strangelove · Jun 26, 2019

I lol'ed at the last line in that write up. "Almost certain" to be in the HOF. These two are first ballot locks.

NWPATSFAN · Jun 26, 2019

sonnyblack65 said:
Scared the shit out of Belichic too, making him go for it 4th and 2 inside NE"s 30 with a 4 pt lead. Other coaches would have punted and put in hands of D, we know how that turned out

One of BBs worst decisions ever.

NWPATSFAN · Jun 26, 2019

Brees#1 said:
He would never lose to him, as he never did.

The NFL and multiple television stations owe a debt of gratitude to Eli.
Otherwise NFL viewership would be worse than the View's.

Brady with 8 rings. No one is still watching football.

BostonBlackie · Jun 26, 2019

sonnyblack65 said:
Scared the shit out of Belichic too, making him go for it 4th and 2 inside NE"s 30 with a 4 pt lead. Other coaches would have punted and put in hands of D, we know how that turned out

I'm good at forgetting that one but you had to go ahead and remind me.

steelerssb · Jun 26, 2019

Rock Strongo said:
its funny how they were just, buddies, as fellow QB's the entire time while the debate raged on, and died.

Greatness respecting greatness. The rivalry never really seemed to go beyond the field and they probably had some fun with the debate.

rmilia1 · Jun 26, 2019

Mofo said:
Who was on top?

Rodgers.

Lolly · Jun 27, 2019

They should make a buddy cop movie in a few years dressed like that.

GNG · Jun 27, 2019

BostonBlackie said:
Better than Marino?

No.

GNG · Jun 27, 2019

BostonBlackie said:
All good points. Manning scared the shit out me late in a game.

Peyton or Eli?

Let's end the Brady/Manning debate right. Now.

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Dysfunctional Member

Well-Known Member

Dysfunctional Member

Well-Known Member

Dysfunctional Member

Well-Known Member

Faith, Hope & Love

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Once banned on CBS

Well-Known Member

New Member

What Me Worry?

What Me Worry?

Similar threads