Four Redskins make the Pro Bowl

[deanpet21]

I'm not allowing dad to do anything other than agree that he was right about sheriff. I haven't said a word about Williams. I won't be surprised if he also turns into a PB player. And this is a perfect example of he deserves more time to prove himself. So please don't put words in my posts I haven't written.

The difference between dad and dean is dad will admit when he was wrong. Dean also regularly uses opinions as facts. I've interacted with both for years. Can't say I've ever seen Dean eat crow. Have you?

Why would I have to eat crow when I was right about Long and Moses. When I stated my claim about TM is was when JG was healthy and slated to start at OLB. So if JG stayed healthy this year does TM have a double digit sack year?

Once again the Pro Bowl is a popularity contest. The best players don't always get in.

 

[deanpet21]

Dean declared Murphy a bad pick from the moment the pick was made. He declared Amerson a wasted pick who would never be a good starter in this league... from the moment the pick was made. Dean also declared Scherff not worthy of a top ten pick from the moment the IDEA was even mentioned that we could draft him at number five, and proclaimed it a mistake as he was not needed with the great and powerful Moses already on roster.

Thinking this is why Dean gets his chops busted so much on his opinion of these guys. Becaue by and large, the worst thing any of them has ever done was have the audacity to get drafted by the Redskins over the player he preferred.

Oh please, if you want to take a trip down memory road what about the time when you guys were sayin Scherff was an OT???? Forget about that Sharky!!!!

 

[j_y19]

Why would I have to eat crow when I was right about Long and Moses. When I stated my claim about TM is was when JG was healthy and slated to start at OLB. So if JG stayed healthy this year does TM have a double digit sack year?

Once again the Pro Bowl is a popularity contest. The best players don't always get in.

No, you stated you claim about Murphy draft day. Do I need to pull up the posts?

And are you stating now that Sherff should not have been voted in to the PB with this statement?

 

[deanpet21]

Dude, you said Murphy was a bad pick on his draft day, way before JG.

If he was such a great pick why sign the Troubled JG???

 

[deanpet21]

No, you stated you claim about Murphy draft day. Do I need to pull up the posts?

And are you stating now that Sherff should not have been voted in to the PB with this statement?

Right. I didn't like the pick just my opinion. So you are saying Scherff is a top four OG in the whole league???

 

[j_y19]

Right. I didn't like the pick just my opinion. So you are saying Scherff is a top four OG in the whole league???

Yup, I beleive so. So let me guess, you are now going to reference some blogger or PFF to "prove" your point? And if it is a popularity contest, why is Sherff so popular, I doubt he is even known outside the NFCE

 

[j_y19]

If he was such a great pick why sign the Troubled JG???

Because you can never have too much talent. That's not hard to understand, is it?

 

[deanpet21]

Yup, I beleive so. So let me guess, you are now going to reference some blogger or PFF to "prove" your point? And if it is a popularity contest, why is Sherff so popular, I doubt he is even known outside the NFCE

He is popular b/c he was the 5th overall pick in the draft. that holds water when they select the pro bowl players. Oh cmon Scherff is not their yet no way.

 

[j_y19]

He is popular b/c he was the 5th overall pick in the draft. that holds water when they select the pro bowl players. Oh cmon Scherff is not their yet no way.

Then why didn't Williams get in? He was 6th. Is that where popularity ends, with the 5th pick?

 

[deanpet21]

Because you can never have too much talent. That's not hard to understand, is it?

bullshit. Tm is taking full advantage of the JG injury and I'm happy he is having a good year. It just as much of a surprise to the Redskins that he is having this type of season. PS regressed this year.

 

[deanpet21]

Then why didn't Williams get in? He was 6th. Is that where popularity ends, with the 5th pick?

Williams had a solid year. He plays a 3-4 De. Unless your JJ watt those guys get overlooked b/c they are run stuffers too. You cant just look at sack numbers when you evaluate Williams. He is not an edge rusher he does a lot more. that is why he was a top pick.

Plus he is the reason why the Jets will move on from Richardson.

 

[Sharkinva]

Oh please, if you want to take a trip down memory road what about the time when you guys were sayin Scherff was an OT???? Forget about that Sharky!!!!

He was drafted as an OT... so was Zack Martin for that matter. Coaches decided it was best for the TEAM to move him inside as having him on the field at guard, and the red sea at OT was better than Scherff at OT and Long at RG.

 

[BeaReylo]

Because you can never have too much talent. That's not hard to understand, is it?

Especially with pass rushers. A team wants quality ones coming out the ying yang.

 

[gkekoa]

If TM was a bust, would he have double digit sacks?

If JG was healthy, what makes you believe he would have ten sacks?

 

[deanpet21]

He was drafted as an OT... so was Zack Martin for that matter. Coaches decided it was best for the TEAM to move him inside as having him on the field at guard, and the red sea at OT was better than Scherff at OT and Long at RG.

dallas never put Martin at OT when he arrived their. The Redskins put Scherff at RT and we all know what happened.

 

[j_y19]

Williams had a solid year. He plays a 3-4 De. Unless your JJ watt those guys get overlooked b/c they are run stuffers too. You cant just look at sack numbers when you evaluate Williams. He is not an edge rusher he does a lot more. that is why he was a top pick.

Plus he is the reason why the Jets will move on from Richardson.

Dean, one thing I love about debating with you is you are not afraid to to offer any rationale to defend you position at any time, even when it completely goes against a previous position you offered just seconds before. I see politics in your future, boy!

 

[deanpet21]

If TM was a bust, would he have double digit sacks?

If JG was healthy, what makes you believe he would have ten sacks?

If Jg was healthy I don't think TM would of seen the playing time that he is seeing right now. Are you calling TM a speed rusher?

 

[deanpet21]

Dean, one thing I love about debating with you is you are not afraid to to offer any rationale to defend you position at any time, even when it completely goes against a previous position you offered just seconds before. I see politics in your future, boy!

What? How does this go against my previous position?

 

[j_y19]

What? How does this go against my previous position?

That the PB is all about popularity?...but I guess not for Williams, he had real talent he was competing against.

 

[deanpet21]

That the PB is all about popularity?...but I guess not for Williams, he had real talent he was competing against.

It is popularity. When the Pro Bowl selects De's they look at sack numbers that's it. I don't what the hell they look at when they select OG's.