Your programs top 10 QBs according to you

[4down20]

No Ponder?

Best thing he ever did:

 

[KansasSooner]

1. AJ McCarron
2. Joe Namath
3. Ken Stabler
4. Jay Barker
5. Greg McElroy
6. John Parker Wilson
7. Brodie Croyle
8. Freddy Kitchens
9. Gary Hollingsworth
10. Mike Shula

11. Wayne Trimble - J/K, fuck you Wayne Trimble.

No Bart Starr? Damn, I would pick him over at least two on that list.

 

[KansasSooner]

Oklahoma:
1) Jimmy Harris '54-'56 25-0-0 2 NC's
2) Steve Davis '73-'75 32-1-1 2 NC's
3) Jamelle Hollieway '85-'87 33-3 1 NC
4) Jack Mildren, Godfather of the Wishbone
5) Josh Heupel '99-'00 1 NC
6) Thomas Lott
7) Sam Bradford
8) Jason White
9) Darrell Royal
10) Bobby Warmack

 

[obxyankeefan]

1. Michael Vick
2. Don Strock
3. Tyrod Taylor
4. Bryan Randall
5. Marcus Vick
6. Jim Drunkenmiller
7. Maurice DeShazo
8. Will Furrer
9. Bob Schweickert

Top 9 was a stretch. Not worth adding a 10th.

QBU

I would put Drunk On Miller at number 2. He took a average team and marched them all the way to a Suger Bowl win over Texas.

 

[Used 2 B Hu]

Texas Longhorns

#9 Alan Lowry All-Conf DB 1971 All-Conf QB 1972 1970-1972

That...is badass.

 

[blstoker]

Washington State Top 10

1) Drew Bledsoe 1990-1992
2) Jack Thompson 1975-1978
3) Jason Gesser 1999-2002
4) Alex Brink 2004-2007
5) Ryan Leaf 1995-1997
6) Timm Rosenbach 1986-1988
7) Jeff Tuel 2009-2012
8) Mark Rypien 1981-1985
9) Steve Birmbaum 1996-1999
10) Connor Halliday 2011-Present (he'd move up the list if he'd stop throwing picks)

 

[obxyankeefan]

1 Shawn Moore
2 Don Majkowski
3 Mike Groh
4 Matt Schaub
5 Dan Ellis
6 Aaron Brooks
7 Matt Blundin
8 Scott Secules
9 Scott Gardner
10 Symmion Willis

 

[bamabear82]

No Bart Starr? Damn, I would pick him over at least two on that list.

If you count his NFL days I'd agree, but I could also see leaving him off really. He really wasn't anything to write home about at Bama and was injured for a decent amount of time if I remember correctly (or read correctly, I'm not that old).

 

[4down20]

No Bart Starr? Damn, I would pick him over at least two on that list.

Outside Namath and Stabler, I only listed people from my era. Mike Shula is not the 10th best QB in the history of Alabama, but he is a top10 QB of my time.

If I had gone into the years prior to the 80's more, I still would have put other people ahead of Starr. Bamabino's list included them, but I took the topic to mean more about players you seen/heard play.

I only included Namath and Stabler because there is so much footage of them going into the pros especially combined with what they achieved @ Alabama. They are a bit before my time, but I feel I get a decent gauge of them.

Plus, I wanted to get a fuck you to Wayne Trimble in there, the reason I quit playing football as a kid.

 

[ElTexan]

#1 Chris Simms
#2 Sam Bradford
#3 Jason White

 

[WB1214]

It's always fun to see some of these names that I've never heard of from these other teams ad seeing different perspectives for certain teams.

 

[The Crimson King]

That team should have beaten TN in the '97 SEC title game.

yes, they should have.

 

[WhiteMamba]

Washington State Top 10

1) Drew Bledsoe 1990-1992
2) Jack Thompson 1975-1978
3) Jason Gesser 1999-2002
4) Alex Brink 2004-2007
5) Ryan Leaf 1995-1997
6) Timm Rosenbach 1986-1988
7) Jeff Tuel 2009-2012
8) Mark Rypien 1981-1985
9) Steve Birmbaum 1996-1999
10) Connor Halliday 2011-Present (he'd move up the list if he'd stop throwing picks)

Pretty good list.

I like Gesser a lot. I remember driving to Pullman and they had a giant poster of him on a billboard in the middle of nowhere on a silo. In response of course to the Joey Harrington billboard in Times Square.

I thought it was awesome.

I would have Leaf one or two though.

 

[Blackshirt]

1. Tommie Frazier
2. Dave Humm
3. Turner Gill
4. Vince Ferragamo
5. Scott Frost
6. Jerry Tagge
7. Brooke Berringer
8. Steve Taylor
9. Joe Ganz
10. Eric Crouch

Eric Crouch 10th. More like somewhere between #1 and #3 on that list in my book.

1. Eric Crouch
2. Tommie Frazier
3. Turner Gill
4. Scott Frost
5. Brook Berringer
6. Vince Ferragamo
7. Jerry Tagge
8. David Humm
9. Joe Ganz
10. Steve Taylor

 

[LvilleSooner]

[FONT=&quot]Statistically speaking w/ personal favorites;

Chris Redman
Brian Brohm
Stephan LeFores
Teddy Bridgewater
Johnny Unitas
Dave Ragone
Browning Nagel
Jay Gruden
Jeff Brohm
Eddie Rubbert
Hunter Cantwell – Honorable Mention[/FONT]

 

[Voltaire26]

Alabama seems to have developed a good number of quarterbacks ... and now for:

1. Tom Brady
2. Jim Harbaugh
3. Rick Leach
4. Benny Friedman
5. Chad Henne
6. Brian Griese
7. Elvis Grbac
8. Dennis Franklin
9. Denard Robinson
10. Boss Weeks

 

[pennstatenut]

Kerry Collins
Todd Blackledge
Chuck Fusina
John Hufnagle
Michael Robinson
Daryl Clark
Chuck Burkhart
John Shaffer
Tony Sacca
Richie Lucas

 

[Boise4Life]

[FONT=&quot]Statistically speaking w/ personal favorites;

Chris Redman
Brian Brohm
Stephan LeFores
Teddy Bridgewater
Johnny Unitas
Dave Ragone
Browning Nagel
Jay Gruden
Jeff Brohm
Eddie Rubbert
Hunter Cantwell – Honorable Mention[/FONT]

Oh LeFores was a freaking STUD. Just a little guy, but tremendous precision and tremendous athletic ability. One of the most underrated CFB QBs ever.

 

[oaknightshockey1]

1. Eric Crouch
2. Tommie Frazier
3. Turner Gill
4. Scott Frost
5. Brook Berringer
6. Vince Ferragamo
7. Jerry Tagge
8. David Humm
9. Joe Ganz
10. Steve Taylor

Flip Frazier and Crouch and this is pretty much my list. As far as the older guys I have to defer to people who had a chance to watch them. Frazier was the first I actually saw play.

 

[theSabanator20]

1. Kenny Stabler
2. AJ McCarron
3. Joe Namath
4. Richard Todd
5. Bart Starr
6. Greg McElroy
7. Brodie Croyle
8. Andrew Zow
9. Scott Hunter
10. John Parker Wilson