Your programs top 10 QBs according to you

[BigRedMoe]

Texas Longhorns
#1 Vince Young
#2 Case McCoy 2006-2009
#3 James Street 1968-1969 undefeated as a starting QB 20-0, NC in 1969
#4 Bobby Layne All-American 1946, 1947
#5 Major Applewhite 1998-2001
#6 Marty Akins All-American 1975 1973-1975
#7 Randy McEachern 1977, 1978
#8 James Brown 1994-1997
#9 Alan Lowry All-Conf DB 1971 All-Conf QB 1972 1970-1972
#10 Chris Simms 1999-2002

Are you drunk or high?

 

[WhiteMamba]

Texas Longhorns
#1 Vince Young
#2 Case McCoy 2006-2009
#3 James Street 1968-1969 undefeated as a starting QB 20-0, NC in 1969
#4 Bobby Layne All-American 1946, 1947
#5 Major Applewhite 1998-2001
#6 Marty Akins All-American 1975 1973-1975
#7 Randy McEachern 1977, 1978
#8 James Brown 1994-1997
#9 Alan Lowry All-Conf DB 1971 All-Conf QB 1972 1970-1972
#10 Chris Simms 1999-2002

#2

 

[Wild Turkey]

1. AJ McCarron
2. Joe Namath
3. Ken Stabler
4. Jay Barker
5. Greg McElroy
6. John Parker Wilson
7. Brodie Croyle
8. Freddy Kitchens
9. Gary Hollingsworth
10. Mike Shula

11. Wayne Trimble - J/K, fuck you Wayne Trimble.

Amazing how many Alabama fans always leave off Bart Starr. I mean Brodie Croyle, JPW, Shula and Freddie Kitchens over Starr?!!!! Crazy talk.

Oh and AJ is not above Stabler, Namath or Star no way no how. More rings does not make you better by default.

 

[outofyourmind]

Oklahoma:
1) Jimmy Harris '54-'56 25-0-0 2 NC's
2) Steve Davis '73-'75 32-1-1 2 NC's
3) Jamelle Hollieway '85-'87 33-3 1 NC
4) Jack Mildren, Godfather of the Wishbone
5) Josh Heupel '99-'00 1 NC
6) Thomas Lott
7) Sam Bradford
8) Jason White
9) Darrell Royal
10) all the rest

 

[TexasExes98]

Texas Longhorns
#1 Vince Young
#2 Case McCoy 2006-2009
#3 James Street 1968-1969 undefeated as a starting QB 20-0, NC in 1969
#4 Bobby Layne All-American 1946, 1947
#5 Major Applewhite 1998-2001
#6 Marty Akins All-American 1975 1973-1975
#7 Randy McEachern 1977, 1978
#8 James Brown 1994-1997
#9 Alan Lowry All-Conf DB 1971 All-Conf QB 1972 1970-1972
#10 Chris Simms 1999-2002

:confused2:

 

[4down20]

Amazing how many Alabama fans always leave off Bart Starr. I mean Brodie Croyle, JPW, Shula and Freddie Kitchens over Starr?!!!! Crazy talk.

Oh and AJ is not above Stabler, Namath or Star no way no how. More rings does not make you better by default.

Why thanks Auburn fan, for being so concerned about my top Alabama QB's. Want to know what I think about the best Auburn QBs? I don't.

I listed those I saw/heard play with the exception of Namath and Stabler. I wasn't trying to make the list that credible journalists would copy until the end of time.

 

[Wild Turkey]

Why thanks Auburn fan, for being so concerned about my top Alabama QB's. Want to know what I think about the best Auburn QBs? I don't.

I listed those I saw/heard play with the exception of Namath and Stabler. I wasn't trying to make the list that credible journalists would copy until the end of time.

Excuse me for having the honor of meeting Bart Starr several times and thinking he is a fantastic individual and should be included on any list of great players in college football period. When they made Bart Starr they threw away the mold, he is a credit to his school and the sport as a whole and you should damn well know who he is if you are going to follow Alabama football.

 

[charlie42s]

Texas Longhorns
#1 Vince Young
#2 Colt McCoy 2006-2009
#3 James Street 1968-1969 undefeated as a starting QB 20-0, NC in 1969
#4 Bobby Layne All-American 1946, 1947
#5 Major Applewhite 1998-2001
#6 Marty Akins All-American 1975 1973-1975
#7 Randy McEachern 1977, 1978
#8 James Brown 1994-1997
#9 Alan Lowry All-Conf DB 1971 All-Conf QB 1972 1970-1972
#10 Chris Simms 1999-2002

Ooops. I did get the years correct.

I actually figured I would get the reaction from #10.

 

[Codaxx]

Oklahoma:
1) Jimmy Harris '54-'56 25-0-0 2 NC's
2) Steve Davis '73-'75 32-1-1 2 NC's
3) Jamelle Hollieway '85-'87 33-3 1 NC
4) Jack Mildren, Godfather of the Wishbone
5) Josh Heupel '99-'00 1 NC
6) Thomas Lott
7) Sam Bradford
8) Jason White
9) Darrell Royal
10) all the rest

Come on. I know Heupel won a title, but over Bradford.

 

[TexasExes98]

1. James Street
2. Vince Young
3. Bobby Layne
4. Duke Carlisle
5. Eddie Phillips
6. Colt McCoy
7. James Brown
8. Peter Gardere
9. Major Applewhite
10. Christina Simms

 

[charlie42s]

1. James Street
2. Vince Young
3. Bobby Layne
4. Duke Carlisle
5. Eddie Phillips
6. Colt McCoy
7. James Brown
8. Peter Gardere
9. Major Applewhite
10. Christina Simms

If I had remembered Peter Gardere, he would have pushed Simms off my list.

 

[ckhokie]

1. Michael Vick
2. Don Strock
3. Tyrod Taylor
4. Bryan Randall
5. Marcus Vick
6. Jim Drunkenmiller
7. Maurice DeShazo
8. Will Furrer
9. Bob Schweickert

Top 9 was a stretch. Not worth adding a 10th.

QBU

 

[TexasExes98]

If I had remembered Peter Gardere, he would have pushed Simms off my list.

You know, the knock on Christina Simms was his record against OU and being the main reason why Texas did not play Miami in '01 for the BCS title. Other than that, he won a shit ton of games....

Gardere wasn't that great really, but is the only UT QB to go 4-0 against the Land Thieves. That receives a top ten ranking in my book.

 

[bamabear82]

1. Michael Vick
2. Don Strock
3. Tyrod Taylor
4. Bryan Randall
5. Marcus Vick
6. Jim Drunkenmiller
7. Maurice DeShazo
8. Will Furrer
9. Bob Schweickert

Top 9 was a stretch. Not worth adding a 10th.

QBU

Saw your favorite teams and forgot you were a Hokie.

I be like

 

[4down20]

Excuse me for having the honor of meeting Bart Starr several times and thinking he is a fantastic individual and should be included on any list of great players in college football period. When they made Bart Starr they threw away the mold, he is a credit to his school and the sport as a whole and you should damn well know who he is if you are going to follow Alabama football.

Oh, so anyone I didn't list I don't know who they are? There are plenty of other people I could have named from the 60's and 70's over the QB's listed, but the topic said "according to you", not according to the history books or some list people can copy off some website.

Thanks for being more worried about Alabama than your own school as usual. Go ahead, list the 10 worst QB's for Auburn as your best - bet I don't give a shit.

 

[charlie42s]

You know, the knock on Christina Simms was his record against OU and being the main reason why Texas did not play Miami in '01 for the BCS title. Other than that, he won a shit ton of games....

Gardere wasn't that great really, but is the only UT QB to go 4-0 against the Land Thieves. That receives a top ten ranking in my book.

 

[ckhokie]

Saw your favorite teams and forgot you were a Hokie.

I be like

Nah, just a bandwaggon soccer hipster faggot who updated his favorite teams to USA

 

[bamabear82]

Nah, just a bandwaggon soccer hipster faggot who updated his favorite teams to USA

 

[Bamabino]

Amazing how many Alabama fans always leave off Bart Starr. I mean Brodie Croyle, JPW, Shula and Freddie Kitchens over Starr?!!!! Crazy talk.

Oh and AJ is not above Stabler, Namath or Star no way no how. More rings does not make you better by default.

Starr's mark as a QB was made at Green Bay and not Alabama. He was a DB his final year at Bama.

 

[Bamabino]

1.Joe Namath
2.AJ McCarron
3.Richard Todd
4.Ken Stabler
5.Jeff Rutledge
6.Jay Barker
7.Scott Hunter
8.Walter Lewis
9.Brodie Croyle
10.Pat Trammell