- Thread starter
- #21
4 years does not = hall of fame career.
Even if he didn't get injured he could have burned out from the heavy workload he took in his first 4 years. There are plenty of runningbacks with equal or better 4 year stretches, what he did was not unprecedented. Over a 5 year stretch even Shaun Alexander blows Davis out of the water and if you shorten that to a 4 year stretch the numbers are not that different:
Shaun Alexander from 2002-2005:
6186 yards rushing 73 rushing touchdowns
Terrell Davis from 1995-1998:
6413 yards rushing 56 rushing touchdowns
Alexander had a mere 227 yards less than Davis, yet 17 more rushing touchdowns. What Davis did was not unprecedented and does not remotely deserve hall of fame consideration for an impressive 4 year stretch.
First of all you are misquoting me. I said arguably one of the greatest 4 year stretches. I never said it was the undisputed best.
That is your opinion of his HOF worthiness and not a valid reason to consider him overrated as a RB.
And I did state that having his career cut short is what is keeping him out of the HOF.
But what your comparison to Alexander lacks is the post season numbers Davis put up.
No RB can match his post season success in back to back Superbowl wins.