SportsHoopla Top 25 week 10 voting

[goDAWGSsicem]

I don't know yet... but my Dawgs will could be top 10 in my poll or atleast real close.

Like I said, I don't know yet, but how bad is it that a 2 loss team might creep into the top 10?

 

[uncfan103]

Clearly.

That list may be the worst I've ever seen. 1-5 isn't bad though.


Lots of problems with your list sir, but do you really think that Cincy belongs there?

I dont know how to judge them. At least Tennessee had Tyler Bray in that game, it makes their lone loss not as bad as if they would have lost to Tennessee yesterday. Their wins are just as good (nobody how bad they are) as South Carolina, Southern Cal, Texas, Georgia, and Auburn. Is a loss to one loss to Tennessee, with Bray, better than two losses? I easily could have slid SMU and Cincy below Texas and into the same group with Georgia, Michigan, and the three loss teams though.

 

[recon]

clemson @ 6 makes me

 

[uncfan103]

clemson @ 6 makes me

Their wins are just as good as Arkansas'...

 

[yeodonie]

1 LSU
2 Stanford
3 Okie Lite
4 BSU
5 Oregon
6 Alabama
7 Arkansas
8 Oklahoma
9 Clemson
10 VT
11 Michigan State
12 Houston
13 Penn State
14 Wisconsin
15 Kansas State
16 South Carolina
17 USC
18 Nebraska
19 UGA
20 Auburn
21 Michigan
22 Georgia Tech
23 Texas
24 Cincinnati
25 Southern Miss

 

[goDAWGSsicem]

I dont know how to judge them. At least Tennessee had Tyler Bray in that game, it makes their lone loss not as bad as if they would have lost to Tennessee yesterday. Their wins are just as good (nobody how bad they are) as South Carolina, Southern Cal, Texas, Georgia, and Auburn. Is a loss to one loss to Tennessee, with Bray, better than two losses? I easily could have slid SMU and Cincy below Texas and into the same group with Georgia, Michigan, and the three loss teams though.

Well UGA only has 2 losses both to ranked teams, and UGA is the one that took out Bray.

I can't see any scenario where Cincy should be ranked above South Carolina, Texas, Georgia, Michigan, Auburn, or Ohio State.

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

Well UGA only has 2 losses both to ranked teams, and UGA is the one that took out Bray.

I can't see any scenario where Cincy should be ranked above South Carolina, Texas, Georgia, Michigan, Auburn, or Ohio State.

I'd take Cincinnati over Michigan

Cincinnati has one loss Michigan has two

and neither have beaten anyone good.

 

[yeodonie]

drop Southern Miss and add Notre Dame at 25. Can't have a poll without ND in it.

 

[TheRobotDevil]

1. LSU (1)
2. Oklahoma State (4)
3. Boise State (3)
4. Stanford (5)
5. Alabama (2)
6. Oklahoma (7)
7. Oregon (6)
8. Houston (8)
9. Arkansas (10)
10. Clemson (14)
11. Virginia Tech (15)
12. Georgia (13)
13. Wisconsin (17)
14. Penn State (16)
15. USC (20)
16. South Carolina (12)
17. Auburn (19)
18. Kansas State (18)
19. Cincy (23)
20. Michigan State (21)
21. Nebraska (9)
22. Texas (25)
23. Michigan (11)
24. Southern Miss (NR)
25. Ohio State (NR)
Dropped: West Virginia (22), Arizona State (24)

+1

 

[ugafan6612]

1. LSU
2. Boise State
3. Oklahoma State
4. Stanford
5. Alabama
6. Oklahoma
7. Arkansas
8. Clemson
9. Oregon
10. Penn State
11. Georgia
12. Virginia Tech
13. Wisconsin
14. Michigan State
15. Nebraska
16. Kansas State
17. South Carolina
18. Georgia Tech
19. Texas
20. Houston
21. Ohio State
22. Michigan
23. USC
24. Southern Miss
25. Auburn

 

[uncfan103]

I'd take Cincinnati over Michigan

Cincinnati has one loss Michigan has two

and neither have beaten anyone good.

Georgias best two wins are Tennessee and Vanderbilt and they have lost two games...

 

[ugafan6612]

Georgias best two wins are Tennessee and Vanderbilt and they have lost two games...

...and Cincy has one loss against that same Tennessee team and has no "best wins"

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

Georgias best two wins are Tennessee and Vanderbilt and they have lost two games...

Florida????

they beat both Vandypants and Tennessee

Georgia's two losses are to top 25 teams while Cincinnati has a blow out loss to that Tennessee team

 

[uncfan103]

...and Cincy has one loss against that same Tennessee team and has no "best wins"

Transitive property doesnt work. UNC is better than Wake Forest. Wake Forest is better than NC State. But NC State is better than UNC. The SEC East is not very good. Louisville, NC State, and Pittsburgh are worse than Vanderbilt, Florida, and Tennessee, but not better enough to offset the fact that Cincy only lost one game.

 

[uncfan103]

Florida????

they beat both Vandypants and Tennessee

Georgia's two losses are to top 25 teams while Cincinnati has a blow out loss to that Tennessee team

Oops, yeah Florida is their best win.

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

Oops, yeah Florida is their best win.

better than your best win being a 25-16 win over Louisville???

and having a blowout loss to Tennessee.

not just a loss a blowout loss

think that right there shows Cincinnati doesn't belong

 

[uncfan103]

Florida????

they beat both Vandypants and Tennessee

Georgia's two losses are to top 25 teams while Cincinnati has a blow out loss to that Tennessee team

i bolded the reason i have Cincinnati ahead of Georgia.

 

[BoiseStateFan27]

i bolded the reason i have Cincinnati ahead of Georgia.

one loss because the best opponent they played is Tennessee

and they lost to them, big

 

[ugafan6612]

Transitive property doesnt work. UNC is better than Wake Forest. Wake Forest is better than NC State. But NC State is better than UNC. The SEC East is not very good. Louisville, NC State, and Pittsburgh are worse than Vanderbilt, Florida, and Tennessee, but not better enough to offset the fact that Cincy only lost one game.

I wasn't using the transitive property but more so saying Cincy got blown out to Tennessee...who is not good at all. And have not beaten anyone at all.

 

[uncfan103]

one loss because the best opponent they played is Tennessee

and they lost to them, big

And Georgia has two losses because the only opponents they have played are Boise and South Carolina...The teams are all bunched together, i do not think Georgia is better because they play in the SEC East. If Georgia played Cincinatti head to head i would definitely have the winner on top, but they havent. We dont know who is better. Lets see how the teams do next week when they both have games that could go either way.