SteelersPride
Well-Known Member
agreeedThere are 3 standout guys: Emmitt Smith, Marshall Faulk and Ladanian Tomlinson.
I still think I'd give the slight nod to Smith, though, even if he was by far the weakest receiver of the 3. LDT doesn't have the playoff chops or longevity. Faulk is lacking a bit in TDs and longevity.
Its a 1a, 1b, 1c kind of question for me, though. I think they are all on the same tier.
If we are using the literal sense of the word 'overall' then its LDT because he was pretty decent at throwing, too. I just think Smith wins on accomplishment and stats.